Now I love surround sound in any form, been mixing to 5.1 for a couple of years, teach it out of Logic and ProTools with Dynaudio Air monitor rigs, blah blah...
There's a problem with it at home level, most punters (i use the term with affection) can't configure STEREO speakers properly. How many times have you seen a speaker on a shelf and one in a dog basket, or two speakers stacked together, or both behind the sofa cos the girl/boyfriend doesn't like the look of them
Configuring 5.1 etc. systems is still at a theoretical stage, yes we have models that work, but only in controlled rooms, nobodies living room is an acoustically accurate space unless it's built to be.
There are more problems to be created by poorly configured surround systems than benefits to be had, don't get me started on phase
BTW, the latest acoustic research indicates that LF sound is directional, not omni as mentioned in an earlier post, where you site the LFE speakers (not subwoofers remember, a different beast) is VERY important, but your room characteristics are far more important. If I can find the LF articles I'll post the URL's.
Quake 3 through a Pro 5.1 rig rocks
