Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
69,401
40,442


Apple's AirPods Pro 3 offer the first redesign of the popular earbuds and add dedicated fitness features, but how do they compare to the previous generations and should you upgrade?

airpods-pro-3-light-blue.jpeg

The AirPods Pro were introduced in 2019 as a high-end version of AirPods, offering a new design, touch-sensitive controls, and active noise cancellation (ANC). The second-generation improved ANC and introduced the H2 chip, Precision Finding, and much more. Apple refreshed it with USB-C a year later. This year, Apple debuted the third generation, featuring a new design and heart-rate monitoring. Each generation has added better sound quality and a range of new features.

The second-generation AirPods Pro have now been discontinued by Apple, but they can still be found for reduced prices at third-party resellers and second-hand. As such, some customers may be weighing up whether to purchase second-generation AirPods Pro for a reduced price or the third-generation version.

The different AirPods Pro generations many of their features, so should you consider buying or sticking with the second-generation AirPods Pro to save money? This breakdown also serves as a way to see all the differences that the new AirPods Pro bring to the table.

AirPods Pro
(2019)
AirPods Pro 2
(Lightning, 2022)
AirPods Pro 2
(USB-C, 2023)
AirPods Pro 3
(2025)
Optical IR sensors for in-ear detectionSkin-detect sensors for in-ear detectionSkin-detect sensors for in-ear detectionSkin-detect sensors for in-ear detection
Refined earbud design
Silicone ear tipsSilicone ear tipsSilicone ear tipsSilicone/foam ear tips
Three ear tips (S, M, and L)Four ear tips (XS, S, M, and L)Four ear tips (XS, S, M, and L)Five ear tips (XXS, XS, S, M, and L)
Force sensor controlsForce sensors and touch controls for volume adjustmentForce sensors and touch controls for volume adjustmentForce sensors and touch controls for volume adjustment
Mechanical pairing buttonMechanical pairing buttonMechanical pairing buttonCapacitive pairing button
Lanyard loopLanyard loopLanyard loop
IPX4 sweat and water resistant earbudsIPX4 sweat and water resistant earbudsIP54 dust, sweat, and water resistant earbuds and charging caseIP57 dust, sweat, and water resistant earbuds and charging case
H1 chipH2 chipH2 chipH2 chip
Bluetooth 5.0Bluetooth 5.3Bluetooth 5.3Bluetooth 5.3
2.4GHz connectivity2.4GHz connectivity2.4GHz and 5GHz connectivity2.4GHz and 5GHz connectivity
Lossless audio with Vision ProLossless audio with Vision Pro
U1 chip in charging caseU1 chip in charging caseU2 chip in charging case
Precision FindingPrecision FindingPrecision Finding (1.5x further)
Active Noise CancellationActive Noise Cancellation (2x stronger)Active Noise Cancellation (2x stronger)Active Noise Cancellation (4x stronger)
TransparencyTransparency and Adaptive TransparencyTransparency and Adaptive TransparencyTransparency and Adaptive Transparency
Hearing TestHearing TestHearing Test
Hearing AidHearing AidHearing Aid
Automatic Conversation BoostAutomatic Conversation BoostAutomatic Conversation Boost
Hearing ProtectionHearing ProtectionHearing Protection
Live TranslationLive TranslationLive Translation
Heart rate sensing during workouts
Lightning portLightning portUSB-C portUSB-C port
Compatible with Apple Watch chargerCompatible with Apple Watch chargerCompatible with Apple Watch charger
Up to 4.5 hours of listening time with ANC enabledUp to 6 hours of listening time with ANC enabledUp to 6 hours of listening time with ANC enabledUp to 8 hours of listening time with ANC enabled
24 hours of total listening time with ANC using charging case30 hours of total listening time with ANC using charging case30 hours of total listening time with ANC using charging case24 hours of total listening time with ANC using charging case


Overall, the AirPods Pro 3 offer a relatively significant upgrade over the previous generation with valuable enhancements across the board, such as better fit, longer battery life, and improved dust and water resistance. Users who heavily use their AirPods Pro may be able to justify upgrading to the third-generation model due to the wide range of improvements, but this will not be the case for all existing users.

Those who recently purchased the AirPods Pro 2 may not be able to justify upgrading to the AirPods Pro 3 at the current time, unless they particularly want features like enhanced ANC and heart-rate monitoring, or hope for a better fit. The AirPods Pro 2 continue to get new features such as Live Translation and share the same chip as the AirPods Pro 3; they are still a solid device in 2025.

Users who purchased their AirPods Pro in 2022 or earlier will almost certainly see more of a reason to upgrade, especially if the batteries in their existing device have significantly degraded and they want to transition to USB-C. First-generation AirPods Pro users, in particular, should consider upgrading. These customers will certainly benefit from the plethora of refinements that the third-generation model offers.

If you've been interested in purchasing the AirPods Pro for a while, now is still a good time to pick up the second-generation model for a... Click here to read rest of article

Article Link: AirPods Pro 2 vs. AirPods Pro 3 Buyer's Guide: Should You Upgrade?
 
Last edited:
The AirPods Pro 3 look like a very minor upgrade over the Pro 2. Especially if you use ComplyFoam tips like I do as I'm sure a LOT of the ANC improvements are coming from the better seal. I noticed a significant upgrade over the standard tips when I swapped to ComplyFoam.

I'll hold onto my AirPod Pros 2 until they either break OR the AirPod Pros 4 comes along with a new H chip.
 
I wouldn't necessarily classify this as a "significant" upgrade except for [possibly] the fit and heat rate sensing. I'm convinced ANC is subjective. Upgrades of any kind are welcomed, and when these have a sale, I'll likely upgrade myself. But significant?
 
The AirPods Pro 3 look like a very minor upgrade over the Pro 2. Especially if you use ComplyFoam tips like I do as I'm sure a LOT of the ANC improvements are coming from the better seal. I noticed a significant upgrade over the standard tips when I swapped to ComplyFoam.

I'll hold onto my AirPod Pros 2 until they either break OR the AirPod Pros 4 comes along with a new H chip.
I switched to those foam tips earlier this year and they're a game changer. Didn't hear any of the crying babies on a 12 hour flight a couple weeks ago (or the engine). ANC only matters to me when I'm listening to music or watching a show/movie, and when the volume is set to high I can't hear anything around.
 
The AirPods Pro 3 look like a very minor upgrade over the Pro 2. Especially if you use ComplyFoam tips like I do as I'm sure a LOT of the ANC improvements are coming from the better seal. I noticed a significant upgrade over the standard tips when I swapped to ComplyFoam.

I'll hold onto my AirPod Pros 2 until they either break OR the AirPod Pros 4 comes along with a new H chip.
Can you tell me more about ComplyFoam? I would like a better seal, comfort and fit in my ears so they won't slip out. I don't have that much of an issue with Apple's own tips, but it sounds like these are a must-buy to make my AirPods Pro 2 perfect
 
It will be interesting if the rumor mentioned last week about updated Air Pod Pro next year comes true. The H3 chip and Bluetooth 6 would be nice additions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gomichaelgo
Can you tell me more about ComplyFoam? I would like a better seal, comfort and fit in my ears so they won't slip out. I don't have that much of an issue with Apple's own tips, but it sounds like these are a must-buy to make my AirPods Pro 2 perfect
They are awesome. I’ve used them for over a decade now across different headphones. Best seal and they are extremely comfortable to wear.

I’d suggest buying them since they’re cheap enough and tying them out yourself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 211 and ingik
Especially if you use ComplyFoam tips
Apple tips last 3,000% longer. Aftermarket tips last months, if that. They are also of greatly poorer quality.

I bought a pair of Comply’s and Sedna’s and given the price, they were abysmal value. The Sedna’s were particularly bad with a life span of a month (the tips were severely misshapen after 30 days).

I find it pretty disingenuous when people tout aftermarket tips like they are a holy grail. Even Apple’s basic silicon tips last about 6 months. Longer of you don’t care about a perfect fit.

Apple’s foam tips look far superior anyway. It’s an insane world when Apple tips are CHEAPER than aftermarket ones 🤦‍♂️
 
The microphone setup is supposed to be improved as well. I'm curious if there's a large difference between the APP2 and APP3 on the latest firmware with "studio-quality" recording.

Don't need but want. :D
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.