Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Site and Forum Feedback' started by Sonmi451, May 29, 2015.
I don't see any Apple Car sub. Can we get one? Surely Apple is working in one.
Has there been some sort of indication from Apple that an Apple Car is to be expected? Lacking that, I'm not sure what purpose such a sub forum would serve here other than idle speculation.
Apple doesn't want to sell you a car. Apple wants to sell iOS based systems to car manufacturers.
Sub-forums generally aren't added until a product is actually announced. That's sometime off yet, if it happens at all.
Bump. With all the articles here, surely we can have an Apple car sub to discuss the project.
That is correct, they are usually added on the day of the keynote and associated sub forums can be added or tweaked later on as the product develops.
As noted, Sub-forums are not created on rumored products. There's really not much to talk about since Apple doesn't have one and denies its working on one.
Perhaps it's an iPhone Accessory?
Seriously though @maflynn & @OllyW , while I know what the policy is, perhaps it should be revised. Since this is indeed a rumors site, it might be worth considering a revision of this policy. After, the question still hasn't been answered: If users do want to discuss future/rumored projects, where are they to discuss them? Industry news?
The issue is how much discussion will occur, and will that level of discussion justify adding a forum and its oversight? I don't think we're at a level of activity where there will be much more discussion other then the occasional news thread.
That's a good place to discuss it.
With the amount of news coming out, I think it will eventually justify its own sub. You can decide when that happens, but it's inevitable. There's news almost every day coming out that is relevant to this project.
I get that an accessory or small rumored product wouldn't need one, but this is a huge complex project that may eventually need its own forum.
When, and if, such an Apple product is released, then we will likely create a place for it on the forum.
...I understand this, but is it not somewhat of a paradox or catch-22 then? The premise of this site is rumors, not facts. If only facts were reported, it would be an entirely different premise & site.
While I understand the point that you Mods are trying to make here in regard to not creating subs for every rumored future Apple product (for both legwork and clarity purposes), there does seem to be a bit of a discrepancy here.
Not really. Rumors get news articles by the editors and they're posted in the news discussion forums for everyone to comment on.
I would submit that this site has evolved far beyond only Macs and/or only Rumors.
I guess my point (again) is as follows:
To say that a topic doesn't deserve a sub because it's only a rumor makes sense both in regards to mod work and clarity/ease of site navigation.
To say that this topic falls under this category (and shouldn't have a sub until it's officially acknowledged by Apple) does not make sense given the amount of information circulating around it. Oh, and let's not forget that MR even has a round up on it: http://www.macrumors.com/roundup/apple-car/ Perhaps that's the tipping point instead of official announcement?
Thanks for the consideration, and thanks again for all you guys do. This place really is great.
100% absolutely agree. I'm not arguing that at all. (Furthermore, I think it's great that it has.)
Kind of cherry-picking, aren't we?
The iWatch/Apple Watch was treated in exactly the same way in the long build up before it's official announcement and also had it's own roundup.
I said an Apple car will need its own forum, not sub. You can either create one or someone else will. You guys are missing an opportunity it's funny someone has to convince you.
Also, Comparing a car to a watch is pretty silly.
It will get it's own forum if and when it is officially announced.
Sure, I remember.
I'm not speculating on what has been done or what the current policy is; I'm stating my opinion/suggestion that the policy ought to be revisited and/or revised--at least in this instance.
But as the Polish proverb says, "Not my circus, not my monkeys."