Hahaha, I hear ya! I remember when I got my blue one that I ended buying 3 just to get the right one with no marks or anything. You'll dig the case though. Gets really nice and soft after some use and feels really nice. I clean my about once a month with leather lotion. Still looks almost brand new after 6 months, granted I don't use the case all the time. The lotion also gives my case an even softer leather feel which I really enjoy!
I really like the leather case. I never tried it previously as I love my silicone cases also. I finally figured out how to take off the silicone cases so not to cause the bottom corners to come loose and peel. My first two silicone cases - I pushed the bottom corners out when taking th case off the phone. Once I started pushing on the sides instead of the bottom edges, I had no further problems.
So a question for anyone out there that has both the Apple leather and silicone cases - do you see any difference in slimness between them? The specs are exactly the same but I truly think the black leather is noticeably thinner than the silicone case.