Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Michael CM1

macrumors 603
Original poster
Feb 4, 2008
5,682
277
I bought "The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" from the iTunes Store last night. Watched it in part on my older LCD TV in my bedroom and didn't notice anything. I later watched it on my newer Samsung LED TV and noticed a green line popping up in the black bar below the picture.

I have never experienced this with any video I have bought from iTunes. I mean never. I noticed a couple spots of compression in very dark scenes in "The Hunger Games" and "Skyfall." I didn't even see that on this movie.

Does anyone have experience with this? Both ATVs are third generation, although the one hooked up to the more expensive TV is a year older. Both are up to date on software. I even tracked back on the video and it is at the same spot, not randomly when playing.
 
I bought "The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" from the iTunes Store last night. Watched it in part on my older LCD TV in my bedroom and didn't notice anything. I later watched it on my newer Samsung LED TV and noticed a green line popping up in the black bar below the picture.

I have never experienced this with any video I have bought from iTunes. I mean never. I noticed a couple spots of compression in very dark scenes in "The Hunger Games" and "Skyfall." I didn't even see that on this movie.

Does anyone have experience with this? Both ATVs are third generation, although the one hooked up to the more expensive TV is a year older. Both are up to date on software. I even tracked back on the video and it is at the same spot, not randomly when playing.

I didn't think it was out until next month...how did you manage to buy it?
 
it's available in the US store, might be different for the UK
rental available on march 19th

https://itunes.apple.com/us/movie/hobbit-unexpected-journey/id598661920

---
is the green bar at the very edge of the screen, might be the way your TV is handling overscan.

it's possible your TV aspect ratio is set to "just scan" instead of 16:9 or something similar (every manufacturer is a bit different in the terminology here)
 
Last edited:
I watched it last night and it looked beautiful with no artifacts or lines - I'd imagine it is an equipment issue.

(Played via ATV 3 on my Epson 710HD projector - 160 inch screen or so)
 
Last edited:
it's available in the US store, might be different for the UK
rental available on march 19th

https://itunes.apple.com/us/movie/hobbit-unexpected-journey/id598661920

---
is the green bar at the very edge of the screen, might be the way your TV is handling overscan.

it's possible your TV aspect ratio is set to "just scan" instead of 16:9 or something similar (every manufacturer is a bit different in the terminology here)

I'll check my TV ratio. It could be the motion-smoothing technology as well.

I will try re-downloading it, but I watched the part at the end (post-Gollum) and didn't see it on my older TV. Darn Samsung barfing on my Apple TV. Play nice!
 
If it bothers you, you can report a problem with the video quality to iTunes (go to Account->Purchase History->Report a Problem). I've done this twice (once for a line similar to what you describe that stayed for the whole movie, and once for an encoding error that was only visible for a few seconds), and both times I have been given store credit to cover the cost of the item.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.