Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


A federal jury for the U.S. District Court for Northern California today found Apple to be infringing upon a pair of wireless patents owned by Core Wireless, a patent holding firm with a large portfolio of more than 1,200 patents and applications, originally filed and later acquired from phone maker Nokia.

ipad_iphone_ios_8.jpg
 
As people often note, $7.3 million is sofa change for Apple.

Core Wireless also won against LG for similar infringements in Android earlier this year, for about $3.5 million.

I wonder how much Core paid for these patents, and if they've made a profit on them yet.
 
While 7.3 million dollar is literally nothing to Apple, they will appeal the first one simply because of the ramifications for all phone companies and really for the future of all wirelessly connected devices if they don't.

As for the labor one, many employers fail to provide the required breaks and it is time we held all companies accountable for it, including Apple.
 
Queue the "Tim needs to go" comments. You guys realize that these issues are from before Tim was CEO?
[doublepost=1481837245][/doublepost]
Over as in what? Last i checked AAPL stock is up today, and close to its 52 week high. US stock market is also at an all time high.

Are you in touch with your sense of humor?
 
Quick question about patent lawsuits and awards...

Let's say Apple has to pay the $7.3 million to Core Wireless for using their patents.

Is that just a one-time thing? Then can Apple keep using those patents in the future?
 
Is that just a one-time thing? Then can Apple keep using those patents in the future?

I have not read this case in detail, but I'm pretty sure this was an award only for past infringement through 2015.

Since the lawsuit covered all 3G enabled iPhones and iPads up until then, I'm guessing that the jury awarded Core Wireless about one cent per each of about 730 million units sold. (I think that Core had asked for a little over three cents each.)

Going forward, Apple will have to negotiate a royalty rate, which might be about the same penny per device.

However, since these patents are reportedly only used for 3G, then as 3G disappears over time, so would the need to pay.
 
Last edited:
I have not read this case in detail, but I'm pretty sure this was an award only for past infringement through 2015.

Since the lawsuit covered all 3G enabled iPhones and iPads up until then, I'm guessing that the jury awarded Core Wireless about one cent per each of about 730 million units sold. (I think that Core had asked for a little over three cents each.)

Going forward, Apple will have to negotiate a royalty rate, which might be about the same penny per device.

However, since these patents are reportedly only used for 3G, then as 3G disappears over time, so would the need to pay.

Ok thanks!

There have been plenty of these "you must pay a fine for using someone else's patents" cases.

But I always wondered what happens after the court case.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.