I've only seen one person so far mention doing an SMC reset. Apple support hasn't asked me to do one, I erased the SSD and reinstalled HS on my own.
But a clean install doesn't necessarily reset SMC. I'm 100% sure the clean install didn't overwrite NVRAM.
I’m still waiting a bit longer to pull the trigger on a 13inch 2018, you guys think it’ll be worth it? I can get it for around 2300/2400 CAD to get the 8th gen specs and some potential kp issues that hopefully will be fixed soon...or save 400/500 CAD and get the nontouchbar (basically 2017 model) they still sell to get a dual core but no kp issues?
2. Once it happens, it crashes again. (no matter what you do your best to fix it)
Just had a total KP that shut my iMac Pro down and went into a really slow reboot. The machine was NOT sleeping either. All I was doing was changing the desktop wallpaper on my second screen. 10.13.6 THIS HAS GOT TO GET FIXED!
View attachment 778423
Leaving the party so soon? I thought we were having fun in this thread 😛Maybe for some people but this hasn't been my experience. My 13" crashed on day 16 when it was asleep. I had a replacement delivered just over 2 weeks after the crash and in that time it hadn't crashed again. That means there were 2 weeks either side of the crash without problem. During the last 2 weeks before the replacement came I tried everything I could to make it crash and had no luck. It's a strange one. The replacement goes back tomorrow, too, despite being fine at the moment. I'm in no crazy rush so I'd rather fall back to my older 2015 work MacBook Pro for now and wait this out to see what happens. Everyone's different here but I really don't want to end up with a computer that crashes months after buying it (like the iMac Pro for some people) with no chance of a return within the 14 day window.
That said, I love the new MacBook Pro and this 2015 13" feels ancient now (and really slow for what I do). If there's a definitive fix in the coming months I'll almost certainly buy again. I might also be tempted by a new iMac instead if there's anything good coming to that line.
Leaving the party so soon? I thought we were having fun in this thread 😛
bingo....As an amateur following this thread, Im beginning to think that those of us who are casual or light users such as web surfing, e-mail, texting, etc. aren't seeing the problem because we aren't stressing the device. Those who are professional users and are attaching all kinds of equipment are getting the crashes and when they get a replacement the same thing happens because their use hasn't changed. It would be unlikely for the majority to have no problem and a few to be unlucky enough to keep getting multiple machines with the same flaw. Unfortunately that may mean all 2018 MacBook Pros are affected.
Some might argue that statement; it's looking like the bottom of the tech chain more and more to me.....lolBefore all of this, I was genuinely thinking, these guys must be really unlucky or plugging in some DODGY third party/aliexpress/shipped from china/back of a garage - peripherals. Bank Holiday in the UK today, you forget the rest of the world is still working, so we should be getting close to something tangible?
Mine has nicks in the aluminium along the keyboard. They stated the same thing, must have happened during shipping, I mean come on, you're going to blame UPS for a nick on the keyboard. Even packaging, I imagine these things happen there either, it's because you didn't pick it up on the belt as a defect, and some poor soul is going to accept this as 'okay'.
I definitely recommend extending your 14 days out mate. That's the first thing I'm doing when I receive mine, I would love to ride to 2022 without a fault, but I'm not leaving £3000 in the hands of hope and Applecare (which is awesome, but if it can be prevented in the first place i'll do that). But I'm worried about my replacement, after hearing about light bleeding.
When you start paying these prices you can be picky, you can return your device multiple times, you can ask for 30 days return period. It's not like we're buying hardware from the bottom of the tech chain #aliexpress
I lost (3) macs to this problem, just bought a Dell this week, switching to Ableton Live 10/Windows 10 rig. Nine years invested in Logic Pro gone... thanks for the post about Universal Audio, glad I stayed away from them.....I have reported this to Universal Audio quite awhile ago. Of course they are playing the “contact Apple it’s not our fault” game. Even worse, they are trying to insinuate that I have bad hardware. That’s when I told them that would mean I have had 4 bad machines in a row. Then I pointed them to this forum... 😉
[doublepost=1535469220][/doublepost]
I have had 4 machines... This is why when members here are asking if they should take a replacement, I say they are wasting their time.
Aaaand yesterday's update doesn't fix the sleep / wake issue 🙁
Just returned to my machine (hooked up to a Caldigit TS3+ and 2 4K LG screens) to find it switched off.
On boot there wasn't even an error to be seen.
*Sigh*
All that is left to try is the forced method of trying to copy over 30gigs.
I lost (3) macs to this problem, just bought a Dell this week, switching to Ableton Live 10/Windows 10 rig. Nine years invested in Logic Pro gone... thanks for the post about Universal Audio, glad I stayed away from them.....
bye, Apple, bye, Timmy.....
Huh? =)
I've formatted and reinstalled several times (as well as NVRAM and SMC resets) on the request of Apple Support if that's what you mean?
I have my MBP attached to an Apple Cinema Display, USB hub, and of course power. I don't know of that info help, but I've not incurred any KPs, the machine is always on, I don't put it in sleep, at least overtly. I'm using this as I use my other Macs, so I'm not treating it any different. My iMac is left on all the time as well.I’ve noticed that a majority of the kp’s happen when there’s an external display being used... has anyone had the same issues natively without displays?
the machine is always on, I don't put it in sleep
I don't prevent the sleep, I just don't engage it from the menu. As you can see the Prevent Computer from sleeping is NOT checked.if you did let it sleep
Interesting. Well, everyone should be able to use their computers in a way that suits their needs but this gets me wondering if you'd also have such issues if you did let it sleep, as most kernel panics mentioned here seem to be related to the MacBook sleeping. Ignorance is bliss in this situation, and it's great that you've had no problems, but I'd have to know by letting it sleep more, work and time permitting. 😉
Sorry just woke up. There is someone who posted sth here on how to produce an error every time. Basically you need to transfer around 20gb+ and it will bring on the kernel crash.
So by virtue of that, if I was to render sth overnight. I would wake up to a crash, I’ll try it tonight.
So is there any info or testing from those affected by the issue if the High Sierra Supplemental Update 2 fixed or at least improved the issue? We know that BridgeOS was updated by it, and the crash issues would fit the vague description of the Supplemental Update 2 about improving stability and the like (but so would a lot of other unrelated things). Has anyone already had a crash like that after installing the update?