Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Apple M1 Hands-On Comparison: MacBook Air vs. MacBook Pro vs. Mac Mini

MacRumors

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
64,104
31,778


Apple's M1 Macs are out in the wild now, but ahead of the holidays, you might still be trying to figure out which one to pick up, either for yourself or as a gift for someone else. We've got all three of the new Macs available, so we thought we'd give MacRumors readers a hands-on overview of each machine in our latest YouTube video.


Price wise, the Mac mini is the cheapest of the bunch at $699, while the MacBook Air starts at $999 and the MacBook Pro starts at $1,299. With the Mac mini you do, of course, need to provide all of your own peripherals, including display, mouse, and keyboard at minimum.

mac-mini-macbook-pro-macbook-air.jpg

If you already have those on hand, the Mac mini is potentially the way to go. For the notebooks, the MacBook Air is lighter, but there's not a huge amount of difference in size between the Air and the Pro.

The entry-level MacBook Air has a 7-core GPU while the entry-level MacBook Pro has an 8-core GPU, which is why the price is a bit higher. If you get the 512GB SSD with the MacBook Air, you get upgraded to that 8-core GPU automatically.

m1-macs-cpu-benchmarks.jpg

There are some thermal differences between the M1 Macs, but most people may not be able to distinguish between them when it comes to performance. The Mac mini has the most space for heat dissipation, while the MacBook Pro has a fan for better thermal management.

m1-mac-gpu-benchmark.jpg

The MacBook Air, meanwhile, has no fan. You may see some slightly better sustained performance when doing system intensive tasks on the Macs with better cooling, but there's not a whole ton of difference between them. In most benchmark tests, they're all just about the same, and they're all huge upgrades over their Intel counterparts. Watch our M1 MacBook Pro vs. 2020 MacBook Pro test below to see.


As for upgrades, there's not a lot available. You can bump up the SSD storage, which is a good idea if you plan to use onboard storage and want a machine that's going to have enough space for years to come, but you can also work with external SSDs if you opt for the 256GB minimum.

blackmagic-disk-speed-test-m1-macs.jpg

You can also upgrade the RAM on each M1 Mac from 8GB to 16GB. If you have the extra $200, it's a good idea to do so for futureproofing and because you're never going to go wrong having extra RAM. This year's Macs have unified memory architecture which basically means all of the chip components can draw from the same memory pool, bringing some speed and efficiency improvements.

Apple is excellent at optimizing RAM usage and there's no exception here. You may not even need 16GB because in our testing, the M1 Macs are super quick even with the built-in 8GB.

All of the M1 Macs offer incredible performance at their price points, and in our testing, they've all outshone their Intel counterparts. macOS Big Sur runs great on the M1 Macs, and apps built for Apple Silicon are fast and efficient. Even apps not built for Apple Silicon and running under the Rosetta 2 translation layer are close to as fast as they are on Intel machines.

m1-mac-mini.jpg

If you rely on specific Windows apps and regularly use Boot Camp, the M1 Macs are not for you. There is no way to run Windows on an M1 Mac at this time. CrossOver does allow for some Windows apps to be used, but this solution may not be worth the effort for heavy Windows users.

Touch ID also seems to be quicker on the M1 Macs in comparison to Intel Macs, and even small tasks like waking from sleep or switching resolutions are instantaneous. All of the Macs are close to whisper quiet. The MacBook Air makes no sound at all, while the Mac mini and the MacBook Pro rarely activate their fans even under intensive tasks.

Apple has made some serious battery life promises with the M1 Macs, and the MacBook Pro can last for up to 20 hours. We've seen that impressive battery life in day to day usage. Intel Macs have never been able to hold up to editing a video with a decent amount of battery life to spare, but the M1 Macs have no problem.

m1-macbook-air-1.jpg

The M1 Macs are amazing so far, but it's worth keeping in mind that these are first generation machines. Apple is upgrading the entire Mac lineup to Apple Silicon chips, a process expect to take two years. These are low-end Macs that have been refreshed, and there are some more exciting, higher-end Mac refreshes in the works which could be one reason to hold out on a purchase right now.

One other consideration is design. Apple did not update the design of the new Macs, and there are some design changes rumored to be in the works for the MacBook Pro at a minimum. A fresh design could also be worth the wait.

macbook-pro-vs-macbook-air.jpg

If you need an affordable Mac for everyday tasks, the M1 Macs are a solid choice. The Mac mini is the one to get if you want a desktop, and if you need a notebook, the MacBook Air is going to work for most people. The MacBook Pro has an extra GPU core in the base model, a brighter display, and better speakers, which is a consideration. We have a full guide on the MacBook Air vs. the MacBook Pro if you're trying to choose between them.

Do you have an M1 Mac or are you going to buy one? Are you holding out for next year's Apple Silicon offerings? Let us know in the comments.

Article Link: Apple M1 Hands-On Comparison: MacBook Air vs. MacBook Pro vs. Mac Mini
 
Article Link
https://www.macrumors.com/2020/11/23/apple-m1-hands-on-comparison-macbook-air-vs-macbook-pro-vs-mac-mini/
  • Like
Reactions: adrianlondon
dogslobber

dogslobber

macrumors 601
Oct 19, 2014
4,670
7,808
Apple Campus, Cupertino CA
There are a few big issues. First the Air is throttled after a short period of time so it isn't as powerful as the MBP due to lack of a fan. The MBP has the dreaded and derided Touchbar for which most people find it horrendous. The Mini isn't portable so you can't use it on the go. All of the laptops have chunky bezels from the 1990s.

So each is neutered in some way or another.
 
  • Disagree
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: MauricioJaramil, polaris20, Pummers and 17 others
G

ghanwani

macrumors 601
Dec 8, 2008
4,679
5,886
MacRumors said:
Do you have an M1 Mac or are you going to buy one? Are you holding out for next year's Apple Silicon offerings? Let us know in the comments.
Click to expand...
Since you asked, I am planning to buy the MBA mostly for its battery life. I need to decide between base vs base with 512 GB. I won't wait for next years offerings. If they are that good, I'll trade again. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: brucemr
S

scupking

macrumors 6502a
Dec 14, 2010
784
385
Was thinking of getting an 11inch iPad Pro next year to replace my 2010 mbp and 7th gen iPad. Now I might stick with my 7th gen iPad and get an M1 air with 512gb and 16gb of ram.
 
  • Like
Reactions: newyorksole
C

citysnaps

Suspended
Oct 10, 2011
12,071
26,131
dogslobber said:
There are a few big issues. First the Air is throttled after a short period of time so it isn't as powerful as the MBP due to lack of a fan. The MBP has the dreaded and derided Touchbar for which most people find it horrendous. The Mini isn't portable so you can't use it on the go. All of the laptops have chunky bezels from the 1990s.

So each is neutered in some way or another.
Click to expand...

Damn, I have an MBA on order. And now you're telling me it's going to be hobbled discovering the next prime number. Thanks a lot Tim Cook! Wah...
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: FriendlyMackle, secretbum, jdb8167 and 9 others
C

cknibbs

macrumors 6502
Dec 12, 2012
288
830
I’d love a 15” MacBook Air if they made one. I’m also sad they got rid of the space grey Mac mini case for the M1. However the M1 is a beast, and that much performance in the MBA is nuts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jdawgnoonan
Chompineer

Chompineer

Suspended
Mar 31, 2020
502
1,182
Ontario
dogslobber said:
There are a few big issues. First the Air is throttled after a short period of time so it isn't as powerful as the MBP due to lack of a fan. The MBP has the dreaded and derided Touchbar for which most people find it horrendous. The Mini isn't portable so you can't use it on the go. All of the laptops have chunky bezels from the 1990s.

So each is neutered in some way or another.
Click to expand...

I don’t think you were using computers in the 90’s if you think that’s what the bezels were like, lol. For one, they were like 10x larger and covered in beige plastic.

Also the air throttles after what, 8-10 minutes of 100% load? Big deal. I’m not using it for anything that would generate a load so large and for so long, nor are 99% of laptop users.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
  • Disagree
Reactions: axcess99, darkharbour, istvan and 35 others
M

Macbookprodude

Suspended
Jan 1, 2018
3,306
898
I will wait for the 15 inch to come out.. but I have my doubts about the validity of Apple's claims that these are really faster than Intel.. Maybe they are, maybe they arent. I am sure the pricing is a lot lower.
 
RumorConsumer

RumorConsumer

macrumors 68000
Jun 16, 2016
1,617
1,117
"If you need an affordable Mac for everyday tasks, the M1 Macs are a solid choice."

Every day tasks! These things kick the crap out of the maxed out MacBook Pro 16" Im working on AND the maxed out iMac 2020 in the corner of this room. Both these machines were purchased to offer as much performance as possible. The Air, quite frankly, is a video editing monster as it is right now in its puny 8gb configuration.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SantaFeNM, darkharbour, dcinema and 9 others
AxiomaticRubric

AxiomaticRubric

macrumors 6502a
Sep 24, 2010
941
1,145
On Mars, Praising the Omnissiah
Macbookprodude said:
I will wait for the 15 inch to come out.. but I have my doubts about the validity of Apple's claims that these are really faster than Intel.. Maybe they are, maybe they arent. I am sure the pricing is a lot lower.
Click to expand...

The pricing is interesting. The entry level models are priced similar to the Intel counterparts, but there is serious savings on the fully maxed out storage and memory options (which were already hyperinflated for the Intel models).
 
A

applicious84

macrumors 6502a
Sep 1, 2020
521
1,090
dogslobber said:
There are a few big issues. First the Air is throttled after a short period of time so it isn't as powerful as the MBP due to lack of a fan. The MBP has the dreaded and derided Touchbar for which most people find it horrendous. The Mini isn't portable so you can't use it on the go. All of the laptops have chunky bezels from the 1990s.

So each is neutered in some way or another.
Click to expand...
I like how you say neutered with a dog avatar, lol. But, you're right about those bezels. The throttling won't matter for most people, I don't think--at least not anytime soon. It's def a 1st gen machine, so I guess they wanted to keep with their tried and tested (if aging) design to minimize other issues. I'll need a new one in a couple years.

Hopefully, they'll have ditched the touchbar at that time. Or maybe someone has made it useful with VSCode. Actually, I just thought of that. Does any one know if that's a thing, the touchbar with VSCode?
 
T

trigf

Suspended
Jun 16, 2009
330
356
The entry-level ‌MacBook Air‌ has a 7-core GPU while the entry-level MacBook Pro has an 8-core GPU, which is why the price is a bit higher. If you get the 512GB SSD with the ‌MacBook Air‌, you get upgraded to that 8-core GPU automatically.
Click to expand...

Again, more false information. There is a 7 core GPU version with the 512 GB SSD, and there is an 8 core GPU verison with the 512 GB SSD There is no "automatic" upgrade to the 8 core version if you select the 512 GB SSD as a build option on the 7 core GPU machine. This is just like last week when you said the Pro is only $50 more, but neglected to mention the $200 needed to bring the storage back up to the same amount as the Air.

Screen Shot 2020-11-23 at 5.09.56 PM.png
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom