Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

lwilliams

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Nov 27, 2012
470
246
Athens, GA
IMG_3551.PNG
 
Just like with 4G, and 3G before that, and 2G before that, the speed you get will be very dependent on many factors, such as signal strength, distance from the tower, how many people are using that tower, what’s around you, and the equipment and network connection speed and type at the tower. Just because your phone says 5G doesn’t mean that you’re magically going to have 1G transfer rates. There are going to be areas where it’s faster and areas where it’s slower.

And frankly it looks like 5G may be even more finicky than 4G, not penetrating as far into buildings and requiring you to be closer to the tower.
 
Last edited:
On T-Mobile in Portland, OR I’m getting speeds that are sometimes slightly better but often twice as good or more than LTE in the same spot. I’ve never gotten excellent speeds on T-Mo LTE out here, usable certainly but nothing amazing, so for 5G to show such a marked improvement right out of the gate is impressive.
 
My phone is the 12 Pro Max.

I tried without 5G and with LTE I was still only getting about 21 down.

Back home, in Athens, GA, I usually get aroudn 80 -120 down on LTE. No 5G there yet.
 
In my area, i see maybe a 5-10% boost over what 4G/LTE speeds were. Not really worth it to keep 5G enabled, IMO.
 
Go outside, stand on your roof and see if there is a 5G mm wave tower that you can link line of sight.

Remember to point the right side of the phone that has the mmWave antenna around 360 degrees, unobstructed to see if you get a 5G signal.
 
And frankly it looks like 5G may be even more finicky than 4G, not penetrating as far into buildings and requiring you to be closer to the tower.
Not true. Only mmWave does not penetrate buildings easily because of the high frequencies but the LTE standard frequencies will perform the same.
 
Not true. Only mmWave does not penetrate buildings easily because of the high frequencies but the LTE standard frequencies will perform the same.

That’s good to know, although it doesn’t quite line up with what I’m seeing. Inside my house I have a good LTE connection, but no 5G connection at all. As soon as I step out of my house onto my front porch or back porch I can get a good 5G connection. Of course I don’t know if the LTE signal and the 5G signal are coming from the same tower. It’s possible that there’s an LTE only tower closer to me or something. This is with ATT.
 
Everyone concerned about speed tests should try something:
Do a speed test in the middle of the night when there isn't the network congesting that you usually get during the daytime. You may be surprised.
On TMobile, I am getting (during the day) anywhere between about 40 and 80 or so MBPS download on 5G. If I do the same test at around 3am, I routinely see close to 200Mbps.
So, it's frankly unfair to blame the technology when the problem is network congestion.
 
I haven't tried 5G yet because I don't have the SIM but my LTE surged from ~50 Mbps on my iPhone X to ~100 Mbps on my 12 mini. It all boils down to your provider tho, I'm getting those speeds with giffgaff (O2) - while SMARTY (three) was 4x slower in my area.
 
Not that fast
 

Attachments

  • 07EEF47F-F9E5-439E-856E-DF4D1F5723E3.png
    07EEF47F-F9E5-439E-856E-DF4D1F5723E3.png
    360.2 KB · Views: 74
That’s good to know, although it doesn’t quite line up with what I’m seeing. Inside my house I have a good LTE connection, but no 5G connection at all. As soon as I step out of my house onto my front porch or back porch I can get a good 5G connection. Of course I don’t know if the LTE signal and the 5G signal are coming from the same tower. It’s possible that there’s an LTE only tower closer to me or something. This is with ATT.
Could be different tower and could be different frequency.
Even if a tower emits LTE and 5G, they might not do it at the same frequencies.
 
On T-Mobile in San Francisco, I’m getting around 1.75x the speeds I had before, and more importantly, it seems much more stable.
 
Just like 5Ge was fake 5G, I think the carries show 5G even when its not running on 5G.
 
Funny thing, I stay in downtown Dallas and got 5G u/w right across street from AT&T headquarters …on Verizon. Surprisingly found 5G u/w coverage in way more areas than Verizon map says.
73585C19-23A2-4D5A-AB47-49CE89B13727.jpeg
46950B57-00CB-40B8-8C0C-44254F7BCAD5.jpeg
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.