Cook’ s product lines and services, and my opinion of each (YMMV):
Apple Pay (2014) - hit, real ‘out of the box’ thinking. Few instances of this since.
Apple Watch (2015) - hit, eventually. The rewriting of history to claim it was always a fitness product while conveniently forgetting the initial courting of the luxury fashion market (the Edition, the Galleries Lafayette pop-up, Angela Ahrendts, etc.) is typical Cook BS.
Apple Music (2015) - miss. iTunes + Beats Music still can’t overtake Spotify, arguably hugely overpaid for the latter too. And the App is still a buggy piece of crap.
iPad Pro (2015) - hit, initially to head off the Surface, latterly a magnificent piece of hardware. Still, really just a development of Jobs’ product that Jobs himself would never have approved. Which may be a good thing, or a bad thing.
Apple Pencil (2015) - hit. Steve didn’t stylus, Tim dared.
AirPods (2016) - slam-dunk, out-of-the-park hit.
HomePod (2017) - miss. A fatiguing listen, with a near-useless implementation of Siri; and being closed to all music services other than Apple Music is sheer stupidity. The later HomePod mini is however a spectacularly good audio product (albeit it still only works with Apple Music).
Apple TV+ (2019) - expensive miss (though with the occasional hit, and indeed Oscar!).
Apple Arcade (2019) - lazy miss. Courted the gaming sector, then decided they weren’t interested in putting in the hard yards. Just buy Nintendo, already!
Apple News+ (2019) - miss. Outside of Apple One, does anyone actually pay for this?
Apple Card (2019) - miss. Apple Pay it is not.
Apple Silicon/M1 (2020) - more epoch than hit, although it does have direct lineage back to PA Semi and the A4, therefore as much Jobs as Cook.
Apple Fitness+ (2020) - miss.
Apple One (2020) - miss.
AirPods Max (2020) - unsure; great product but massively overpriced, and with lazy as hell updates.
App Tracking Transparency (2021) - hit.
iCloud+ (2021) - unsure. Some great features, still way too buggy and overpriced compared to the competition.
AirTag/Find My network (2021) - big hit. Nefarious use cases cannot be blamed on Apple.
Apple Vision Pro (2024) - very large miss. Magnificent engineering but a $4000 tech demo/beta in search of a market.
Apple Intelligence (2025) - humongous, utterly embarrassing miss.
MacBook Neo (2026) - hit, but it’s just the new iBook, let’s be honest.
His various macOS, iOS and iPadOS updates are not listed. On those I will offer: the iOSsificaition of macOS has been a f ucking disaster; iOS and iPadOS continue to be brilliant under the hood but have barely innovated UI-wise since iOS 7 and have been going backwards UX-wise for some time now. System software should be a - if not the - priority for Jonny Appleseed.