I ended up with the Brother MFC5700DW. It’s a black and white laser printer and it does an good job and suits my work needs well. The print quality is crisp and fast via USB. The automated scanner takes up to 50 pages and does a decent enough job. You can set the dpi and scan to multiple different files. It also has a non-skew feature which straightens a scan that does in crooked.
So I guess I’ll be keeping this one.