I'm upgrading my wife's phone from a 2G to a 3G (black 8 gig). She currently has an Agent18 EcoShield on it which has served her well. I also used to have an InCase Protector (the rubbery one) on my old 2G which I thought was fine and just a little tackier when removing from a jeans pocket. Anyway, I've been reading these forums and I have a good idea what the winner in this poll is going to be. But I wanted to ask in a poll. Please keep in mind that this is for my wife who will not baby the phone as well as I do and will be typically propping it up in a minivan drink holder and letting two 5-year olds play with it once in a while to keep them tame. Also, I have a BSE full body skin that I plan to at least apply to the screen (not sure about the back depending on the case selected). Here are links to each the primary candidates. http://www.agent18.com/productdetail/iphone-cases/iphone-3g/iphone-3g-ecoshield/89.aspx http://www.goincase.com/products/detail/slider-case-cl59055 http://www.goincase.com/products/detail/protective-cover-cl59051 Please let me know what "other" case you recommend if you vote that choice. Thanks!