Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Kingsly

macrumors 68040
Original poster
I Just got the academic version of aperture in the mail today, and there is this big sticker that says "Academic version, not elegible for upgrades" ?:confused: :eek:?!! What!? It never said this on my FCE boxes, and upgrades (the $99 ones) worked fine. Is this some new über secret plan of Apple's?

What's going on??
 
If you are not happy with this policy return your software and buy the full fat, upgradable and probably vastly more expensive version!
 
Kingsly said:
I Just got the academic version of aperture in the mail today, and there is this big sticker that says "Academic version, not elegible for upgrades" ?:confused: :eek:?!! What!? It never said this on my FCE boxes, and upgrades (the $99 ones) worked fine. Is this some new über secret plan of Apple's?

What's going on??

I agree that it's a crappy policy. With some apps they make that pretty clear before you buy it, but doesn't seem to be consistent.

As far as I'm concerned it makes the academic versions pretty worthless. I'd probably stick with the "real" versions.
 
milo said:
As far as I'm concerned it makes the academic versions pretty worthless. I'd probably stick with the "real" versions.
How can you say its worthless? In most cases buying a new academic version is cheaper than the retail upgrade. So nomatter how many times you upgrade you always get away paying less then retail. This is also true with retail versions of software suites such as adobe creative suite and macromedia stuio. The retail suite doesn't have an upgrade, you have to buy seperate upgrades which adds up to more than buying the suite again.
 
jsm4182 said:
How can you say its worthless? In most cases buying a new academic version is cheaper than the retail upgrade. So nomatter how many times you upgrade you always get away paying less then retail. This is also true with retail versions of software suites such as adobe creative suite and macromedia stuio. The retail suite doesn't have an upgrade, you have to buy seperate upgrades which adds up to more than buying the suite again.
I see your point here but if the aperture upgrade is $99 and I have to pay another $149 instead... I don't know... *grabs calculator*

Edit: I added it all up. Yes, I save money purchasing the acedemic version (the hypothetical aperture 2) all over again than purchasing the "real" version and the upgrade. :)

Edu. Aperture 1: $149 + Aperture 2 $149 = $298

Aperture 1: $299 + Aperture 2 upgrade: $99 = $398
 
Aperture 3 Academic: the worse deal

If you intend to upgrade to Aperture 3 when it's released, and if Apple offers another $99 upgrade for full-version users, then it's actually a worse deal to purchase the academic version of Aperture 2. While full-version users will be able to upgrade, it seems that academic users will have to purchase an entirely new program.

Assuming the same pricing for A3:

EDU: Aperture 2 + Aperture 3 = $179 + $179 = $358
Regular: Aperture 2 + Aperture 3 upgrade = $199 + $99 = $298.

I teach math and use photography in my class, and would very likely upgrade to A3. Apple's pricing seems rather strange, then, as it ironically makes it MORE expensive for educators (and students) to continue to use the newest technology.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.