Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
if it doesn't run in the background isn't it usless for car navigation? when a phone call comes in your all screwed up.
 
if it doesn't run in the background isn't it usless for car navigation? when a phone call comes in your all screwed up.

What the heck good would it do running in the background? What's the point of a map you can't see?

You have 3 options:

1) Ignore the call
2) Go without the map for a minute
3) Buy a seperate GPS unit

If you're going to have your phone and your GPS in one device, then #1 and #2 are you only choices. No way around that.
 
What the heck good would it do running in the background? What's the point of a map you can't see?

You have 3 options:

1) Ignore the call
2) Go without the map for a minute
3) Buy a seperate GPS unit

If you're going to have your phone and your GPS in one device, then #1 and #2 are you only choices. No way around that.

4) Take the call in hands free mode. GPS can still speak its commands, which would cause only a momentary disruption of conversation.
 
What the heck good would it do running in the background? What's the point of a map you can't see?

What's the point of a nav app that stops working just when you need it most?

TomTom on other phones (especially WM) continues to run while you're in your call, or responding to a text message.

That way, you don't miss a turn while you're talking to someone. Like your wife telling you she's having the baby right now and you better not get lost.
 
Looks good.

If you don't have an existing GPS, it may be a good choice.

If already have a GPS, it may not be.

I'm quite happy with my Garmins, and I'll be sticking with them (and, yes, I do plan on getting the 3GS).
 
What's the point of a nav app that stops working just when you need it most?

TomTom on other phones (especially WM) continues to run while you're in your call, or responding to a text message.

That way, you don't miss a turn while you're talking to someone. Like your wife telling you she's having the baby right now and you better not get lost.

How about not die because you're talking on the phone and playing with the GPS, I think that would suck more than getting lost.

As for the price no matter what they charge someone here will bitch about it, because hey that's what Mac Rumors is about.
 
What the heck good would it do running in the background? What's the point of a map you can't see?

You have 3 options:

1) Ignore the call
2) Go without the map for a minute
3) Buy a seperate GPS unit

If you're going to have your phone and your GPS in one device, then #1 and #2 are you only choices. No way around that.

Obviously you have never used a GPS.
 
I am excited about the possibility of having navigation in my car (I never could bring myself to spend £100 on a standalone navigation unit) but the price really needs to be spot on or I won't be having it. Probably £40 or £50 is the upper limit to what I'd spend on this, less if I factor in the cost of the accessory to stick the phone to the dash.

I'm concerned about how the maps would be stored though - for a full map of the United Kingdom I wonder how much of my storage will be used by this app?
 
What's the point of a nav app that stops working just when you need it most?

TomTom on other phones (especially WM) continues to run while you're in your call, or responding to a text message.

That way, you don't miss a turn while you're talking to someone. Like your wife telling you she's having the baby right now and you better not get lost.

Well, that sure sounds like the PHONE is running in the background.

I was responding to the guy who asked about the GPS running in the background. I said that didn't sound too useful.

What you said makes sense, but that's not what he said.
 
How about not die because you're talking on the phone and playing with the GPS, I think that would suck more than getting lost.

You're not "playing with the GPS". This isn't Google Maps in manual mode. It's a turn-by-turn automobile specific app.

On other phones, it shows a screen banner at the top how far it is to the next turn, and telling you when to turn by way of a voice-over.

You can either watch it or just wait for the voice.

As for the price no matter what they charge someone here will bitch about it, because hey that's what Mac Rumors is about.

I didn't catch the price. The usual $100+ ? Or monthly?

Well, that sure sounds like the PHONE is running in the background.

I suppose you could look at it that way. But I believe what you see on other phones is the phone app as the primary onscreen (say with a picture of who's calling, or whom you're calling), with the Nav app kind of "behind" (see above).
 
I'm concerned about how the maps would be stored though - for a full map of the United Kingdom I wonder how much of my storage will be used by this app?
This may be comparing apples and oranges, but I think the US maps for a Garmin standalone GPS are somewhere around 2GB. I imagine that the UK maps are a bit smaller (under 1GB, I'd hope, but I really don't know).

Edit: Garmin has the US map broken into manageable chunks, and not everything has to be uploaded (for those Garmin units that don't come with a complete, built-in US map). I imagine that TomTom does also (but, again, I really don't know), and so I'd hope that the TomTom app wouldn't force users to upload an entire map of the UK.
 
Nah not really, I'm more than satisfied with my Garmin nuvi 255W. And when I use it, it doesn't drain my iPhone's battery life :D
 
I have a TOMTOM GO and in some areas it will make sure you get lost.
 
I suppose you could look at it that way. But I believe what you see on other phones is the phone app as the primary onscreen (say with a picture of who's calling, or whom you're calling), with the Nav app kind of "behind" (see above).

Just to be clear:
Map while you hear the phone call: Useful
Seeing the phone but not the map: Not so useful

I have no idea who's talking about what, but that's my point. I guess some of you are describing one and some are describing the other, but I'm not sure who's who.
 
Well wait...I renew my objection then.

:)

Just to be clear:
Map while you hear the phone call: Useful
Seeing the phone but not the map: Not so useful

The core idea is that the user still gets the turn directions (voice and/or turn indicator), even while using another application. This is a primary example of a need for multitasking.

If you're the driver of course, talking is the most you should do at the same time (and that as little as possible). OTOH, a passenger with the phone could be reading the restaurant menu on the web, while still getting the realtime turn instructions to get there, for the driver to hear.
 
:)



The core idea is that the user still gets the turn directions (voice and/or turn indicator), even while using another application. This is a primary example of a need for multitasking.

I believe that you can just initiate the phone call before bringing up the maps and then talk on the phone while still viewing the map and directions. Of course, if you receive a call, you'd have to answer and then re-open the TomTom app for the same effect.
 
psyched! i want the grip stand too! looks nice for coverflow mode on my iphone. the stand looks like it has and audio out. not too excited about two wires coming off my dash. already scheming ways to route the wires in my impreza...
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.