Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

virginblue4

macrumors 68020
Original poster
Apr 15, 2012
2,027
700
United Kingdom
I pre-ordered my Apple Watch this morning, with my order going through at 8:03am (orders began at 08:01am in the UK). I chose the 38mm stainless steel version with the white sports band. Additionally, I ordered the Milanese loop separately. I also purchased AppleCare.

I was extremely happy that I got the order through and that I managed to get a delivery date of 24/04 - 8/05 and how smoothly the ordering process went for me. But then, my happiness started to fade after reading the forums.

Many people on this forum had attended their try-on appointments and shared their experience with the 38mm. Almost everyone said how small it was, many even cancelled and were prepared to lose their early delivery dates to wait until June just to get the 42mm model. This really worried me! Throughout the day, this is pretty much all I read on these forums.

So, I've just returned from my try-on appointment at my closest Apple Store. I had an appointment booked for 19:15, but turned up at 19:00. I had a quick look at the watches under the glass, including the edition and was surprised by, you guessed it, just how small they were.

Very quickly I was greeted and then introduced to a Apple Store employee who got my 'favourite' (the one I had chosen on the Apple Store app) up on his screen and grabbed the box which had 10 Apple Watch models in, a mixture of 38mm & 42mm sport and stainless steel models.

I should stress that I've been quite worried over the months about my small wrists and whether or not they would fit. My wrists are 147mm and yes, I am a man.

The first watch I tried on was the 38mm sport version with the white sport band (close to the model I ordered). The band fitted perfectly, plenty of holes either side of the one I was on, so could be tightened / loosened as required.

As soon as it was on my wrist, it just felt perfect. Smaller than what I had expected, but simply perfect. I felt the taptic engine (very cool!) throughout the demo loop that was playing.

I then tried on the 38mm stainless steel with Milanese loop (I've ordered this band in addition to the sport band) knowing that this is the exact model that I'll be wearing pretty soon.

The Milanese loop feels amazing! It really does feel like fabric, not metal. And it looks gorgeous too! For anyone who is worried, the magnet is extremely strong. Absolutely 0% chance of it coming off accidentally.

I turned the digital crown which has just enough friction it felt very high quality!

He then asked me if I would like to look at any further models just for a bit of fun. I tried on the 42mm stainless steel Apple Watch with classic leather buckle (sorry for the awkward angle in the photo, I adjusted it shortly after). It felt great. Great, but not perfect. It didn't have the same feeling as the 38mm model. It just didn't feel right. Don't get me wrong, it was lovely, the extra screen real estate was great, but I still preferred the 38mm. He even commented and said that it also looked good on my wrists (honestly it is smaller in real life compared to the photos- I know it looks ridiculous in the photo below).

I took this off and asked a few questions. I asked if I could change out the bands myself just to get a feel of how it works, and he was more than happy to let me. Very easy!

I took a few photos, played around with a few more models, thanked the guy and then left shortly after. A fantastic experience with a great employee. I've heard many were limited to only trying on 2 models, not my experience at all.

And now back to the 38m model. People have to realise that everyone has different tastes and different sized wrists. The amount of people saying the 38mm is for ladies, well that's just silly. It was perfect on my wrist and I'm extremely happy with the model that I chose.

So to anyone out their worrying about which size to go for, please go and try them out. Don't go by the photos, as they really are smaller in real life. And don't let anyone tell you what size to get, as they haven't got your wrists!

I am man who pre-ordered the 38mm model and am over the moon with my choice!

All of the photos below that show me wearing the Apple Watch are the 38mm model apart from the classic buckle which is 42mm.

c2739528aa1337af29e2d5034799a4cc.jpg
218f87da145033f6d34341857eb9e2a2.jpg
51975e175b0433faa6d365f7080a8ccb.jpg
7fe192e97c2443dd3d857db807c856df.jpg
b7c03f30d246b685722b75966e8dfaa2.jpg
9fcab62c3133e3235d889e177c3ba93d.jpg
af101b187c2e6f47e0b8fb958df7e3a2.jpg
 
Last edited:
The 38mm really does not look small at all. I have used the Apple Store App "actual size" comparisons and it looks like a nice size on my 190mm circumference wrist. The height of my wrist makes the 38mm look more in proportion and does not drown my wrist like the 42mm does based using the same test. I'm very glad I ordered the 38mm and as I got a 24/4 - 8/5 delivery date range. I will not change it to 42mm as I really prefer a more discreet look. I'll prob go try it on in store on Monday and expect to be pleased. I also tried that credit card text from another thread and I get " can choose either size" so I am confident I chose well.
 
38 mm is the way for me. I can't imagine I'll change my mind on trying them on tomorrow.

Hopefully my 38 mm silver sport with white band will be validated tomorrow. I want to try the silver sports watch with the Milanese loop and if it looks ok I'll go ahead and order that as an extra band.
 
Thanks for the pictures. My wrists are like yours and I ordered the 38mm SS with the Milanese band and black sport band. Torn on whether I should have gotten the black classic leather strap instead of the Milanese. My try on is tonight.
 
I have really small wrists, but when I tried on the 38mm it looked allot smaller on my wrist than on yours. It boils down to this: As long as your happy, then who cares what anyone else thinks.... Unless they bought it for you;)
 
Thanks, same here. I ordered a 38 SS Milanese, and have been agonizing. The 38 was a last minute decision. I got in at 12:05 and am in the first wave of deliveries, and would hate to go to the end of the line. I have had a Rolex Oyster for over 35 years, and the 38mm seemed comparable. I'm 5'7, 170mm skinny wrists.

Going to Apple store after work and hoping that I made the right choice!
 
Last edited:
This is proof that people just need to try them on. There are a lot of people online right now saying that 38 is just for women, and that is really not true.
 
38mm from a male here as well, and after my appointment, I'm happy with my purchase. I was nervous that I'd prefer the 42mm and have to push my delivery back, but I came out happy. I just wish I could've been lucky like you guys were and gotten a 4/24 delivery. I'm at 4-6weeks as of right now :(.
 
I went to the local Apple store a few hours ago and tried on the 42mm SS (Milanese strap). It did feel ok, I have wrists that are approx. 165mm (55mm width) and I thought it would be the one. Then I tried the 38mm with the same strap and it just sat better on my wrist and felt much more "personal".

Looks like I'll be sticking with the 38mm, but I might go to the store again a few times to be sure of it :p.

Note that I do wear a watch every day, some of them bigger than the 42mm :apple:watch. But it's all about how this watch felt, and the 38mm just seemed to be better (for me).
 
I pre-ordered my Apple Watch this morning, with my order going through at 8:03am (orders began at 08:01am in the UK). I chose the 38mm stainless steel version with the white sports band. Additionally, I ordered the Milanese loop separately. I also purchased AppleCare...
Thank you for posting your in-store review! I have smaller wrists around the same size as yours and am thankful I went with 38mm.

As others have mentioned it's all about personal choice and feel. Not just "male/female" sizes.

Thanks again!:apple:
 
I have similar measurements to you, OP. I'm relieved you stuck with the 38 -- and, going by the pics, you definitely made the right decision. It fits you extremely well. The 42 overwhelms your wrist.
 
Thanks for sharing the photos. I was questioning my order online since I went with a 38 but I'm glad I did.
 
I pre-ordered the 38mm at 3am. My delivery date is May 13-27.

The thing is, when I try them on at the store, the 38 seems too small. I tried them both on, walked away, and came back and tried them both on again.

I ordered a 42mm at noon that will ship in June.

As you can see from the pictures, the 42mm looks huge on my 155mm wrist, but for some reason, when I see it in person, I like the bigger one better. Maybe lack of sleep affected my eyesight.

I'm planning on keeping the 42mm, but that may change if the 38mm arrives to change my mind...
 

Attachments

  • thumb_IMG_0017_1024.jpg
    thumb_IMG_0017_1024.jpg
    164.6 KB · Views: 371
  • thumb_IMG_0018_1024.jpg
    thumb_IMG_0018_1024.jpg
    141.7 KB · Views: 395
Wow....your experience is almost identical to mine except I am female. I have 145mm wrists and went to try on a 38mm which I had already preordered. I had a great experience! The Apple employee I worked with was sensational and let try on 5 different watches. The 38mm fits me to a T and the Milanese band was very, very nice. I was a little worried that so much extra band would look bulky on my wrists but the band, even doubled up is extremely thin and light. I was also surprised at how comfy the sports band is. I tried on the modern buckle and also liked it, but the price is more than I want to pay.

Man, two weeks can't come fast enough....
 
I woke up at 2:55 am and pre-ordered the 38mm too...then worried all day it was too small after reading the forums. Went and tried it on after work...it's perfect for me. The 42mm just looked kind of awkward on my wrist.
 
I woke up at 2:55 am and pre-ordered the 38mm too...then worried all day it was too small after reading the forums. Went and tried it on after work...it's perfect for me. The 42mm just looked kind of awkward on my wrist.

I may end up keeping the 38mm as I doubt I am patient enough to wait until June. I should've ordered both this morning.
 
Great post. I have 150mm male wrists, and all the threads of people changing to the 42 look gargantuan to me. Very happily sticking with the 38 here too.
 
I tried on both and am torn. It's true. The pics and the feel are different. I may sell my 38 mm SS Milanese
 
I'm a man and I have absolutely no idea how many mm my wrist is, like most men. ;)
 
I pre-ordered the 38mm at 3am. My delivery date is May 13-27.

The thing is, when I try them on at the store, the 38 seems too small. I tried them both on, walked away, and came back and tried them both on again.

I ordered a 42mm at noon that will ship in June.

As you can see from the pictures, the 42mm looks huge on my 155mm wrist, but for some reason, when I see it in person, I like the bigger one better. Maybe lack of sleep affected my eyesight.

LOL, yes it does look rather large. :p
 
The 38mm really does not look small at all. I have used the Apple Store App "actual size" comparisons and it looks like a nice size on my 190mm circumference wrist. The height of my wrist makes the 38mm look more in proportion and does not drown my wrist like the 42mm does based using the same test. I'm very glad I ordered the 38mm and as I got a 24/4 - 8/5 delivery date range. I will not change it to 42mm as I really prefer a more discreet look. I'll prob go try it on in store on Monday and expect to be pleased. I also tried that credit card text from another thread and I get " can choose either size" so I am confident I chose well.

After attending my try-on experience, I used at Apple Store app again to look at the actual size models. They really look totally different in real life! Just a perception thing.

The 38 looks great on you. I got the 38 too.

Thanks :)

Thanks for the pictures. My wrists are like yours and I ordered the 38mm SS with the Milanese band and black sport band. Torn on whether I should have gotten the black classic leather strap instead of the Milanese. My try on is tonight.

How was your try-on experience?

Thank you for posting your in-store review! I have smaller wrists around the same size as yours and am thankful I went with 38mm.

As others have mentioned it's all about personal choice and feel. Not just "male/female" sizes.

Thanks again!:apple:

No problem :)

I have similar measurements to you, OP. I'm relieved you stuck with the 38 -- and, going by the pics, you definitely made the right decision. It fits you extremely well. The 42 overwhelms your wrist.

It's strange, in store it didn't overwhelm my wrist. But I agree, in the photo it definitely does.

The pictures still shock me. If you looked over my shoulder in the store, you would think that they are much smaller. Perception is a strange thing.

I agree, it's very strange!
 
Thanks for the great post! I'm a male and I've also been agonising over the 38mm (which I pre-ordered) and the 42, wondering if I made the wrong choice due to the bigger screen, battery life, etc. Seeing your pictures has cemented in my mind that the 38mm is definitely the right choice :)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.