this is why Android phones suck.
http://mobile.venturebeat.com/2010/...-steals-your-data-was-downloaded-by-millions/
http://mobile.venturebeat.com/2010/...-steals-your-data-was-downloaded-by-millions/
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
SECURITY ALERT: Android wallpaper app that steals your data was downloaded by million
- Thread starter dogie678
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I'm not sitting here saying that Apple goes through a seriously thorough review of every app that comes across their plate, but at least they say they do and I have something to fall back on. I'd be shocked if there weren't a crapton of apps doing this on Android.
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (Linux; U; Android 2.1-update1; en-us; SGH-T959 Build/ECLAIR) AppleWebKit/530.17 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/4.0 Mobile Safari/530.17)
He can post it anywhere he wants. I have both iPhone 4 and Samsung Vibrant, but mainly hang out at Macrumors. Still deciding on which phone to keep
Stay Tuned said:
He can post it anywhere he wants. I have both iPhone 4 and Samsung Vibrant, but mainly hang out at Macrumors. Still deciding on which phone to keep
I find it Ironic that this is not on any of the big name tech blogs yet but if this was on the iPhone you'd be hearing on everysite and ESPN.
its already on Techmeme, Appleinsider, Venturebeat, financial times, eWeek, Technologizer, Techflash, etc.
They also stole my entire contact database without my permission when I used a application called MyBackup. The application pretended that the backup is only from the phone to e SD card. But when I restored, everything was sent to the cloud, and not my phone. Luckily I didn't trust Android to use it for my eWallet, and accounting application yet.
They have no respect for privacy there.
They have no respect for privacy there.
I'm all for apple monitoring the app store for stuff like this and for apps that don't fun right, I just wish they would stop censoring.
I find it Ironic that this is not on any of the big name tech blogs yet but if this was on the iPhone you'd be hearing on everysite and ESPN.
I think the Internet would inevitably explode if it was on Apple's store. This will like just get a 10 second mention on tomorrows news. Maybe Google will offer security "bumpers" now.
I guess there are vested interest and co-ordinated attack against apple. They want to see Apple fail, so that they can go back to old virus ridden windows style world or even DOS days.
I've just done a quik check of permissions reqested on one of the suspected wallpaper apps and something does seem fishy:
Storage and Network communication permissions make sense (needs to write wallpaper to SD card and needs to download wallpapers) but the location and phonecalls one seems odd (unless the phonecalls was to quit the app once a call was initiated and the location was for analytics).
I thought I'd compare with two apps that genuinely have reason to access SMS/Contact info and the permissions requested are very different (Chomp SMS and Phonebook 2.0):
On the jackey wallpaper app there was no mention of accessing phone numbers, SMS messages or personal information.
This puts me off too:
They have something to sell and they have nasty stories of malware on Android.
All of it seems odd to me but one word of warning, always check the permissions requested before installing an app.
Storage and Network communication permissions make sense (needs to write wallpaper to SD card and needs to download wallpapers) but the location and phonecalls one seems odd (unless the phonecalls was to quit the app once a call was initiated and the location was for analytics).
I thought I'd compare with two apps that genuinely have reason to access SMS/Contact info and the permissions requested are very different (Chomp SMS and Phonebook 2.0):
On the jackey wallpaper app there was no mention of accessing phone numbers, SMS messages or personal information.
This puts me off too:
They have something to sell and they have nasty stories of malware on Android.
All of it seems odd to me but one word of warning, always check the permissions requested before installing an app.
"The app in question came from Jackeey Wallpaper, and it was uploaded to the Android Market, where users can download it and use it to decorate their phones that run the Google Android operating system. It includes branded wallpapers from My Little Pony and Star Wars, to name just a couple."
Except it isn't a single app, the dev has many wallpaper apps on there:
If you actually look into what you are installing, any insecurities are avoidable. The very fact that Jackey Wallpapers apps do not request SMS info means I will wait before worrying (not that I use a wallpaper app at all).
Contact theft isn't impossible on iOS either: http://www.appleiphoneschool.com/2008/07/24/aurora-feint-removed-from-app-store/