and what if your sim card is damaged as well?
This sucks - Apple are picking and choosing what 'damage' they will replace and what they won't entirely arbitrarily.
I cracked my screen and am willing to pay apply either to fix it - OR - a fair price for an exchange, bearing in mind they will take my old phone, fix it, and then sell it on no doubt at a profit anyway...
A screen costs like $5 - and they aren't too hard to replace - yet apple told me I would have to pay for an entirely new phone AND hand in my old one.
And of course if I decide to fix the thing myself, it voids the damn warranty (which doesn't cover screens in he first place (WTF?)...
Apparantly I was told by Apple they can't touch the screens as doing a screen replacement isn't in line with their Green Policy... WOW - get a grip. I don't care about green - the majority of Apple customers don't give a damn about green.
Since when did we all decide we were willing to pay a premium and get ram raided for cash on repairs etc for 'green'...
I'm really losing patience with Apple. If they don't change policies, and get their act together with other things (FW with Macbooks, over-pricing, seeming lack of quality control on products that leave the factory (I went through 4 macbooks before I got one that was perfect - i.e. what I paid for)) - if they don't sort out their shop I'll be buying a Dell and Blackberry - and I won't look back with any anxiety that I made a bad choice.
If you're irresponsible enough with your $500 toy to give it water damage then you shouldn't deserve to get another one when it breaks. $199 isn't cheap anyways, this isn't anything to be excited over. Just get a cheaper, more appropriate phone, if you can't handle expensive items.
Oh please tell me fanboys aren't sucked into their stupid PR things like this so easily. It's exactly the same as buying a new one, which is something you've always been able to do, except you give them your old broken one in return. If microsoft did this i'm sure there'd be pages of posts about people laughing at them because of this point, but fanboys just go '<3 apple' and think it's great, not even questioning the logic of it. In fact, you can do this with any product, go and get a new one for the buying price. Seriously.
How is $199 exactly like buying a new one again?
I believe you spend 500 and 600 to replace before this....
Ya, but what I'm saying is you guys are still acting like $199 is still cheap and something to be excited about when it's exactly still the opposite - anyone who gets water damage on their phone is just plain irresponsible...
is this just for water damage, or for any damage? like the silent switch not working anymore?
Ya, but what I'm saying is you guys are still acting like $199 is still cheap and something to be excited about when it's exactly still the opposite - anyone who gets water damage on their phone is just plain irresponsible, and they shouldn't deserve to be spending big money on things like cellular devices when they are going to be careless about it and break it in the end.
How is $199 exactly like buying a new one again?
I believe you spend 500 and 600 to replace before this....
and what if your sim card is damaged as well?
and what if your sim card is damaged as well?
is this just for water damage, or for any damage? like the silent switch not working anymore?
If your sim card is damaged on an iphone contract in the UK 02 will replace it for free.
I've yet to see this reported anywhere else, and it's not confirmed by any press releases on the Apple website. I wish I knew the source.
FWIW- I lost my first iPhone 3G to the rain, even while my phone was in my pocket. I tried turning it off, but it kept turning itself back on because the water had gotten into the unprotected dock connector. Yanking the battery would have probably prevented permanent damage, but yeah... battery is buried inside, and merely trying to access it voids the warranty.
To note: I got quoted all sorts of different prices from ATT / Apple for a replacement 16GB phone: from $500 to $700. I eventually just upgraded another line that was eligible.
My question: I wonder what this policy will look like after next iPhone? I've seen the rumors of ATT working on a "phone trade in" program... is this it? Or will there be an upgrade / trade-in path for iPhone 3G to iPhone 3rdgen?
Assuming this story is valid, I wonder if it would be better to water damage swap, and hope to be qualified for upgrade pricing to iPhone 3rdgen, or would it be better just wait and see.
- tollie