Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Tozovac

macrumors 68040
Original poster
Jun 12, 2014
3,047
3,249
Outside of working on spreadsheets or doing major word-processing on an iPad, how has using a mouse (trackpad) with your iPad been an amazing breakthrough for you that you now can't live without? I'm looking for a reason to purchase a keyboard w/trackpad for my iPad Air 3 instead of just a cover w/keyboard.

My Apple Smart Keyboard for my iPad Air 3 self-destructed at the seams at 3 locations after just 12 months of truly regular use. I just got it replaced under warranty and it's currently boxed up still; I'm debating selling it if I find a better alternative, but I like how it does not need charging and is "on" and ready for use instantly once unfolded, and I'm hesitant to go to a "regular" bluetooth keyboard as I hate the stalls and waits for pairing.

I'm curious to hear real-life examples. I've not been drawn to feeling like I need a mouse for my iPad, just like I've had zero interest in an Apple Watch so far (if I were still training for bike races, I'd be all over an Apple watch). But I'd like to be enlightened by the experiences of others.
 
I tested the Apple Keyboard (old aluminum BlueTooth and Magic Mouse I). Pairing is fine but the mouse disconnects if you don't use it for a while and it's a bit of a pain to reconnect. The MM1 also doesn't have scrolling and gestures and I'm annoyed at Apple for dropping that support.

I like the way they work (except for scrolling and gestures). Performance has been fine with these on my iPad Mini 5. I think that you have to get an opinion for every device as what you can say for one can't be necessarily transferred for another device.
 
I tested the Apple Keyboard (old aluminum BlueTooth and Magic Mouse I). Pairing is fine but the mouse disconnects if you don't use it for a while and it's a bit of a pain to reconnect. The MM1 also doesn't have scrolling and gestures and I'm annoyed at Apple for dropping that support.

I like the way they work (except for scrolling and gestures). Performance has been fine with these on my iPad Mini 5. I think that you have to get an opinion for every device as what you can say for one can't be necessarily transferred for another device.

Thanks, you confirmed that if I dislike the pairing pains, I might want to stick with the Apple magic keyboard, but -- what uses for a mouse/trackpad on an iPad have wowed you, if any?
 
I use both Logitech MX Anywhere 2S and MX Master 3 without any issues. They nicely switch from my docked laptop to the iPad Pro and back again. Also have the Trackpad 2 - vary my devices depending on want I want to do though mostly I use the iPad without one.
 
Thanks, you confirmed that if I dislike the pairing pains, I might want to stick with the Apple magic keyboard, but -- what uses for a mouse/trackpad on an iPad have wowed you, if any?

I'm a keyboard/mouse person. It makes it easier to do a lot of typing and scroll quickly through long pages.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigMcGuire
I use a Logitech MX Keys keyboard and MX Master 3 mouse. I have no disconnects at all. For both devices I switch back and forth between my Linux desktop and an iPad 7th generation (the Logitech devices allow for up to three devices). Switching to my Linux desktop (which uses a USB receiver) is instantaneous, switching back to the iPad (which uses Bluetooth) takes about 1-2 seconds before it's connected (once connected there are zero disconnects or problems).
 
  • Like
Reactions: pshufd
My job requires me to use a lot of web based tools that were not created with touch in mind and many of them have sub-par apps for iPhone/iPad. For those tools, I really need a keyboard and mouse--most of the time when I use the trackpad on my Magic Keyboard it's because I'm using one of those web based tools.

The other times I'm really glad it's there are when I need to edit, copy, paste, or move text. This was not a pleasant experience before the Magic Keyboard. I also find that the more advanced multitasking features in iPadOS, all of which I use daily, flow really smoothly on the trackpad and behave a lot like their macOS counterparts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marlon DLTH :)
Thanks so far to @BasicGreatGuy, @AutomaticApple, @spiderman0616, @Dave-Z, @pshufd, and @sparksd. What I'm reading so far tells me that the mouse/trackpad helps most for those doing productive coding/writing work (i.e., productivity work) vs. "taking in content." I use the heck out of my 2014 MBA for productivity but I do very little "productivity work" for hours on the iPad; I mostly just take in content on the iPad. So far I'm steering towards a simple keyboard/case for my iPad Air 3...
 
Before my MK, I tried both the Magic Mouse 2 and Trackpad 2. I preferred the MM2 before Apple started to refine input capabilities. I then preferred the Trackpad because it has more swipe functions than the MM2. That alone makes it a better tool than the mouse. I still think the mouse has better precision but the trackpad is better in almost every other scenario.
 
Before my MK, I tried both the Magic Mouse 2 and Trackpad 2. I preferred the MM2 before Apple started to refine input capabilities. I then preferred the Trackpad because it has more swipe functions than the MM2. That alone makes it a better tool than the mouse. I still think the mouse has better precision but the trackpad is better in almost every other scenario.

I've used the trackpad, MM and full-size, TKL and short keyboards. I have settled on Mechanical TKL + mouse as I run with two systems so I need the desk space for two KVMs. I like the trackpad but it takes up too much space in my workspace.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ejin222
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.