Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


Apple and Amazon are facing a new UK opt-out class action seeking more than £900 million ($1.2 billion) over claims that the companies struck an unlawful deal that pushed independent Apple and Beats sellers off Amazon and kept prices higher for consumers.

amazon-black-friday.jpeg

The claim centers on an agreement from October 2018, from which point it is alleged that Amazon restricted third-party sellers from offering Apple products on Amazon's marketplace, while Apple gave Amazon better wholesale terms for Apple products sold directly by Amazon as a retailer. The lawsuit claims that by January 2019, most independent Apple resellers had effectively disappeared from Amazon, reducing discounted listings and leaving consumers paying closer to full price.

The proposed class includes UK consumers who bought new Apple products since October 2018, whether from Amazon or other retailers, on the basis that the alleged conduct affected prices more broadly. It covers Apple hardware and Beats products, plus accessories, but it excludes Apple products bought as part of mobile network contracts.

This is not the first attempt at a case over the same issue. A similar case was triggered in the United States in 2022. Collective action was brought forward in the UK in 2023, but the tribunal did not allow it to proceed. The new filing argues the core competition allegations remain strong and should be heard with a different proposed class representative and structure.

Article Link: Apple Hit With Another Lawsuit Over Alleged Collusion With Amazon to Keep Prices High
 
Left unsaid: resellers were flooding Amazon with counterfeit Apple hardware.
I don't think that'll stand up as a valid reason. Amazon is flooded with all kinds of garbage, knock-off, and counterfeit listings. They do some work to prevent it, but probably not nearly enough. The sheer quantity of garbage "brands" that stand up one week and are gone the next should speak volumes about how much Amazon cares about counterfeits and knock offs.
 
I don't think that'll stand up as a valid reason. Amazon is flooded with all kinds of garbage, knock-off, and counterfeit listings. They do some work to prevent it, but probably not nearly enough. The sheer quantity of garbage "brands" that stand up one week and are gone the next should speak volumes about how much Amazon cares about counterfeits and knock offs.
At the time of the deal between Apple and Amazon, it was reported that Apple contacted Amazon because of the many counterfeit Apple products being sold on Amazon.

Apple filed a lawsuit against an Amazon third party selling counterfeit products, and in 2018 (to avoid a lawsuit) Amazon formed an agreement with Apple to combat rampant fakes. The deal allowed only Apple authorized sellers on the platform.
 
I don't think that'll stand up as a valid reason. Amazon is flooded with all kinds of garbage, knock-off, and counterfeit listings. They do some work to prevent it, but probably not nearly enough. The sheer quantity of garbage "brands" that stand up one week and are gone the next should speak volumes about how much Amazon cares about counterfeits and knock offs.

How does the rest of your comment support the first sentence? Apple doesn’t want counterfeit products being sold and Amazon doesn’t care about selling counterfeit products, so how is it “anticompetitive” for Apple to seek an agreement with Amazon?
 
  • Love
  • Like
Reactions: SFjohn and Stevez67
At the time of the deal between Apple and Amazon, it was reported that Apple contacted Amazon because of the many counterfeit Apple products being sold on Amazon.

Apple filed a lawsuit against an Amazon third party selling counterfeit products, and in 2018 (to avoid a lawsuit) Amazon formed an agreement with Apple to combat rampant fakes. The deal allowed only Apple authorized sellers on the platform.

I bought a pair of AirPods from Apple's official Amazon store and still got counterfeit. Had no problem swapping, though, and and my next set was real.
 
Last edited:
I sure ain't complaining. Amazon is the first real sales I've ever seen on apple products. Half the time I can pick up stuff for less than using my friends apple discount.

Are you talking about the UK Amazon site? This lawsuit is only about amazon.co.uk and as others have said, you almost never see reductions exceeding 5% on Apple hardware on that site. The US site is quite different, there are often significant reductions.
 
  • Love
Reactions: SFjohn
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.