It wasn't rumor or speculation, it was a working -n card under Windows. That's called a fact, which is much different than rumor or speculation.
You're still missing the point that that status was never promised to you. It doesn't matter what other people experienced--you can't base buying decisions on anecdotal evidence (truthful or otherwise).
Perhaps, a counter-example would be helpful. Please describe any other piece of hardware in a Mac that is working, but at a purposely diminished level.
That's precisely the point. This is the first and only instance where Apple shipped out hardware without the software to take full advantage of it. Had the software been ready, it would have been sold as pre-n from the beginning.
Sure, nothing is guaranteed in life. Apple has just never chosen to charge for a driver before. Ever.
And they've never shipped incomplete hardware before, either. It doesn't indicate a new direction. Single events do not make trends.
Apple is now charging for improved hardware drivers. That changes its value model.
How? It shipped hardware that was feature-complete as advertised (but with latent, unrealized hardware), and then needed to find a way to activate the superior-than-reported hardware without raising suspicion. If you prefer, they could have never released the enabler and left these customers out in the cold entirely.
But they're still charging $2 for -n as an add-on if you go and buy a new machine today. So they're either lying about the SarBox requirement or nickle-and-diming new buyers.
According to whom? Furthermore, does the product indicate that it has 802.11n capabilities? If it doesn't, from where exactly do you draw your entitlement?
You're confused about what a driver is. They don't enable hardware. They provide an interface for an operating system to access hardware resources.
And without one, you can't use the hardware. Again, I ask, how could they enable 802.11n capabilities without a driver to do so?
(and all these machines came with a man page describing those features)
My PowerBook G4 also has man pages on it describing 802.11n operation. They came with developer updates. Does that mean my G4 has the capability, too? Maybe you're confused about what man pages are. They're generic manuals for software commands, not evidence of specifications.