Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
You said that he knowingly resold stolen property. Where are you getting this from? What if the kid though he was running a legit buisness. He might have just google the number to foxcom, got in touch with an employee who told the kid he could sell him parts for the iphone. As far as the kid is concerned when he first started this he was doing everything in a legitamite way (except probably paying taxes). Once he was told what he was doing was illegal he inidiatly shut down his site.

Ignorance is never a defense for breaking the law. He clearly knew he was doing something illegal in the first place.

This thread is full of weird opinions.

It concerns me for society in general.
 
Yeah, I don't support Metallica in any sense of the word, but the difference there was no one was profiting in lue of Metallica, thats like me taking a unreleased album, putting up a website saying I'm Metallica and selling that album to people. Its a little different.

Napster was a company going public and making money off of advertising...they were certainly profiting. The funny thing is, Metallica is not the sort of band that would try to milk money from their fans...and had sued their own record company many times for trying to use their music without their explicit permission - most bands don't have the kind of balls to stand up to their own record company, and most bands don't even own their own music. After fighting for 18 years to maintain control, it all makes sense. Also, for the very same reason as Apple, if you do not file suit you set a precedent that it is ok to use your trademark. If Metallica knowingly let Napster host/trade/etc their music, they would never be able to prevent it in the future. Same goes here.
 
He's only a teenager, Apple are just throwing their weight around. :(:apple::(

I hate these kind of comments. Seriously being a teenager doesn't make the laws any less serious. If you are a teen and you break the law you should face the same penalties as anyone else, and your parents should be on the hook as well if they haven't taught you well enough.
 
How was he infringing on apples trademark? On his website he said he was selling apple parts, he never said he made them. Im guessing that by everybody believes that it is also trademark infringment to resell my macbook because it has an apple logo on it?

If you sold it as an Apple reseller, yes. Essentially, that is what this kid was doing.
 
who cares. that kid had the balls do what nobody else managed to do. He saw an opportunity and went for it. This is how innovative minds are born.
 
Whether it was rite or wrong.. you gotta do what you gotta do in this economy, we don't know the extent of the teen and his family background.. they could have been poor as dirt.. last I check and correct me if I'm wrong Apple has over $9,000,000,000 in the bank.. I can see to file a suit to shut him down, but to go after if money too.. a petty $130k

makes me sick to own a Macbook Pro now

OMG. Is this what you actually believe?

who cares. that kid had the balls do what nobody else managed to do. He saw an opportunity and went for it. This is how innovative minds are born.

Isn't theft and counterfeiting so awesome! Kewl!
 
who cares. that kid had the balls do what nobody else managed to do. He saw an opportunity and went for it. This is how innovative minds are born.

Yes, innovative minds and criminals too. So if you figure out a way to enter a home without breaking the door or a key, and you actually do it, you are innovative as hell, but you are a criminal, too.
 
who cares. that kid had the balls do what nobody else managed to do. He saw an opportunity and went for it. This is how innovative minds are born.

What is innovative about buying spare parts and selling them? The only thing "innovative" is that the parts were stolen. It's great to appreciate an entrepreneurial spirit like this kid has...but it's downright dumb to call breaking the law having "balls".
 
These were parts that Apple owned. This is no different than if someone stole your car from your garage, then sold it to someone else.
It is extremely different. He did not go to the factory and steel the parts and then sell them. He simply bought parts and was reselling them. I think this is a better analigy. You by a car from somebody, then you go to resell the car, a couple months later you find out the car you bought and then sold was stolen.

So basically your trying to claim the kid didn't know the parts were illegal?? If the kids that stupid at that age then he should be put in a home for mentally challenged. People keep making excuses because he is young which is ridiculous. People wonder why we have kids killing other kids, its not violent video games or tv, its all these kind of people who think its ok to make excuses for kids, so the kids have no sense of respect for authority at all anymore because some bleeding heart out there will go "oh go easy on them, they are just a kid" over every thing. Its time laws started to come down hard on kids and their parents who obviously didn't take the responsibility to teach them right from wrong.
 
who cares. that kid had the balls do what nobody else managed to do. He saw an opportunity and went for it. This is how innovative minds are born.

If by "innovative" you mean criminal. Apple did him a favor. Just imagine the bigger heists he might have run if he got away with it.
 
What part of your iPhone 4 is defective? Have you called Apple about it? Even better if you have AppleCare, but they'll often just replace it for free.

I dont have an iPhone 4. What good is applecare gonna do if they are gonna keep giving out the same defective phones as replacements?

And again if apple is so readily able to release a black defective iPhone 4, then why are they so above releasing a defective WHITE iphone 4(at release date)?

I mean, well they could of included a iphone rubberband with your iPhone 4 purchase, oh wait, they dont like giving away stuff... even if it remedies a defective by design iPhone. Oh well.
 
Nice to see a lot of people here supporting a teenager trafficking in stolen goods to sell a product he doesn't have any license to do. Should Apple have sent him a fruit basket instead?
 
How do you have to hold it? It isn't working for me. I can still make calls.

reading is not your strong point I presume. He said you lose signal when holding it a certain way, particularily on the lower left hand corner, where the "gap" is present.

You will lose signal, but that doesnt mean you wont be able to make a call. That all depends on how strong your signal is to begin with.
 
If by "innovative" you mean criminal. Apple did him a favor. Just imagine the bigger heists he might have run if he got away with it.

Studies have shown that kids who custom build white iPhone 4's are five times more likely to be involved in gangs.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.