Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I’m fairly certain that Malwarebytes was causing kernel panics on my Mac and in my experience third party antivirus are the mostly likely types of software to do that. I uninstalled it and the random restarts nearly ceased immediately. I didn’t even have Malwarebytes in an active state (Scanning was turned off, etc) so, it can be tricky.
Norton certainly impacted my M1 MBP slightly. It’s not a universal binary the last I checked. I was using ESET previously on my Intel MBP and even though it’s considered as one of the best it certainly impacted the performance of the device.
 
How do I know I have the appropriate settings for effective protection?
 
Maybe they know something we don't know and are putting something in place to prevent bad actors around the world from doing some attack that could tarnish their image with its users. Maybe in 10 years you'll need an internet connection for verification to even be allowed to install an app at all. Thats after you'll need to scan yourself to verify your identity, location, account balance and social status to be allowed to interact with the computer in the first place.
Should this happen, it will be the ultimate end of privacy and civil liberty, as there’s no trust anymore. I hate to see this happen, feeling safe or otherwise.
 
Love Oakley's site and work – digging deeper into some aspects of the Mac and showing beautiful paintings I didn't know about. Glad he's getting headlines. :)
 
Apple have traditionally used Mac's "virus free" nature as a selling tool. You don't want to change that perception if you don't have to.
I think that rubicon was crossed with the original XProtect, if not before. Even if they made no song and dance, the presence of something has long been fairly obvious. The simple fact that there are anti-malware products for macOS indicates some people have felt the need whatever Apple said, or implied, or simply let us assume.
 
I thought MacOS is based on Unix and it is already very safe lol xd

It’s based on a hybrid Mach kernel.

An operating system’s kernel and base system says nothing about security.

All operating systems get attacks and all operating systems need to update security holes and add malware protection.

It will be like this forever.

In the next wave people will be learning to hack into and causing denial of service attacks on AI systems which are almost exclusively running on Linux.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wanha
Great. But what they really need are major performance updates and bug fixes.

Oh, and the old Finder icon is still dotted around the system! I mean c’monnn!
"You got a promotion?

Great. But what you really need is to lose weight and get over your social anxiety issues.

Oh, and you still haven't fixed the damn doorbell. I mean c'monnn!"
 
  • Haha
Reactions: svenmany
Many thanks Apple but why quietly? Scream it from the rooftops!

Unless of course this would be another reason for idiot politicians to look into anti-trust behavior because MalwareBytes might complain.
nah i rather have it in the background wihout being visible. I like its directly integrated so its seamless
 
  • Like
Reactions: MajorFubar
I'm glad it's built into the fabric of the system and just sits there doing its thing quietly.
My experience of 'bolt-on' third-party virus protectors in the Windows world is that they bring the computer down to its knees. And woe betide you ever wanting to fully uninstall them without undertaking a complete rebuild.
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbital~debris
Yeah, I thought it was a little comical that they announced it quietly. I mean, Apple doesn't need to announce everything they do, or even announce it at all. Who knows...maybe they already implemented CSAM quietly (or will) since there was so much of an uproar last year.
Let's think this one through.

Say Apple were to implement CSAM quietly and secretly after the uproar its announcement caused last year - how would we all feel?

Betrayed, outraged, and disillusioned in Apple, I would imagine.

These forums would be filled with outrage. Tech websites, major newspapers, TV news would be all over it, milking the scandal for 10 million clicks.

The incident would constitute a colossal scandal for Apple and would cost them a ton of goodwill and trust.

What I am getting at is that Apple may be a lot of things, but "really stupid" isn't one of them.
 
Last edited:
Let's think this one through.

Say Apple were to implement CSAM quietly and secretly after the uproar its announcement caused last year - how would we all feel?

Betrayed, outraged, and disillusioned in Apple, I would imagine.

These forums would be filled with outrage. Tech websites, major newspapers, TV news would be all over it, milking the scandal for 10 million clicks.

The incident would constitute a colossal scandal for Apple and would cost them a ton of goodwill and trust.

What I am getting at is that Apple may be a lot of things, but "really stupid" isn't one of them.

There’s no scandal.

It’s a design and corporate legal issue presently.

In the end CSAM protection will work like this.

Parents and guardians will enable CSAM protection on their children’s devices.

Everyone else can choose not to use it and if they upload any illegal images on iCloud/iMessage servers then the images will be scanned on the server side, the evidence will be quarantined so that Apple is legally cleared, and the user willl be reported to the authorities.

Simple.

Dropbox, Google, Microsoft has been detecting such material on their servers for half a decade using PhotoDNA.

 

you guys should check this suite of software that protect of malware and unwanted connections.

It's free open-source software, very light on ressources and works on older macOS too!

also no, macOS is not secure, it is famous for some of the most ridiculous bugs

like the empty password bug
Patrick's book, The Art of Mac Malware, is a great read so far
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbital~debris
There’s no scandal.

It’s a design and corporate legal issue presently.

In the end CSAM protection will work like this.

Parents and guardians will enable CSAM protection on their children’s devices.

Everyone else can choose not to use it and if they upload any illegal images on iCloud/iMessage servers then the images will be scanned on the server side, the evidence will be quarantined so that Apple is legally cleared, and the user willl be reported to the authorities.

Simple.

Dropbox, Google, Microsoft has been detecting such material on their servers for half a decade using PhotoDNA.


The whole point of this thought exercise was what would happen if Apple turned on CSAM secretly on users' devices.

Secretly, as in "without knowledge of users".

THAT would be the scandal, not CSAM itself.

If it's implemented secretly, how will parents know to turn it on?

If it's implemented secretly, how will others know to choose to use it or not?
 
The whole point of this thought exercise was what would happen if Apple turned on CSAM secretly on users' devices.

Secretly, as in "without knowledge of users".

THAT would be the scandal, not CSAM itself.

If it's implemented secretly, how will parents know to turn it on?

If it's implemented secretly, how will others know to choose to use it or not?

I said ‘In the end’ because right now by design it emphasizes protecting Apple from legal action. It should balance in the end by protecting Apple on the server side and give power to parents to enable it on family devices.

On school/college owned devices it should be enabled by default.
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: foliovision
Just curious as I don't really use my Macbook often, is it worth it to get a 3rd party malware and/or antivirus suite for MacOS, or is it secure enough to just run without any additional software?
 
I said ‘In the end’ because right now by design it emphasizes protecting Apple from legal action. It should balance in the end by protecting Apple on the server side and give power to parents to enable it on family devices.

On school/college owned devices it should be enabled by default.
Ok, but in that case, your comment had nothing to do with the comment you replied to :)
 
I’m fairly certain that Malwarebytes was causing kernel panics on my Mac and in my experience third party antivirus are the mostly likely types of software to do that. I uninstalled it and the random restarts nearly ceased immediately. I didn’t even have Malwarebytes in an active state (Scanning was turned off, etc) so, it can be tricky.
I have seen that happen with a few Macs that come into my work. What I would do is start up in Safe Mode and perform the scan there. For some reason, Malwarebytes would get hung on some sort of system process/files when just sitting in the background. Uninstalling and Reinstalling would normally fix the issue.
 
Just curious as I don't really use my Macbook often, is it worth it to get a 3rd party malware and/or antivirus suite for MacOS, or is it secure enough to just run without any additional software?
It's not really necessary. Just don't install anything stupid like MacKeeper, TotalAV, or some cleaner app. Be aware of random browser extensions that pop up, any random profiles shown in System Preferences, and Green search magnifying glass icons in your Applications folder.

b667db13-3a3e-41d2-a163-96ab6e59275e.png


Malwarebytes is pretty good that removing this kind of crap though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: spinedoc77
So do we need to keep running Malwarebytes? Apple tech told me a couple of years ago to always run the program, but if I can drop a program, I'd love to. Thanks.
 
It’s based on a hybrid Mach kernel.

An operating system’s kernel and base system says nothing about security.

All operating systems get attacks and all operating systems need to update security holes and add malware protection.

It will be like this forever.

In the next wave people will be learning to hack into and causing denial of service attacks on AI systems which are almost exclusively running on Linux.

I don't know anyone uses Linux needs malware protection or whatever protection
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.