I'm going to make the case for the iPad in business.
I've been in many different types of business roles, and I've seen the usefulness of the iPad directly correlate with how much I need to interact with people. Working as an analyst, the iPad had very little use because the financial modeling can only be done on a PC, and most of my time was spent by myself researching. Contrast that to being a manager, spending a lot of my time on my feet interacting with people, the iPad is very useful. In this type of role, the software doesn't need to be as sophisticated because my ideas are at a higher level. I don't need the precision of a mouse, or a keyboard to type out a report. I need something unobtrusive. A way to take notes while visiting colleagues and also share what I'm working on. Or sketch out a mind map of an idea for someone. Could you imagine me carrying around my MacBook doing these things? It would be very awkward. The iPad replaces the pad of paper that I would have on me, but removes the need for me to add it to my computer when I get back.
I suspect that most people on technology message boards generally fall into categories where the iPad would be less useful, so there's some bias there.
Tim Cook has a lot of good things to say about the iPad, for obvious reasons. But stop to think what his typical day is like, and why he probably uses the iPad more than his computer. His productivity is in the form of managing people, making deals, etc. It's beyond the level of a PC. Compare that to a programmer whose level of productivity depends on the PC.
I've been in many different types of business roles, and I've seen the usefulness of the iPad directly correlate with how much I need to interact with people. Working as an analyst, the iPad had very little use because the financial modeling can only be done on a PC, and most of my time was spent by myself researching. Contrast that to being a manager, spending a lot of my time on my feet interacting with people, the iPad is very useful. In this type of role, the software doesn't need to be as sophisticated because my ideas are at a higher level. I don't need the precision of a mouse, or a keyboard to type out a report. I need something unobtrusive. A way to take notes while visiting colleagues and also share what I'm working on. Or sketch out a mind map of an idea for someone. Could you imagine me carrying around my MacBook doing these things? It would be very awkward. The iPad replaces the pad of paper that I would have on me, but removes the need for me to add it to my computer when I get back.
I suspect that most people on technology message boards generally fall into categories where the iPad would be less useful, so there's some bias there.
Tim Cook has a lot of good things to say about the iPad, for obvious reasons. But stop to think what his typical day is like, and why he probably uses the iPad more than his computer. His productivity is in the form of managing people, making deals, etc. It's beyond the level of a PC. Compare that to a programmer whose level of productivity depends on the PC.