You're entitled to your own opinion, but from what I've seen the new one is far from a flop. Yes there are certain features that are missing but the majority of consumers that buy Apple's notebooks don't really care too much (I know that there are a significant number of "pros" that would disagree with me and that's why I also think that they should just drop the "pro" moniker on the MBP since it doesn't seem to serve the needs of pros anymore). It's just that on boards such as these, all you see are people complaining about problems. I guess it makes sense since if you think about it, how many people would actually make an effort to post about a product that met their expectations?
In addition, based on the history of Apple's redesigns for the MBP (or lack thereof), there is a good possibility that they will not update the cosmetics to a significant extent once nehalem comes in late 09. I'm not saying that this isn't possible, but I wouldn't be surprised if they just made it thinner, updated the internals, and left it at that. Perhaps they will offer a matte display solution. IMO, the new design isn't that bad and most "average" people I know think that, while the design isn't as revolutionary as the PB/previous gen MBP design was, it's still a pleasure to look at. It might look slightly more like a PC because of the black on silver but all in all, I think they did a satisfactory job.