Yes, I know the the iPod Touch and the iPhone are two different devices since one does have a phone component to it, but the reason I say a your better off with an iPod touch over an iPhone without Data is simply because of the financial standpoint. Why pay that much more just to have a phone feature (note: paying $199/299 would force you onboard to data. Paying $599/$699 would get you the phone) is just unreasonable for my point of view...