Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Aethelstan

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Aug 18, 2020
11
1
I have a question for the community here: I have an older iPad Air 2 which fits my needs perfectly well as I use my MacBook Air for most of my work-related tasks. I’m an elementary school teacher and in Los Angeles we are delivering instruction remotely. As for distance learning, we will have the option of using either Zoom or Google Meets. I prefer Zoom and like its virtual whiteboard. I’d like to use my iPad to write on the virtual whiteboard as using a trackpad on the MacBook Air or even a mouse simply is too cumbersome. Are there digital pens that can be used with my older iPad, and will I be able to write effectively for students to take notes. Or do I need to upgrade to a newer model to get the benefits? I also looked at the Surface Go, but as a longtime Mac user, I prefer to stick with Apple.
 

sracer

macrumors G4
Apr 9, 2010
10,372
13,199
where hip is spoken
I have a question for the community here: I have an older iPad Air 2 which fits my needs perfectly well as I use my MacBook Air for most of my work-related tasks. I’m an elementary school teacher and in Los Angeles we are delivering instruction remotely. As for distance learning, we will have the option of using either Zoom or Google Meets. I prefer Zoom and like its virtual whiteboard. I’d like to use my iPad to write on the virtual whiteboard as using a trackpad on the MacBook Air or even a mouse simply is too cumbersome. Are there digital pens that can be used with my older iPad, and will I be able to write effectively for students to take notes. Or do I need to upgrade to a newer model to get the benefits? I also looked at the Surface Go, but as a longtime Mac user, I prefer to stick with Apple.
The Air 2 is quite old by iPad standards. But if you are committed to keeping it, there are a few options that will work. The non-powered capacitive styli generally have a fat rubber or mesh tip. Not so good for use on a digital whiteboard.

There are others, like the Adonit Jot that have a fine tip with a clear disc. That's a bit better for finer control, but it is a bit disconcerting to use as it isn't natural to have that clear disc, and it is pretty noisy as the plastic taps on the screen.

There are powered bluetooth styli that have fine pointed tip. These work well, but they are usually only supported by some apps (they aren't universally supported by all apps on the iPad).

Last, there are powered capacitive styli. These are essentially like the rubber tipped styli in that they are recognized by any and all apps and usable wherever a finger tap/touch is recognized. But these have a traditional fine tipped point.

The Adonit Dash 3 is the one that I have and use... and it is extremely good given the limitations of the technology. I use it on my iPad Mini 4 (that doesn't support the Apple Pencil) and use it with documents that I share on my 6th gen iPad (that DOES support the Apple Pencil).

Powered capacitive styli don't support pressure sensitivity or palm rejection, but some note-taking apps have their own palm-rejection logic in them that really help. I am delighted that I can use the Adonit Dash 3 on my iPad Mini 4 for handwritten notes in a nearly identical way that I use the Apple Pencil on my 6th gen iPad.

 
  • Like
Reactions: secretk

AutomaticApple

Suspended
Nov 28, 2018
7,401
3,378
Massachusetts
Will it be accurate enough for writing as you would on a traditional whiteboard? Also, any recommendations on the stylus that will give the best results?
I would recommend this one.
 

ericwn

macrumors G5
Apr 24, 2016
12,056
10,843
Great conversation! I haven’t used anything but the Apple Pencil on iPad for years and before that only had some really cheap stylus things in the household- those were night and day compared to the Apple Pencil.

If you like handwriting notes, I believe there are more pencil features coming with that iOS 14 update, maybe consider a new iPad with the pencil (14 day return period to try it out :) ) - any current iPad is a decent-great note taking machine.
 

ericwn

macrumors G5
Apr 24, 2016
12,056
10,843

tamara6

macrumors regular
Apr 28, 2004
225
137
I'm curious how this will work with zoom. Do you plan to use both your ipad and your macbook air at the same time, or will you be zooming only with the ipad?
 

Aethelstan

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Aug 18, 2020
11
1
I'm curious how this will work with zoom. Do you plan to use both your ipad and your macbook air at the same time, or will you be zooming only with the ipad?
I’m thinking of reserving the MacBook Air to create my lesson plans using Office which the district provides. I’m hoping to use the iPad for instruction as the battery lasts longer and I was hoping to use a stylus for the virtual whiteboard feature.
[automerge]1597849836[/automerge]
 

The1andOnly

macrumors regular
Aug 2, 2020
162
93
There are powered bluetooth styli that have fine pointed tip. These work well, but they are usually only supported by some apps (they aren't universally supported by all apps on the iPad).
True. I used the one from “53” for a few weeks. The tip was too mushy, in addition to the fact that the stylus only fully worked with 53’s Paper app. It did, however, support pressure sensitivity and drawing angle (within the app).
 
  • Like
Reactions: sracer
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.