Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I'd like to see clarification that the :apple:Watch requires the use of TouchID via a compatible iPhone.

A single pin number isn't secure enough to give free access to 'all' your cards. :(
 
I've been wondering about that. Do we know if it'll work on the Watch if you don't have it tied to a 6? I know the watch has NFC built in, but I thought there was a component of the security system that had to be on the phone.

Or is this just another utilization of the 5s "secure enclave" for fingerprint storage? Because I've got a 5s and I'll tell you what, if that combination will work with Apple Pay, that alone will sell me the watch.

From my understanding the watch will enable Apple Pay for any connected phone. IE older ones too.
 
Excited

I'm actually pretty excited about this.

Sadly, we in the US have been left far behind by the chip and PIN model adopted in over 80 countries and in use for more than a decade in many.

When I travel to the UK, people there look at my magnetic strip cards from America like I just stepped out of a 1980s time machine, and shake their heads.

Even the cards in the US that are starting to get chips are just a poor copy of what the rest of the world is using. Our chip cards are "chip and signature" which is just a cop out.

With this push though, Apple stands to drive the next generation of more advanced payment options, since there are certain banking regulations forcing changes in 2015.

If they can grab some big retailers (and they already have quite a few) this could be huge. Maybe we can finally have a comprehensive payment system that is far more secure that the terrible and obsolete system we have now.
 
Sorry, Tokenisation is already standard practice outside the US - its one of the definition features of Chip cards.

Not to deny your comment, but could you please provide a reference? The way I read Visa's reference, it is more recent than chip cards.

But if there's evidence to the contrary then I'll gladly accept it.
 
What i would like to know is what are Apple's plans for the rest of the modern world? There are countries out there that have contactless payments for credit cards in place for quite a while now. Whats the hold up on allowing Apple pay there? e.g Personally, I'm talking about Canada.
Come one Apple bring Apple pay here. Its the only reason why ill go back to Iphones..
 
A matter of time until someone's finger is hacked off? And, didn't they already hack the touch-ID system?

You're right. We should just give up and stick with our current very secure credit cards.

Also, does this give new meaning to the phrase 5-finger discount?
 
As far as I can tell from reading a ton about it - I was going to just buy a Watch in order to do Apple Pay and not the 6 Plus but then I caved - it is indeed the case that an Apple Watch plus a 5S will enable Apple Pay, which implies that the Apple Watch has an NFC chip in it as well.

That's been my impression as well, but so far I haven't seen anything definite on it. Well, since I won't be getting a 6 this year in any case, I'll just hope that's true and look forward to the watch coming out next year. :)
 
The way I read Visa's reference, it is more recent than chip cards.
The framework is different. The actors differ slightly. The security methodology is not. I could link you references, but the good documents are behind paywalls I'm afraid.
 
I am still unclear how Apple pay will work.. Will Apple strictly disallow the feature to be enabled on non US iphones?
Or the setting will be there but simply wont accept non US bank credit card?

I NFC payment system didnt reply so much negotiations between banks, carriers etc... its the main reason why it never took off here in Canada even though feature was on most Android phones for ever.. But greedy cell phone carriers and "strict" banking regulation prevented it.
 
People thinking this will get rid of cash are delusional (that or drink too much Apple Kool-Aide). Apple Pay is just a convenience, not a currency replacer.

Agreed. This won't replace cash anymore than credit cards have. As for being a cashless society already, I probably use cash at most once per month. I can basically count the number of times I use cash per year using both hands.
 
Whats the hold up on allowing Apple pay there? e.g Personally, I'm talking about Canada.

Canadian banks and payment processor networks.

Until they embrace and implement the EMV tokenization technology that :apple:pay is using, you won't be able to use it.
 
Hey, how will refunds work on Apple Pay considering they don't have our account number?
 
Exactly! No portion of this is particularly "new", nor does it offer end users any real security benefits.

If you have a non-US issued contactless credit/debit card you have very similar technology in your wallet already.

Google and the NSA are based in the US.... and it was a joke.
 
A matter of time until someone's finger is hacked off? And, didn't they already hack the touch-ID system?

And didn't the article just state that is was the MOST secure system to date on this planet?
 
People thinking this will get rid of cash are delusional (that or drink too much Apple Kool-Aide). Apple Pay is just a convenience, not a currency replacer.

Who ever said that is was a currency replacement?
 
Replacing cash - no - replacing carrying your credit cards - hopefully.

Well, in a way it does. For me, credit cards/bank cards already replaced cash. So this is just an extension of that. I never use cash. Ever. Deposit my checks into the bank each week. Never see the cash. Cards are so much easier. This is going to be EVEN easier than cards. Can't wait.

----------

I'd like to see clarification that the :apple:Watch requires the use of TouchID via a compatible iPhone.

A single pin number isn't secure enough to give free access to 'all' your cards. :(

Pretty sure you can replace the pin with an actual password.
 
When I hear of Apple Pay, I think of bankers and investors that hold Apple shares trying to sell a "new" feature so they can offload their share at a higher price. Buy low. Hype the product. Sell high.
 
People thinking this will get rid of cash are delusional (that or drink too much Apple Kool-Aide). Apple Pay is just a convenience, not a currency replacer.

In the UK we've had contactless payment via our bank account cards for a few years now.
I rarely ever carry cash, every shop, self service machine or restaurant has a card machine.
The only time I have to go to an ATM to withdraw cash is either to pay for a taxi or... or... nope I nearly always use my card!
 
Until they embrace and implement the EMV tokenization technology that :apple:pay is using, you won't be able to use it.

Are you serious? Canada is lightyears ahead of the US in that department.
 
A matter of time until someone's finger is hacked off? And, didn't they already hack the touch-ID system?

You mean that convoluted system that required a perfect copy of the persons fingerprint and something like four hours of fabrication? I wouldn't really call that "hacked." By the time they got a dummy fingerprint made up, I'd have realized my phone was missing and locked it via iCloud.

Do you mean physically hacking off a finger or hacking off a finger or hacking off a finger..?
 
No, a merchant doesn't have to sign up for :apple:pay. All of this is done on the back-end, by the credit card processing networks and the card-issuing banks.

If a merchant supports contactless card payments (PayWave, ExpressPay, PayPass), they can accept payments from your iPhone 6.

Well, I'm skeptical. Were this the case, why would Apple have gone to all the effort to "sign up" Macy's, McDonalds, Panera and the others ?? It could just have said that Visa and MasterCard were signed up and everyone else came along for free.

But Apple did not say that. Maybe I missed something ?? I am under the impression that merchants do need some updated software in their own back office systems. But I may be wrong here.

p.s. I fully agree about the need to replace terminals before Oct 2015, and the impact of EMV terminals
 
Security is good, and this sounds like good security. I'm still a little bummed that you have to buy a 6 to use it.

This is one of the big reasons I decided to purchase the 6 even though I was very happy with the 5s. I love using square but have been concerned about the security, and PayPal want to debit my bank. I am really looking forward to Apple Pay. Hope it takes off well.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.