One thing is not even up for discussion:
this game is cute as hell.
Cute enough to give me & my wife a warm fuzzy feeling.
She said when she has a hard day at work she loves turning the Wii on and hearing the music for MySims, it picks her spirits right up.
I still haven't played it since my initial hour's worth, but she's probably logged somewhere between 5-10 hours into the game and she loves it.
I think it's the best sim-ish game out there, really. I love the Sims and I love Animal Crossing, but there are things about both that I dislike (at times).
- the constant status checking in the Sims, which in turn gives you less time to do fun things because instead you have to shower because you stink or eat because you're hungry.
- the constant errand runs in Animal Crossing, because when you're done with errands and everyone is sleeping for the night, there's almost nothing else to do aside from fishing or plant/tree work.
MySims is a nice mixture of the positives of both games, minus a lot of the negatives. And it's more cute than AC.
MySims2 needs internet village-visiting like AC:WW though...that's a must. Hopefully they fix some of the issues of that though that are in AC:WW, like the fact that people who visit your village can trash it and then leave.
I'm expecting Nintendo to do the same with the Wii AC so that won't happen on there either.