I currently work as part time video/photographer with some software development and website design. Taking this in account is there any downside in running non-ECC in my Pro?
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Any downside to running non-ECC ram
- Thread starter beto2k7
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
You'd be fine with non-ECC for the usage you've listed from a general standpoint. 🙂
What kind of RAM are you currently running, and where did it come from (UDIMM's or RDIMM's, and is it OEM or 3rd party)?
I ask, as there's a strong chance you won't be able to mix it (IIRC, some have had success mixing non-ECC with Unbuffered ECC, but in the case of early 4GB DDR3 UDIMM sticks from OWC, it won't, nor would it mix with Registered ECC).
What kind of RAM are you currently running, and where did it come from (UDIMM's or RDIMM's, and is it OEM or 3rd party)?
I ask, as there's a strong chance you won't be able to mix it (IIRC, some have had success mixing non-ECC with Unbuffered ECC, but in the case of early 4GB DDR3 UDIMM sticks from OWC, it won't, nor would it mix with Registered ECC).
I edited it a bit for clarification, and it posted after you did. So you might want to take a look. 😉
Right now I'm running on loaned 24 GB of Apple branded ram which I'll have to return in a couple days because the owner is coming back from a trip and so I would have to go back to my stock 6 GB (which i dont think I would be able to do hehehe) So I checked prices with a local retailer and made a good offer on 6x4GB 1066 Mhz CL7 non-ECC ram which I'm gonna be using to replace the stock 6x1GB ECC so no mixing there.
Not giving it back would just be cruel. And maybe even get yourself shot. 😱 😛
That will work then. 😀
Nope, you need FB-DIMMs in that machine, anyone with a '06, '07, or '08 is stuck with FB ram 🙁
When is it not okay to use non-ECC memory? I have 3GB in my 2009 Mac Pro which I use for Aperture, Photoshop and Plex. Is it okay to use non-ECC memory in it? What does it actually do? I was thinking of going to 12 GB.
You'd be fine running non-ECC memory for your listed software usage. 🙂
Take a look at the Error detection and correction page on wiki to see what it does and when/why it's needed (think mission critical use that cannot withstand any errors, such as recursive algorithms, which would can be found in scientific/engineering modeling/simulation software for example).
Would it be ok to use non-ecc memory for the Handbrake usage?
Also, 1333MHz non-ecc in 2009 Mac Pro? Eventually, I would like to change firmware to 5.1 and swap the processors to 6-cores, so would 1333 non-ecc ram work with my current one (2.26 8 core)?
Thanks
CaptainChunk
macrumors 68020
Of course. Handbrake (and video encoding in general) doesn't really benefit from ECC RAM.
I could be wrong, but I think the majority of the reason why Mac Pros continue to use ECC RAM is that Apple goes by Intel specifications on reference designs and Xeon workstation/server boards have historically specified ECC memory modules. Someone else can probably elaborate on that.
Just keep in mind that you can't mix ECC and non-ECC modules. If you decide to to go non-ECC, you'll have to pull the ECC ones out.
Thank you so much for your quick response!!! Yes, I was planning on removing my stock ram and trade it in at OWC. But, how about the second part of my question, would 1333Mhz non-ecc ram be ok to use in 2009 Mac Pro?
Yes.
It can step down if need be (2009 firmware doesn't support 1333MHz, but will if you flash it and have a CPU that supports 1333MHz memory).
ActionableMango
macrumors G3
This thread implies that using non-ECC ram without a temperature sensor will cause the MP to spin up the fans.
https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1004548/
I have not found verification one way or the other.
Back when I researched this, what I was able to determine was that nearly all if not all ECC ram includes the temperature sensor. Some non-ECC ram also have the temperature sensor, although this tended to be expensive stuff aimed at overclockers for hard core gaming rigs.
On a positive note, ECC RAM is supposedly 3% slower, so if you use non-ECC ram you're system might run ever so slightly faster, but probably not noticeably so.
https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1004548/
I have not found verification one way or the other.
Back when I researched this, what I was able to determine was that nearly all if not all ECC ram includes the temperature sensor. Some non-ECC ram also have the temperature sensor, although this tended to be expensive stuff aimed at overclockers for hard core gaming rigs.
On a positive note, ECC RAM is supposedly 3% slower, so if you use non-ECC ram you're system might run ever so slightly faster, but probably not noticeably so.
gslrider
macrumors 6502
I just found this thread, after posting a question about ECC vs non-ECC. So currently I have all ECC ram in my system, with 2 slots left which I'd like to fill up. Locally, it's hard to come across the same ram I currently have. I'd have to order online, which if I don't need to do, prefer not to. The local computer stores I go to do have non-ECC of the same specs for my Mac Pro 8-core (2008). http://canadacomputers.com/product_info.php?cPath=24_311_313_621&item_id=031239 and http://canadacomputers.com/product_info.php?cPath=24_311_313_621&item_id=012841
Apart from the original 2x1GB ram that came with the system when I bought it, I purchased 4x1GB Kingston 240-pin PC2-6400 (800Mhz) DDR2 ECC fully buffered DIMMs. System has been running fine for the last couple of years. Would it be safe to throw in non-ECC ram in the mix. I'm a graphic designer, and use all the Adobe software, but starting to get into 3D design, hence why I'd like to up my ram.
Thanks.
Apart from the original 2x1GB ram that came with the system when I bought it, I purchased 4x1GB Kingston 240-pin PC2-6400 (800Mhz) DDR2 ECC fully buffered DIMMs. System has been running fine for the last couple of years. Would it be safe to throw in non-ECC ram in the mix. I'm a graphic designer, and use all the Adobe software, but starting to get into 3D design, hence why I'd like to up my ram.
Thanks.
Umbongo
macrumors 601
None of that will work gslrider. This is what you need: http://canadacomputers.com/product_info.php?cPath=38_504_605&item_id=017048
You can get it for half that price online though. CanadaRAM is worth looking at and the owner is a reputable member of these forums (under that username). http://www.canadaram.com/apple_mac_pro.htm
You can get it for half that price online though. CanadaRAM is worth looking at and the owner is a reputable member of these forums (under that username). http://www.canadaram.com/apple_mac_pro.htm