Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Yep, agree all the way!! I especially like the idea of window snapping—and while there are third party services that you can run to make this happen, having it work natively would be really nice!
 
  • Angry
  • Like
Reactions: Gudi and sorgo †
+1 on window snapping.
for me only via keyboard commands like fn+arrow keys though. i wouldn't want my windows to snap to places when using the mouse


my personal full list though:

  • bug fix: drastically reduce the insane disk read / write behavior of most processes; SafariBookmarksSyncAgent, krernel_task, launchd, and mds_stores in particular
  • bug fix: Safari does not block all cookies consistently, neither with "block all cookies" enabled, nor in Private Windows
  • bug fix: sometimes Books and Preview aren't getting closed by CMD + Q (these are still visible in the Activity Monitor and Force Quit app)
  • bug fix: Terminal window losing some height after closing tabs with CMD+W
  • bug fix: trackpad pinch to zoom sometimes not working
  • App Switcher: selecting the Finder icon will open Finder, even with no Finder windows currently open
  • App Switcher: show all open windows for the currently highlighted app on top, without having to use the up or down key on it
  • Calendar: filter for individual state's holidays
  • Calendar, Year view: show full extent of events longer than one day just like in Month view
  • Calendar, Year view: use of the different colors for the events just like in Month view
  • Confirmation Dialog: allow keyboard to control more than just two options (tab or arrow keys + enter to switch between yes / no / cancel, etc.)
  • Dock: App Icons: option to selectively remove dead links from the respective recently opened files lists
  • Dock: show all open windows above when hovering with your mouse above an icon
  • Dock: toggle "hide / unhide" of app windows via simple clicks on the icons for both ways and not Option + click = hide / click = unhide
  • Exposé: integration of hidden and minimized windows
  • Exposé: show all the "recent files" while three-finger swiping down an app icon in the Dock, as if you would be right-clicking it
  • File Transfer Window: show transfer / download speed (+ size per default)
  • Finder: a way to directly enter / alter directories with a click on the toolbar / current directory shown
  • Finder: CMD + Q to restart Finder
  • Finder: get rid of those separation lines in Column View, which are only there when a mouse is connected
  • Finder: Option + Click on any folder = open in new tab
  • Finder: right-click option to create at least a new TextEdit file in the current location. bonus points if other installed apps like text processors, or spreadsheets could do this too
  • Finder: Shift + Option + Click on any folder = open in new window
  • Finder: show used / remaining storage capacity graph + numerical values on all volumes
  • Mail: push notifications even when the app is quit by CMD+Q
  • Mission Control: integration of hidden and minimized windows
  • Mission Control: less confusing / seemingly random placements of apps
  • Numbers: allow links to local files
  • Photos: truly separated folders so you don't need to have one huge single main folder cluttered that you have build your linking folders upon
  • Preview: improved handling, more options (full screen = default, different sorting options, etc.)
  • Safari: global privacy settings that will apply to all sites
  • Sidecar: should also work with Bluetooth disabled
  • Universal Control: should also work with Bluetooth disabled
  • Window Management: better "auto focus" on windows
  • Window Management: option for double click on the window header to maximize the window to take up the whole screen
  • Window Management: option inside the green button to maximize the window to take up the whole screen
  • Window Management: proper window snapping via keyboard arrow keys like it's done on other OS's for eons now
  • XProtect: allow manual scans of volumes, files and folders via right click option in Finder
 
7 ways to improve windows fast:

- Make it free (as in beer)
- Make it stable
- Fix DLL hell
- Give it contained apps like on macOS
- Make its mouse scroll behave naturally
- Focus it on productivity instead of gaming
- Give it a proper centralised Settings App

See, there is no perfect OS. They need to learn from each other.
 
What I've never liked about macOS and never really got used to it: that you may have one app visible yet the menu bar at the top may be for a totally different app. Say only Safari is open, but "Finder" (which has zero open windows) is in focus and the menu bar is for Finder. I often find myself going through the menu and not understanding why I can't find what should be there... only to realize this is not the menu for the app that I'm looking at. Windows solves this by giving each app its own menu, not sure how it could be better on Mac. But it annoys me.

Also Mission Control. I still prefer the old Spaces in a grid. You could just zoom out, see all your spaces, then do Exposé and see all your windows in all your spaces at once. There's no way to do that anymore (exposé only works on the current desktop, not all at once, plus there's no overview mode anyway).

Full screen apps. They suck. The slow ass animation, the inability to show the desktop if you're in a full screen app (seriously why???) and the way activating Mission Control while in a full screen app brings you to the leftmost Desktop for some unknown reason, and all this without even showing an animation to indicate that you've been yanked 5 desktops to the left.

In Finder, when you're in grid icon view, using the arrow keys doesn't wrap around. I hate this so much. You can QuickLook on a photo, then go "Right" to see the next photo, but once you reach the rightmost icon, that's it, it stops. You can fix this by selecting all icons and then doing QuickLook, but then it starts showing the very first photo. Maybe you're scrolling through 10000 photos and suddenly want to see one specific one in the middle, then the next one and so on. Can't do that.

App permissions in Security and privacy. Every time you install something it asks you to kindly go into Security and Privacy and just... figure out which handful of sub-categories you're meant to find the app icon in, unlock them, give it permissions, then restart the app. And then it sometimes still won't work for some reason. Like the Wacom tablet driver needs "full disk access" in order to control the mouse. Sorry but what the hell? Why do I have to know this? And every random week it will forget this and I have to do it again. I'm all for "security" but if that prevents me from using my computer, what's the point?

Oh and I'd love it if Time Machine had moved on from the Leopard days. Like, it could back up external disks to other external disks. Rather than having one single massive backup task of backing up disk A B C and D to disk E (which won't fit), it could keep track of backing up disk A to disk B, disk C to disk D, etc... There are 3rd party backup apps but they all suck for various reasons. Really today there's still no good way to back up if you have a bunch of external HDDs.
 
Click on an app icon in the dock to minimize and maximize like Windows. One of the things that annoys me the most about macOS besides proper window snapping.
 
7 ways to improve windows fast:

- Make it free (as in beer)
- Make it stable
- Fix DLL hell
- Give it contained apps like on macOS
- Make its mouse scroll behave naturally
- Focus it on productivity instead of gaming
- Give it a proper centralised Settings App

See, there is no perfect OS. They need to learn from each other.
Perfect example of whataboutism. We’re talking about macOS here, not Windows…
 
Perfect example of whataboutism. We’re talking about macOS here, not Windows…
We're talking about seven random things Windows users believe macOS might be lagging. This has nothing to do with actual grievances of Mac users. It all comes down to, I'm used to something else and I refuse to adapt. 90% of the complains against Apple Silicon Macs are of this category. And this Linus guy is a serial offender.
 
I'd hardly call Linus the best judge when it comes to looking at Linux or Mac OS issues! His bias against Apple and his inability to master the basics of Linux are well known.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Colstan
We're talking about seven random things Windows users believe macOS might be lagging. This has nothing to do with actual grievances of Mac users. It all comes down to, I'm used to something else and I refuse to adapt. 90% of the complains against Apple Silicon Macs are of this category. And this Linus guy is a serial offender.
Linus Tech Tips has an Apple dedicated channel, called Mac Address. It seems to be Linus' way of pretending to be unbiased. If you want in-depth coverage about the Mac and macOS, then that secondary channel isn't the best, but at least it isn't a barrage of negativity. On LTT proper, Anthony is usually platform agnostic, and when he has covered the Mac by himself, he is generally positive, yet here he's being shoehorned into an anti-Mac screed.

Linus himself is another matter, along with most of his cohort. His clickbait titles, "shock face" thumbnails, and open disdain for the Mac are constantly on display. He takes random shots at Apple, but I think he's salty because Apple has never advertised on his channel. Linus' company has gotten so big that he seems to care about his sponsors more than his viewers. Since every video they release starts with a 30-second "this is sponsored by" it's easy to forget that some of those videos are nothing but extended infomercials disguised as tech reviews.

I can't blame Apple for having no interest in advertising with his company, because he's always trotting another opinion piece going after the Mac, to the point where it's like clockwork. He knows his audience, and they eat up what he is peddling. That includes his overpriced nicknacks and backhanded digs at the fruit company. Slamming the Mac is cheap heat among PC partisans. It's the same reason that he is constantly "dropping" expensive hardware, for slapstick humor, because it's a simplistic way to get a reaction.

Linus appeals to PC nerds who lambast the Mac for being an expensive "toy", yet their primary argument revolves around having comparatively fewer computer games available on the Mac, while those same adherents are furiously typing up those comments using a custom muscle gaming PC housed inside an anime themed case. The irony of that criticism aside, all Apple Silicon Macs are quite performant with game titles optimized for Apple Silicon. That's unlike the garbage Intel iGPUs that are still shipped inside a great many Windows laptops and desktops; an albatross which Apple Silicon does away with now that the Mac's fate is no longer handcuffed to Intel's inefficient designs and archaic architecture.

There are legitimate criticisms about the Mac and macOS. I have many myself. However, I respect the opinions of other Mac users over some PC diehard who doesn't know the first thing about the Mac, and uses his substantial reach to preach to the PC faithful. Meanwhile, Linus appears to know nothing about Apple Silicon, macOS, or the platform in general. In the past, he refutes his ignorant bias because he owns an Apple Watch and is "literally an Apple customer", in his words.

Linus is the living embodiment of a Windows PC given human form. There's nothing wrong with catering to his audience, but when he attempts to stray into territory that he obviously has great disdain for, it does no one any favors, other than to stroke the ego of PC users who look down upon us Mac plebeians. If he were as open-minded as he claims, then he'd do a "Mac challenge" like he did with Linux, but that's not going to happen. His anti-Apple videos get too many hits for him to back off from it now. Ignorance is profitable, in this case.

Regarding people who are new to the Mac that are trying to adapt to macOS and the Mac experience, my advice has always been the same: don't try to make a Mac into a PC. Don't try to force macOS into behaving like Windows. Don't try to make Apple Silicon into an x86 PC. Learn to use a Mac as a new device and your experience will be much better for it. Window management is different, firmware boot options are far more limited but less esoteric, backup routines using Time Machine are streamlined, macOS has strong built-in security without needing third-party anti-virus, and some things are so easy that they aren't immediately obvious. Unlike Windows, macOS generally stays out of your way to let you get your work done.

When I am forced to use Windows, I don't try to make it into a Mac, I deal with the PC's strengths and weaknesses as they are. The same should be considered when using a Mac, but many people have never used a Mac in their entire lives, so the differences can be jarring. Everyone has been a Windows user, at some point in our computing existence, so the PC mediocrity is always going to be familiar regardless of which new color of paint Microsoft is using to hide the various ancient layers of Windows archeology installed on any generic x86 space heater.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gudi
I guess some people here can't accept that there are opinions other than theirs.
Please stop pretending that every criticism is "not enough adaptation". I use OSX for ten years, and creating new file from finder still will be faster, than opening specific app, creating new file in app, and then selecting path with save dialog with specific file extension.
I will use my devices as i want and optimize my workflows as i want, not as i "should" because of some platform fanatics.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: sorgo †
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.