I'd just go with the single 2 GB stick to max out out one slot.It really depends if the OP is even going to reach the 2GBs with his current use. I think the bump from 2 to 2.5 is not a whole lot. If you are going to start swapping at 2, then you probably will be at 2.5 as well.
Samwise592: check to see how much blue and green is left in Activity Monitor.