@ OP calm down man it's all good.
Me and another forum member called our respective Apple Stores and were told that, since a number of people recieved e-mails for reservations but weren't entered into the system, they will honor the email as proof.
Now I know some trolls are seething right now, yelling at my post at the top of their lungs , "Liar! Fake!", but I kid you not.
I didn't ask how or why this would work out nor is it any of my business as a customer, but if left to conjure up my own solution, I feel the best and only practical way to allow this is to let the reserved customers get their phones (and keep their stocks untouched), but allow those with reservation emails to stay in the "reserved" line and pick up phones from
general stocks. This way, aside from an additional wait from people who arrived before, parties who reserved their phones are in no way injured by this move. I invite arguments against this, if possible

.
But as you said earlier, you sir will be lining up
extra early. The sooner the better has never been truer in this case. This move will allow us to stay in the "reserved" queue upon opening (if my theory is correct), but it will not allow us to waltz in at one minute before closing time and pick up a phone that no longer has our name on it, unless of course stock is for some reason still sufficient.
But then...we wouldn't need reservations, would we?
I suggest you call your Apple store and see if they are offering similar service. Better yet, bring in your printout the day before and have someone sign off on it (manager or something), so if someone is misinformed on the 24th, you'll be waived through.