I had the same problem with my first 27". It had the seagate hdd. It made the noise noted by many of the users of this forum. Grumbling pretty much. I ended taking that particular machine back due to other reasons ( screen flicker and video card failure). The 27" I have now has the western digital 1tb hdd and it is virtually silent. So there are quiet hdd's out in the wild. Just my 0.2 cents
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
27" iMac Seagate 1Tb HDD Noise NORMAL!!
- Thread starter frenchie0101
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Yes, but the way it is heard in the video is misleading. The loudness of the clicking appears to make the grumbling (in the background) seem less obtrusive in comparison. In reality, that's not the case. The rumbling heard in the background is very much a foreground noise in mine and entirely unacceptable. So while the video identifies the noise we're talking about, it doesn't reflect the scale of the effect.
Yes I understand what you are saying but this is due to my camera mic not being sensitive enough to capture a clear sound.
It's not easy to show it on video but as I stand here next to the iMac it is is definitely a very clear and audible sound.
I'm gonna return mine and hopefully get a WD. Let's see how it goes..
GREAT JOB, that is exactly the noise that I am hearing as well...
Agree with Sir Cecil, it is very noticeable when using the machine...
Good luck with an exchange, I think the WD drives are a shot in the dark... My exchange last night produced another Seagate...
For what it's worth, I just took delivery of a 21.5 Imac that has a Seagate drive and have not heard any grumbling thus far. I referenced that video clip posted earlier in this threat and can confirm that that sound is not present in my machine.
As I said above I'm not experiencing the noise issues with my i7's Seagate 1TB but that said I'm glad I didn't get a Western Digital.
I much prefer Seagate over WD for drive quality. My 24" mid-2007 iMac has a WD hard drive in it and it crashed. Fortunately I was able to have Apple replace it under Applecare. Unfortunately they replaced it with another Western Digital.
I have a 1.5TB Seagate Barracuda in an IcyDock Firewire 800 enclosure I've been beating the heck out of for a year and a half now and I've not experienced any problems with at all. Thank god for it or I would have had major data loss when the Western Digital in my other iMac died.
This is actually a concern of mine too. I had a couple of WD externals that were very poor and unreliable, while my previous experience of Seagate has been good.
Anyway, when I noticed my second i5 was beginning to "rumble", I was aghast. BUT, after another day and evening with it (after four or five days of silent operation), I have to say this second unit remains quieter than the horrendous first. Indeed, while the first i5 could be shown to anyone and immediately be heard to be faulty, I'm not so sure I could make such a convincing case for returning this one. Right now, I think the fear of it continuing to get worse, like the previous one, is the most worrying thing I could live with it as it is at present.
So I've decided to give it more time and if towards the end of my return period it is no worse, I'll likely end up keeping it.
I just ran the smart utility and my HD status shows FAILING! and when i checked attributes it shows this HD had 71 hours power on!! Also on line 190 highlighted in red shows it's value @ 62, worst @ 44, threshold @ 45
Found It
Sorry I guess I should have read through all of this forum before posting.I did find the type-its a seagate and there is no noise from the HDD except the odd time it downloads.
I've gone through 2 Seagate and 2 Hitachi HDDs in my iMac (27"), and let me tell you something, they ALL had the same noise. My first Seagate annoyed the hell out of me, so I took it to the Apple store and they put in a Hitachi instead, which made a much different sound, instead of the grumbling noise, it was more of a sharper scratching sound.
Then, I got my machine replaced, it came with a Seagate which also failed on me from the second I started the computer, so then I had a in-home repair and ended up getting a new Hitachi HDD.
I'm using my Hitachi HDD right now, and so far it's been great. The sound is still there, but it's very mild. I can't even hear it when I have my window open/playing music, which I always am. I'm just gonna have to find a way to live with it, or wait for SSD manufacturers to lower the price so I can finally replace this loud HDD and get on with a much quieter and better SSD.
It's a fact that 1TB HDDs are louder than any other. I haven't had the chance to use a iMac with a WD in it, but I'm sure it's just as loud
Then, I got my machine replaced, it came with a Seagate which also failed on me from the second I started the computer, so then I had a in-home repair and ended up getting a new Hitachi HDD.
I'm using my Hitachi HDD right now, and so far it's been great. The sound is still there, but it's very mild. I can't even hear it when I have my window open/playing music, which I always am. I'm just gonna have to find a way to live with it, or wait for SSD manufacturers to lower the price so I can finally replace this loud HDD and get on with a much quieter and better SSD.
It's a fact that 1TB HDDs are louder than any other. I haven't had the chance to use a iMac with a WD in it, but I'm sure it's just as loud