Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
  • Like
Reactions: ericgtr12
I like the idea of follow-up mode, provided it can be done while still being secure. Will be interesting to see what Apple comes up with.

I do get frustrated at times, having to do the "hey, Siri" wake all the time.

Agree it makes it more convenient but I still don’t trust Amazon or Google... or any other company whose main motive is to mine data for ad dollars. Not a fair trade at all... my data is worth far more than any digita assistant technology that’s not very smart.
 
Agree it makes it more convenient but I still don’t trust Amazon or Google... or any other company whose main motive is to mine data for ad dollars. Not a fair trade at all... my data is worth far more than any digita assistant technology that’s not very smart.
Excellent point. If Apple can protect our privacy in this regard, it would be a game changer for many people.
 
Also, after much discussion, they decided to replace the creepy random laughter with Alexa saying "Redrum! redrum!"
 
  • Like
Reactions: xalea
Agree it makes it more convenient but I still don’t trust Amazon or Google... or any other company whose main motive is to mine data for ad dollars. Not a fair trade at all... my data is worth far more than any digita assistant technology that’s not very smart.

I understand your point, but I'd argue that in this particular aspect, Amazon is much more like Apple than it is Google. Google doesn't sell anything except its users (yeah, I know they have some other arms to their company, but your eyeballs are the main product). Amazon sells a lot of stuff, both to end users through amazon.com, and to institutional players through AWS.

The value to Amazon of the echo products is in ecosystem lock-in. They want to make Echo a convenient front-end to spending more of our $ on Amazon products. In that sense, it's the same as Apple & Siri. Siri encourage Apple device and service ecosystem lock-in (only runs on iOS & MacOS, only *completely* works with Apple Music and iCloud).

So, ultimately, I think their motivations for collecting data are very different than google's. Not that that makes me trust them any more than google.
 
I'm not anti-Siri but really have never had a use for it on my iPhone so I just disabled it mostly because it comes up when I don't want to.

I use Siri on my watch to set timers and Siri on my iPhone when I’ve already got into bed and I can’t be bothered to grab my phone again to set alarms. That’s pretty much it. Occasionally I set reminders with her.

She’s actually incredible fast on Series 3 Apple Watch so I wish I had more use for her!
 
Last edited:
I think this is one thing people sometimes are missing in regards to Siri - getting the feeling Apple is enhancing it regularly. Somehow you get the feeling Siri‘s AI has already reached it design-wise peak...
 
Very useful. Been hoping for this since I got an echo. Using lights is a good example. Being able to say Alexa, turn on lights, set lights to 30%. Instead of having to make two separate requests is really nice. It sounds like it wouldnt be that big of a deal but it does get annoying, for me.
 
I think this is one thing people sometimes are missing in regards to Siri - getting the feeling Apple is enhancing it regularly. Somehow you get the feeling Siri‘s AI has already reached it design-wise peak...

Apple has been "enhancing" Siri since 2011, and yet about 75% of the time it still can't identify the correct person when I ask it to call someone from my contacts list.
 
hope google follow this. one of the most annoying things is when google doesnt understand you and you have to rephrase it, and say hey google all over again.

or the wife will say can you set an alarm for 730, and you say hey google set an alarm for 730. then she says, actually 745. so you have to say hey google cancel the alarm. hey google set an alarm for 745
 
So, ultimately, I think their motivations for collecting data are very different than google's. Not that that makes me trust them any more than google.

A well thought out post, but I'd like you to consider that the issue isn't just the danger of which company has the data - its that the data is out there in the first place. Eventually someone or something is going to come along and make use of it, most likely in a way that puts our liberty and privacy somewhere at the back of the back of considerations.
 
Excellent point. If Apple can protect our privacy in this regard, it would be a game changer for many people.

It is indeed an excellent point, and Apple making Siri comprehensive while maintaining privacy would be HUGE.

That said, the vast majority of use is simply not privacy critical. Who care's if Amazon knows what radio station(s) I listen to (via iHeartRadio), or when I turn on my lights, what temperature I keep the house, etc. What about trivia questions? Weather reports? Nope... and Nope!

Now, I made a decision to connect ONE (1) of my calendars to Alexa for testing purposes. That means Amazon *does* know what I'm doing, however I'm still not sure I care. It's not a work calendar so only lists things like family doctor appointments, haircuts, and other activities. Does THAT matter? Maybe, but to some extent we already post about these on Facebook so at the end of the day it's not a deal killer. Work calendar's - particularly with customer names - are a different story though. THAT could potentially lead to corporate espionage... though I still doubt it would occur.

Any other real-world use cases that would be a privacy impact?
 
hope google follow this. one of the most annoying things is when google doesnt understand you and you have to rephrase it, and say hey google all over again.

or the wife will say can you set an alarm for 730, and you say hey google set an alarm for 730. then she says, actually 745. so you have to say hey google cancel the alarm. hey google set an alarm for 745

Google home will accept two commands in a single sentence, so you can say: hey Google cancel the alarm and set an alarm for 745.
 
  • Like
Reactions: madeirabhoy
I understand your point, but I'd argue that in this particular aspect, Amazon is much more like Apple than it is Google. Google doesn't sell anything except its users (yeah, I know they have some other arms to their company, but your eyeballs are the main product). Amazon sells a lot of stuff, both to end users through amazon.com, and to institutional players through AWS.

The value to Amazon of the echo products is in ecosystem lock-in. They want to make Echo a convenient front-end to spending more of our $ on Amazon products. In that sense, it's the same as Apple & Siri. Siri encourage Apple device and service ecosystem lock-in (only runs on iOS & MacOS, only *completely* works with Apple Music and iCloud).

So, ultimately, I think their motivations for collecting data are very different than google's. Not that that makes me trust them any more than google.

Amazon sells products but they are also a marketplace for an enormous number of other sellers. Much like Google connecting people trying to sell products all over the globe to you via advertising Amazon is also trying to connect people trying to sell products to you all over the globe, they just continue on to a transaction. Both parties are trying to build profiles on you in order to make money helping merchants convince you to buy stuff.
 
Request #4 "...and don't reply with let me look that up on the web for you"
"I don't know what 'let me look that up on the web for you' means, but here's what I found on the web for 'let me look that up on the web for you'"
😡

😉
 
  • Like
Reactions: j_maddison and Sill
Siri needs this bad. SO annoying that I can't tell my HomePod to turn on two lights at once unless they're linked.
 
Actually, it appears we might be going more in this direction...


😉

But, at least we seem slightly ahead of this now...


...because Siri will at least answer us.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Aston441
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.