Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Michael73

macrumors 65816
Original poster
Feb 27, 2007
1,082
41
Is the MP '08 physically limited to 32GB of RAM or is 32GB just the limit because there *only* 4GB RAM sticks?

Anyone heard any rumblings about 8GB RAM sticks on the horizon that would fit into this machine?
 
Usually Apple's posted limits are due to what is available at the time of testing, however some are limited by chipsets. The Mac LCII was limited to 10MB of RAM even though you could install 12MB due to chipset, and the first MacBooks/MBPs were limited to 2GB due to the chipset, eventhough their 32-bit processors could use 4GB.

TEG
 
Wirelessly posted (iPhone: Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 2_1 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/525.18.1 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/3.1.1 Mobile/5F136 Safari/525.20)

I think that the largest stick that is ever going to be available is the 4GB. If an 8GB is made it will probably change the design of the RAM and not work in the current Mac Pro but this is just speculation on my part. Another thing to consider is the max RAM recognized by OS X. Is it 32Gb or is it more?
 
The 8GB DIMMS should work in the MP, but if you need more than 32GB in the near future it'll likely be cheaper just to buy a new Mac Pro which should have more slots, access to 16GB DIMMs and likely cheaper 8GB DIMMs.
 
Leopard can only address 32gb per computer currently on the desktop version.

So, 32gb is the limit for the Mac Pro for now.
 
Really? I thought the limit was much higher...

Yeah just wait till snow leoaprd.

"To accommodate the enormous amounts of memory being added to advanced hardware, Snow Leopard extends the 64-bit technology in Mac OS X to support breakthrough amounts of RAM — up to a theoretical 16TB, or 500 times more than what is possible today. More RAM makes applications run faster, because more of their data can be kept in the very fast physical RAM instead of on the much slower hard disk."

http://www.apple.com/macosx/snowleopard/
under the 64bit column.
 
(from archive.org)
This is what Apple claimed:
"The dual-core PowerPC G5 joins forces with Mac OS X v10.4 Tiger to enable 64-bit computation. With 42 bits of physical address space, the PowerPC G5 supports a colossal 4 terabytes (4TB) of system memory. Although it’s not currently feasible to purchase 4TB of RAM, the advanced architecture of the PowerPC G5 allows for plenty of growth in the future."

Hm.
 
(from archive.org)
This is what Apple claimed:
"The dual-core PowerPC G5 joins forces with Mac OS X v10.4 Tiger to enable 64-bit computation. With 42 bits of physical address space, the PowerPC G5 supports a colossal 4 terabytes (4TB) of system memory. Although it’s not currently feasible to purchase 4TB of RAM, the advanced architecture of the PowerPC G5 allows for plenty of growth in the future."

Hm.

The hardware is capable of supporting it, but the software, regular OS X 10.5, is limited at 32GB. Vista is currently limited to a more generous 128GB.
 
I thought it was 32GB using 8 DIMM slots and 64GB if the logic board maker installed 16 DIMM slots for these chipsets.

The 5000x was ...

• Supports up to 16 dual-ranked FB-DDR2 4GB DIMMs, that is, 64GB of physical memory in non-mirrored configuration or 32GB of physical memory in mirrored configuration.

The 5400 says ....

• Supports up to 16 dual-ranked FB-DDR2 8GB DIMMs, i.e. 128 GB of physical memory

Of course since we don't make use of all the available server options, we only use half the max memory due to the 8 DIMMs.

The new 5400 Mac Pros "may support" the 8GB dimms, don't know about the older ones.
 
I thought it was 32GB using 8 DIMM slots and 64GB if the logic board maker installed 16 DIMM slots for these chipsets.

The 5000x was ...

• Supports up to 16 dual-ranked FB-DDR2 4GB DIMMs, that is, 64GB of physical memory in non-mirrored configuration or 32GB of physical memory in mirrored configuration.

The 5400 says ....

• Supports up to 16 dual-ranked FB-DDR2 8GB DIMMs, i.e. 128 GB of physical memory

Of course since we don't make use of all the available server options, we only use half the max memory due to the 8 DIMMs.

The new 5400 Mac Pros "may support" the 8GB dimms, don't know about the older ones.

Both Mac Pros are capable of handling 8gb sticks as long as the fall down the correct fsb requirement of their chipsets. They both can physically handle 64gb of ram, but the OS will only see 32gb, and thus only 32gb can be used.
 
Both Mac Pros are capable of handling 8gb sticks as long as the fall down the correct fsb requirement of their chipsets. They both can physically handle 64gb of ram, but the OS will only see 32gb, and thus only 32gb can be used.

Hopefully Snow Leopard solves this.
 
Tradgedies said:
What could you use 32GB of RAM for? O-o

People were asking what you could use 1GB RAM for 10 years ago...

personally, i'd keep all of my programs loaded in that RAM...forever...for permanently 'warm' starts

as for what i'd do with the other 20GB, i'll have to find a particularly large photoshop file...
 
People were asking what you could use 1GB RAM for 10 years ago...

personally, i'd keep all of my programs loaded in that RAM...forever...for permanently 'warm' starts

as for what i'd do with the other 20GB, i'll have to find a particularly large photoshop file...
Hmm...Impatient I presume...I can appreciate that one. :D :p
 
I'm rendering stuff in FCP while web browsing and listening to podcasts, maybe running a WinXP virtual machine as well via Fusion. I'm 'only' working with 720p video, I could see 32 gigs or more being an absolute must if working with 1080p or 2K video, given whatever app you're working in can make use of it.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.