Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
3GS Signal reception not as good as iPhone 3G?
- Thread starter Pagemakers
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
So is that the AT&T network is bad atm, the iPhone 3GS signal is shocking, or some people are getting ones with bad batteries and bad signals (requiring a replacement)?
I'm in Australia, and I am on the 3 Network, I want to buy an iPhone 3GS 32GB (unlocked), and get it working, but not if I'll have no signal? can I take it back if there is none?
Kind Regards
I'm in Australia, and I am on the 3 Network, I want to buy an iPhone 3GS 32GB (unlocked), and get it working, but not if I'll have no signal? can I take it back if there is none?
Kind Regards
I actually get significantly better reception where I live. Side-by-side, I have compared my 3GS to 3G phones in different areas and I get 3-4 3G Bar signal whereas the 3G gets 2-3 Edge signal.
It is likely variable based upon location.
It is likely variable based upon location.
I get zero bars now at my beach house, and with the 3G I got 3-4 bars most of the time on EDGE (no 3G out there). I am wondering if the EDGE chipset in the 3GS is much weaker than the one in the 3G. The 3G reception seems about the same, but EDGE is much weaker.
It really is a problem though. I'm wondering if I need to take my old RAZR with me now to use when I am out there, because I don't like being without a phone.
It really is a problem though. I'm wondering if I need to take my old RAZR with me now to use when I am out there, because I don't like being without a phone.
I having the same issue
my 3g was almost always 5 bars in my house the 3GS goes up and down I had it drop call etc. I might have to call the Apple store and go talk to them. so far this the only thing I am not happy with my phone..
my 3g was almost always 5 bars in my house the 3GS goes up and down I had it drop call etc. I might have to call the Apple store and go talk to them. so far this the only thing I am not happy with my phone..
I upgraded from the first gen and yes, I am getting better signal strength with the 3gs than I did with my 2g.
5 bars compared to 3 bars.
Seems slightly worse on Optus here in Australia. Finding it goes to GPRS more often. But it's not significantly worse enough to worry about, Optus was already plenty bad on the 3G. 
Can't tell any difference on Telstra's network, their network is amazing and it's nearly always full bars anyway.
Can't tell any difference on Telstra's network, their network is amazing and it's nearly always full bars anyway.
My 3GS signal is better then my 3G signal. At the moment, I have four bars on one phone, and full bars on my 3GS.
There is absolutely no doubt the 3GS has MUCH poorer reception.
I drove down the M6 from Manchester to Birmingham last night and I had 3G reception for about 2 minutes in the 90 minute journey.
Much of it had no data reception at all.
It's awful compared to my 3G iPhone.
Definately a bug.
Reported to Apple.
I drove down the M6 from Manchester to Birmingham last night and I had 3G reception for about 2 minutes in the 90 minute journey.
Much of it had no data reception at all.
It's awful compared to my 3G iPhone.
Definately a bug.
Reported to Apple.
I have 4 iPhones in my house. 2 3g and 2 3gs
The 3gs continually perform the worst no matter where I am in the uk.
For me I don't need any more proof and I stand by my statement that the 3gs has a poorer reception than the 3g. Unless of course I have TWO faulty phones.
The 3gs continually perform the worst no matter where I am in the uk.
For me I don't need any more proof and I stand by my statement that the 3gs has a poorer reception than the 3g. Unless of course I have TWO faulty phones.
Or maybe a simple firmware update from Apple will tweak the radio reception in the 3GS and solve your problems.
Which is exactly what they did with the iPhone 3g last year and a software update fixed the problem.
Let's hope the 3gs fix is not too far away.
I've had a 3g since day 1 and the performance of my 3gs radio reception on my new phone is blindingly obvious.
Let's hope the 3gs fix is not too far away.
I've had a 3g since day 1 and the performance of my 3gs radio reception on my new phone is blindingly obvious.
Suboptimal iPhone 3GS reception as well, though clearly part of it is AT&T's fault since the iPhone 3G had it's own signal issues here.
I'm expecting the BlackBerry Tour I have on order will have none of these issues.
I'm expecting the BlackBerry Tour I have on order will have none of these issues.
Anyone else in AUS have any feed back on how their 3GS reception is?
Is it more likely the 3GS has a flaw with it's radio transmitter, or AT&T is just really bad :O?
Should I wait a few weeks before buying the 3GS, if at all? currently just have a 2nd gen touch
Kind Regards
Is it more likely the 3GS has a flaw with it's radio transmitter, or AT&T is just really bad :O?
Should I wait a few weeks before buying the 3GS, if at all? currently just have a 2nd gen touch
Kind Regards
Another thing the 3gs does it sit there for ages with no signal at all.
Turn airplane mode off and on and bam, full signal and 3g.
Apple please sort this. I'm beginng to hate the phone that I've loved for the l past 12 months
Turn airplane mode off and on and bam, full signal and 3g.
Apple please sort this. I'm beginng to hate the phone that I've loved for the l past 12 months
I have upgraded from a year with 3G to 3GS. I regularily travel by train and I know where the black spots are on the journey for data connections which on the 3G goes from GPRS to Edge to 3g on the 02 network but with the exception of one area rarely had no signal. With my 3GS nearly half the journey shows No Signal. I have also noticed that the signal strength indicator often shows no signal in 3G or Edge but still holds the E or 3G symbol not sure if this is a 3.0 feature but my 3G never did this as it would switch to GPRS instead. I also agree when it jumps to no signal it takes a Long time to recover a signal. As previously said switching airplane mode off and back on resolves this No Signal time out. Not so happy so far with 3GS experience!
If you e-mail apple about this, do they actually reply :O?
If they would I'd just ask, whether it's the network, the phone, or a combo, I really want a 3G O_O hope they get some fix soon! beats my Nokia N95, heck a stick is more entertaining than it
If they would I'd just ask, whether it's the network, the phone, or a combo, I really want a 3G O_O hope they get some fix soon! beats my Nokia N95, heck a stick is more entertaining than it
Signal Reception is Inconsistent
I just bought an iPhone 3GS as my first iPhone. I've had signal reception issues since I first activated it. It will have 2 or 3 bars and then (while staying in the same place) it will go down to "no service". I've traveled a bit in the last week and reception will be 5 bars and a few minutes later go down to 2 or 3 bars. Obviusly the worst condition is when it goes from some bars to none. I called AT&T when I activated the phone and they said it was poor 3g coverage in my area, although the coverage map shows me in the best reception area. It looks like an Apple problem, especially since I'm not the only one experiencing this problem.
I just bought an iPhone 3GS as my first iPhone. I've had signal reception issues since I first activated it. It will have 2 or 3 bars and then (while staying in the same place) it will go down to "no service". I've traveled a bit in the last week and reception will be 5 bars and a few minutes later go down to 2 or 3 bars. Obviusly the worst condition is when it goes from some bars to none. I called AT&T when I activated the phone and they said it was poor 3g coverage in my area, although the coverage map shows me in the best reception area. It looks like an Apple problem, especially since I'm not the only one experiencing this problem.
