Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Kendo

macrumors 68020
Original poster
Apr 4, 2011
2,363
922
I am guilty in the fact that I have downloaded music illegally. Not much, I probably have less than 1GB of pirated music (not trying to make myself feel better, but I know some people have tens or hundreds of GB worth).

I was doing some thinking and realized, even if I were to buy 100 songs, in the end that is "only" $130. Sure that is a lot, but how many of us spend that much on one piece of clothing, two Xbox 360 games, one fancy dinner, etc? In other words, it is an amount that we are easily accustomed to spending on other things.

And that 100 songs is roughly 6 and a half hours of entertainment that you carry with you throughout the day (at work, in the gym, on the bus, etc.).

Is there anyone who strictly buys all of their music legit and if so, do you buy from iTunes or Amazon?
 
Hmmm I'm a broke college student, I don't have the money to buy music off iTunes lol. When I get a job, I'll get all my music off iTunes, but as for now, I'll keep uploading music off my friends computer.
 
I do buy/download all my music legit, but mostly from independent artists on Bandcamp and Scrub Club Records. When I do buy something, it's usually from iTunes for convenience, and Amazon when I can't find it on iTunes.
 
If I had to guess I'd suspect my wife and I have spent close to $3,000 on iTunes music.

When you break it down by month that's somewhere between $25 and $30 per month.

But compare that to CDs...that would have been 200 CDs, whereas we've bought the songs we wanted from many, many more albums than that. iTunes has saved us money over the long run (assuming we would have been buying CDs that whole time).
 
I enjoy music too much to steal it. I have friends who are artists in the business, and their record labels have been hit hard. Not to mention the artists, and entire infrastructure as we knew it.

While change is good, and progress marches on, I don't work for free and I don't expect anyone else to. I pay for everything I have. Period. If I don't like the pricing I just don't buy it.

So yes I have far more than just hundreds of dollars spent via iTunes after all these years of iPods, then iPhones. It is what it is. iTunes is part of the Apple experience.

Amazon? Absolutely, I've spent a lot and will be spending more now with my Fire. The Kindles I've had as I've upgraded at each refresh. The reading experience is too good to bother with an iPad.

My iPad 2 is used for Web, email and other content. That's what it excels in. Side by side, you have to see how much better the Kindle display is for reading. But then again, it should be it's purpose built for that . I must have both types for the wide range of my personal needs.
 
Probably between $3000 and $4000 for me. I love music and admire the artists that create it.
 
I enjoy music too much to steal it. I have friends who are artists in the business, and their record labels have been hit hard. Not to mention the artists, and entire infrastructure as we knew it.

While change is good, and progress marches on, I don't work for free and I don't expect anyone else to. I pay for everything I have. Period. If I don't like the pricing I just don't buy it.

So yes I have far more than just hundreds of dollars spent via iTunes after all these years of iPods, then iPhones. It is what it is. iTunes is part of the Apple experience.

Amazon? Absolutely, I've spent a lot and will be spending more now with my Fire. The Kindles I've had as I've upgraded at each refresh. The reading experience is too good to bother with an iPad.

My iPad 2 is used for Web, email and other content. That's what it excels in. Side by side, you have to see how much better the Kindle display is for reading. But then again, it should be it's purpose built for that . I must have both types for the wide range of my personal needs.

Any difference between Amazon and iTunes for buying music? I did notice Amazon does have sales but for the most part, most new tracks are the same price as iTunes. I would like to keep everything uniform however.
 
Yikes. I just pulled up my statement and filtered out iTunes... $1190.63! :eek:

It doesn't seem like that much when you're paying <$20 per album!
 
I've certainly spent over $1,000 since getting my first iPod about 5 years ago. I have a small collection of CDs (maybe 100 or so) that I ripped into iTunes too (BTW a lot were ripped at 128k when I was more concerned about hard drive space, and a ton of those just got upgraded to 256k with iTunes Match).

I meter my buying by getting iTunes gift cards every now and then. If I don't have money in iTunes balance I generally hold off buying music until I get some. It's just a way to keep my spending in check :)
 
I've never looked at the exact figures, but I know I've spent thousands over the years. The past few have all been iTunes, Amazon and some Sprint music purchases, when I had my Android phone.
 
I enjoy music too much to steal it. I have friends who are artists in the business, and their record labels have been hit hard. Not to mention the artists, and entire infrastructure as we knew it.

While change is good, and progress marches on, I don't work for free and I don't expect anyone else to. I pay for everything I have. Period. If I don't like the pricing I just don't buy it.

I don't work for free either, but I don't understand why a digital album at EMI etc has to cost me €25, where I often can buy CD's directly from an artist at 10-15, when they also have the cost of a physical cd and often really small production batches thus higher costs.
And there is over here the idiotic tax on empty cd's that is to compensate artist for their royalties. I never use a cd, dvd or usb-stick to burn/copy music, i use them for work, but that doesn't matter. that combined with the law that downloading for own use is legal, but uploading isn't, doesn't give me a guilty feeling.
Most of all, i don't download much music. Perhaps two cd's a year and if i like it and want to keep it, i buy it afterwards as I like to support that artist. I just don't like record companies.
OTOH i have downloaded a lot of books as I couldn't buy them digital. they just weren't available in my language (Dutch)
 
I only pay for music from small/up and coming artists. The big-time ones are rich enough and make a killing from concerts. Also broke college student here.
 
Yikes. I just pulled up my statement and filtered out iTunes... $1190.63! :eek:

It doesn't seem like that much when you're paying <$20 per album!

I'm scared to look at mine for this reason...

The funny thing is, when you take a look at your DVD movie collection or Xbox collection of games sitting on the wall, do you ever stop and think "OMG, I spent $2000 on everything." I know I don't. If anything I feel proud of my collection.

I wonder why there is sticker shock when looking up how much you spent on a digital collection? Maybe because there isn't really anything to show for it even though you're getting the same content as physical discs?
 
I would, but I like to rip my audio tracks at the maximum quality that iTunes allows (320Kbps I believe).

Good thing is that Amazon has most of the CDs I want for cheap and since I have amazon prime, it's free 2-day shipping!
 
The funny thing is, when you take a look at your DVD movie collection or Xbox collection of games sitting on the wall, do you ever stop and think "OMG, I spent $2000 on everything." I know I don't. If anything I feel proud of my collection.

I feel proud of my 60+ HD DVDs at $2 each :cool:
 
I don't buy the reasoning of all those contributors who complain that they are too poor to pay for music, when they are probably not too poor to have an iPhone or other Apple product. No sympathy from me if they get prosecuted for copyright violations...
 
Yea I've spent a lot on music, lots, I definately believe in supporting artists even if I have issues with record companies.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.