Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
They've all been promising this under 3 different names for years now. Utter BS. Open it up for whats there already, we all know these things work as third parties have managed to step in to accomplish this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: siddavis and jk1221
Huge disappointment- was holding off on some items thinking they would see updates with Matter this summer or early fall.

I highly doubt they’ll offer Matter as a firmware update to existing products.

So close, no matter how far
Couldn't be much more from the heart
Forever trusting who we are
And nothing else matters.
 
I guess this explains why none of the newly announced Google Nest cameras received Matter support, which surprised me initially.
 
Will Matter be backward compatible with current systems? Will current devices be able to use the Matter standard?

Yes thankfully, well at least Phillips has said they will release a firmware update for their smart products like Hue once Matter is released to make the transition 'seamless'.

Google will do the same with existing Hub and Hub Max's so they can control Matter devices, and they'll update the latest gen Nest thermostat.

Still a huge question mark over the vast majority of existing smart home products though, and I bet they do some products, while leaving others out so people basically are all enrolled into Matter on release, then they're incentivised to sell and replace some of the non Matter tech. Will be a dirty that way I think - devices that could be update simply won't in order to upsell.
 
I guess this explains why none of the newly announced Google Nest cameras received Matter support, which surprised me initially.

They may yet update them, though leave out the earlier versions from any firmware update. They will want at least some tech enrolled into Matter on release in order to upsell others. The new Nest will definitely be getting a Matter firmware update.
 
IMO that is looking like another gimmick in the short term. Until people actually support it, it is a pipe dream.

It's been "out" as a standard for years and only Eve and Nanoleaf make Thread accessories, a very limited number of types too, still. There isn't even basic stuff out other than some lighting and 2-3 Eve sensors (like contact sensors). And I use mostly switches and not bulbs anyway to still have manual controls. And would want a full suite of sensors- motion, vibrate/glass break; the basic home security stuff.

Maybe that will change in the next year or 2, but you cant always wait for the next big thing.
Yeah this is very true. I just feel really let down that hue aren’t going to be supporting thread/matter even though the hardware is there, only on the hub which is useless, one of the benefits of it in the first place is you don’t need a different hub for every company which is very annoying. Hopefully it will take off and become the gold standard, all the pieces are there for it to be amazing
 
  • Like
Reactions: jk1221
Personally I am less focused on the specific standard and more focused on the company behind it. In my view, the issue is not the number of hubs, but whether you will be able to get matching accessories in years to come.

To me it seems that Nanoleaf as a company is still too green - too young - compared to some of the others. They make some fun products, but they don't have the history to assure me that their bulbs will still be sold in 10 years and compatible with whatever system they have today.

Signify can trace it's roots back to the mid 90s, they truly innovated smart LED lighting back in the day, and during their brief time as subsidiary of Philips they picked up some good IP. Hue is probably going to be in this for the long haul.

But we can go even further back. Lutron has been around for something like 100 years, and was the first company to sell a solid-state dimmer switch. They're not going anywhere anytime soon. They'll probably still be making RA2-compatible switches in 10 years if not longer. So even through it's proprietary, I am eyeing their RA2 smart system.
Very true, but hue seems bent on forcing us to keep using their hubs and ecosystem, which is why I’m moving on from them. I guess they make more money selling hubs, they have pledged support for matter but only on the hub which brings zero benefit if the bulbs themselves can’t communicate with other thread stuff
 
  • Like
Reactions: mhnd
I wonder what it means for me since I own everything HomeKit.

Will it continue to work?
Will it respond faster?
Will I continue to see "Not responding" errors?
Will it be more reliable?
Will it allow for more automations?
Will I need to keep my hubs ? (Arlo, Philips)
 
My trusty old light switches will do for now, it really isn’t that hard to flick it and you get a healthy workout getting of your backside!
 
I don’t see how they could orphan so many customers.

There are people outfitting entire homes with Homekit certified Lutron devices and they are not cheap.

Hue and Eve are doing huge sales of extremely high priced basic Homekit accessories and continuing to introduce new accessories.

There was a new “gradient” led tube strip product announced this week!

There are always cries of Apple will screw you over, or comparisons to what happened with HomePod.

However, abandoning support for existing HomeKit compatible devices essentially breaks reasonable expectations of what agreement should’ve been in place with Eve and Hue in the first place

If Apple is allowing them to sell homekit certified accessories part of that agreement has to include some expected needed support for these devices.

That certainty is part of the licensing fee Eve, Hue, Ikea and the rest pay for this and presumably pass on in their overpriced buttons and motion sensors.

The Homekit certification fees also allow these companies to budget the R&D and years of support costs needed to continue to sell existing and new Homekit certified devices.

So I think people should feel comfortable buying existing homekit stuff with confidence. It’s just an unnecessarily expensive patchwork of absolutely atrocious UX right now.

I run the Lutron, Ikea tradfri, and hue hubs and have experimented with the conbee ii univeral gateway.

From my view, Homekit / smarthome m is the ugliest, most underinvested product category Apple is in by far.
It’s literally everything apple not to have the new features with out buying the new product. Literally everything
 
My trusty old light switches will do for now, it really isn’t that hard to flick it and you get a healthy workout getting of your backside!
It's kind of nice to be able to hit one button, then have all six floor lamps in one room dim for watching a movie. It's kind of fun to be able to click on a button and have all the lights in the dining room and the kitchen turn on bright or tune down. It's kind of fun to program your bedroom lights as an alarm clock. They come on dim five minutes before your wake up time, then bright, right when your cell phone alarms goes off.

It's not so fun when a thunderstorm causes a power blip and it turns on every single light in your house. I have been meaning to program a button that I can put next to the bed that shuts off every light.
 
I wonder what it means for me since I own everything HomeKit.

Will it continue to work?
Will it respond faster?
Will I continue to see "Not responding" errors?
Will it be more reliable?
Will it allow for more automations?
Will I need to keep my hubs ? (Arlo, Philips)
I would guess ”yes“ to all of those.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PsykX
Apple, Google and Amazon?!! How safe is going to be?
Can you opt out of it?
I don’t think Apple would be involved if there was anything shady about it. I dislike Apple at times but I trust them more than most with my privacy. They would drop out if there was any chance of negative PR about privacy. Their entire data philosophy is “everyone has a right to privacy” and they’ve worked hard to build that image. They’re not going to risk it on this of all things.
 
I don’t think Apple would be involved if there was anything shady about it. I dislike Apple at times but I trust them more than most with my privacy. They would drop out if there was any chance of negative PR about privacy. Their entire data philosophy is “everyone has a right to privacy” and they’ve worked hard to build that image. They’re not going to risk it on this of all things.
No offense, but where have you been the last couple of weeks?
 
  • Like
Reactions: AbsoluteAnointedOne
All HomeKit 2 devices should be compatible with Matter by 2023 and support a new slogan: "All Smart Home Devices Matter."
 
Last edited:
I wonder what it means for me since I own everything HomeKit.

Will it continue to work?
Will it respond faster?
Will I continue to see "Not responding" errors?
Will it be more reliable?
Will it allow for more automations?
Will I need to keep my hubs ? (Arlo, Philips)
Matter = Apple HomeKit way of thinking thrown into an alliance with Google and co, stands for essentially cross-platform compatibility. It‘s mainly for having vendors only implement one standard (Matter) which works in all of the major Home automation frameworks. That‘s pretty much the biggest advantage Matter has.

More reliable experience mostly stems from using the Thread protocol, which allows any Thread enabled equipment to band together to a mesh network to relay data. That‘s what probably helps with „Not responding“. That‘s been in iOS 14 already though and requires hardware compatibility (HomePod mini and latest Apple TV 4k are the only Apple Home hubs that can do Thread).


If you actively follow iOS 15 betas, especially read the release notes, you already saw this article coming. They‘re this close to launching iOS 15 and yet the Home app known issues section is 10+ bullet points long with mind boggling issues like Matter accessories not working if your Apple TV is on wifi (workaround: plug into Ethernet). You can sum up the known issues list of iOS 15 beta release notes as „Matter: The Thread (featuring FaceTime woes)“.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PsykX
No one will seriously install this stuff in buildings until you can walk into Home Depot and buy a carton of switches or sockets for $20 and have some expectation they will still be useful and available in 30 years.

The gadgets are just toys for rich people until it because PERVASIVE in the industry. Until then a few enthusiasts will place a few of them in their own homes. But no one will actually use then in (say) a newly constructed condo complex until there is one standard and you can buy it at every electrical supply company for $2 per unit.
 
Matter = Apple HomeKit way of thinking thrown into an alliance with Google and co, stands for essentially cross-platform compatibility. It‘s mainly for having vendors only implement one standard (Matter) which works in all of the major Home automation frameworks. That‘s pretty much the biggest advantage Matter has.

More reliable experience mostly stems from using the Thread protocol, which allows any Thread enabled equipment to band together to a mesh network to relay data. That‘s what probably helps with „Not responding“. That‘s been in iOS 14 already though and requires hardware compatibility (HomePod mini and latest Apple TV 4k are the only Apple Home hubs that can do Thread).


If you actively follow iOS 15 betas, especially read the release notes, you already saw this article coming. They‘re this close to launching iOS 15 and yet the Home app known issues section is 10+ bullet points long with mind boggling issues like Matter accessories not working if your Apple TV is on wifi (workaround: plug into Ethernet). You can sum up the known issues list of iOS 15 beta release notes as „Matter: The Thread (featuring FaceTime woes)“.
We’re still at least 2 months away from release…
 
We’re still at least 2 months away from release…
We‘re a month away from the keynote, which means Apple is already closing in on a RC that probably is internally finalized in the next 2 weeks. Anyone expecting big strides in any department is in for a bad time / rude awakening.

That being said iOS 15 is pretty good already.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.