any cases similar to Seidio Innocase II?

I'm kind of sick of my Seido Innocase II and I'm looking for a replacement to use with my 3GS. I know the Incase Slider is very similar but I've read a lot of reports of it scratching the phone, paint chipping off the Slider, etc. Is there anything else out there that is similar? I want something that doesn't add much bulk, totally protects the bezel, and leaves all buttons and the headphone port uncovered. I know the ifrogz luxe is close but it doesn't provide total bezel protection. The iskin solo is nice too but I don't like that it covers the power and volume buttons. Am I missing anything?

 

The EcoShield looks pretty nice but it looks like it might be a bit too bulky.

 

I'm basically just kind of sick of it but it also seems to have scratched the bezel on my old 3G a bit. I can't say with 100% certainty that the case caused the scratches (could have just been dust and dirt getting trapped between the phone and the case), but others have reported the same thing. I also don't like the hole in the back that exposes the Apple logo. I think it looks ugly and it's just another way for dust and dirt to get in. Other than the hole in the back, I like the design of the case itself - I just want something that's a bit nicer and just as thin, if not thinner.