Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The Echo Dot is so popular and main stream now simply due to its price point and ‘it’s good enough’ niche group. Whoever is happy with the Echo won’t be in the market for a HomePod. I can see those who like the Sonos and want to use this for mostly music to gravitate towards this.
 
Some of the adverse comments here closely track what was said about Apple's AirPods announcement in late 2016. Not shocked.

That tells me HomePod will be a huge success. Looking forward to purchasing one. And likely a second unit assuming I'm jazzed about the first.
 
I agree that this is a Sonos competitor first and foremost. I have an Echo and its sound quality isn’t that great. And chances are HomePod’s Siri integration will be better than the Sonos Play One’s Alexa integration. Reviews state that it’s more finicky than an Echo.

But Sonos can be integrated into your home theater using a Playbar or Playbaze and plays nice with the most comprehensive set of third party music services. For example, it’s the only one to support Apple Music. Those advantages will be difficult to overcome.
 
I picked up a pair of the Google Home Max after the Apple delay. The sound is quite good when grouped as a stereo pair, although they are not going to replace your $10k speaker setup. The microphones are amazing though, I can whisper from across the room and they pick everything up perfectly.

The Apple homepod is less than half the size and weight of each Max, so I wonder how good of a sound physics will allow.
 
Last edited:
zzzzzzz. Who cares? They're so late to market there's no hope of overtaking Amazon or Google. Especially at that price point. Yeah, a few people will buy them, but like someone above said, it's too little too late.
Nonsense, Apple never goes for market share, all those market share leaders almost never lead in revenue. Apple was a successful company selling 5% of computers before ipods, iphones and ipads
 
  • Like
Reactions: chabig
I agree that this is a Sonos competitor first and foremost. I have an Echo and its sound quality isn’t that great. And chances are HomePod’s Siri integration will be better than the Sonos Play One’s Alexa integration. Reviews state that it’s more finicky than an Echo.

But Sonos can be integrated into your home theater using a Playbar or Playbaze and plays nice with the most comprehensive set of third party music services. For example, it’s the only one to support Apple Music. Those advantages will be difficult to overcome.

All you need is a Sonos Connect for an existing home theater. In addition to offering speakers and sound bars, Sonos has two speaker-less options. Connect connects to an existing amp and utilizes the existing speakers and the Connect:Amp has a built-in amp and allows you to connect whatever speakers you want. When it comes to serious audio and home theater, Sonos is definitely the best choice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nt5672
Agree. My only complaint about my system is that is an ordeal to turn everything on, set it up, choose your effects, etc. so many adjustments can be made that it’s never just turn it on and listen for a few minutes.

If you are looking for a sub, look no further.

PowerSoundAudio
Maybe we can take this to PM as it's getting off-topic - but I'd ask here:

I live in the second floor unit of a two-familly house. The people that live below me are pretty cool, but I don't want to annoy them with a sub; low frequencies tend to travel even through the best insulated walls.

Is there a way to get "directional" sub that doesn't fire down as much as it fires up? Or, is there a mat I can get that lessens the amount that goes down? You know what I mean?
 



Ahead of the promised "early 2018" launch of the HomePod, Apple has received official FCC approval for the smart speaker. Now that FCC approval has been obtained, Apple is free to begin selling the device at any time.

All devices that use communications technologies like Bluetooth and Wi-Fi must be submitted to the United States Federal Communications Commission to ensure compliance with federal regulations before they're eligible to be sold in the United States. That FCC approval has been obtained suggests the HomePod will launch in the near future.

fcclabel.jpg

For comparison's sake, Apple received FCC approval for the iPhone X on October 4, just under one month before the device was released to the public on November 3.

Today's FCC clearance of the HomePod follows a rumor earlier this week suggesting HomePod supplier Inventec has already started shipping HomePod units to Apple. Apple is reportedly set to receive "about 1 million" HomePod devices and an industry source that spoke to the Taipei Times, the source of the rumor, has said that the HomePod is coming "soon."

Apple originally planned to release the HomePod in December, but the company ended up requiring additional development time, delaying its debut until 2018. Apple has said the HomePod will ship out to customers in the US, UK, and Australia in "early 2018."

HomePod-on-shelf-800x451-800x451.jpg

Early 2018, by Apple's historical definition, is something of a broad window. Apple considers "early 2018" to be the period between January and April, so it's been tough to narrow down the prospective launch date of the HomePod. Given the shipment rumors and the FCC approval, however, we may see the device in late January or early February rather than later in the year.

Like many new Apple products, rumors suggest initial supplies of the HomePod could be constrained at launch. Inventec is expecting revenue from the HomePod to be "limited" during Q1 2018 due to a low quantity of HomePod devices available for shipment.

Article Link: Apple Receives FCC Approval for HomePod, Suggesting a Launch Could Come Soon
i wonder if a government shutdown would have delayed the homepod if this had not been released today.
 
The Echo Dot is so popular and main stream now simply due to its price point and ‘it’s good enough’ niche group. Whoever is happy with the Echo won’t be in the market for a HomePod. I can see those who like the Sonos and want to use this for mostly music to gravitate towards this.

As someone who has Sonos, I see no reason to consider switching. HomePod offers no advantages over my existing setup. Plus it has one major disadvantage (from what I can tell). I have a few Sonos Play speakers, but I also have a Sonos Connect connected to my home theater setup and a Connect:Amp driving my living room’s in-ceiling speakers. I can’t replicate this setup with Apple’s offerings, so when it comes time to add another speaker or buy a smart speaker, I’ll stick with Sonos.
 
I have a few Sonos Play speakers, but I also have a Sonos Connect connected to my home theater setup and a Connect:Amp driving my living room’s in-ceiling speakers. I can’t replicate this setup with Apple’s offerings, so when it comes time to add another speaker or buy a smart speaker, I’ll stick with Sonos.

Google also has this capability (to hook to your exising stereo) with the $39 Chromecast audio. Ideally, you could get this functionality from Apple with the HomePod and a revised version of the Airport Express.
 
Last edited:
Google also has this with the Chromecast audio. Ideally you could get this functionality with the HomePod and a revised version of the Airport Express.

Not exactly. The Sonos Connect:Amp is an amp. With airport express (and I assume chromecast), I need to buy either crumby powered speakers that connect via a headphone jack or I need an amp. That’s the beauty of Sonos Connect:Amp. The device is an amp. I have in-ceiling speakers in several rooms and with Sonos all I need is one of those small boxes per room.

The Connect box that connects to my existing home theater amp connects via an optical cable, not a 3.5mm headphone jack. I believe airport express supports optical out, so that setup is easier to replicate. But there’s no option for a device with a built-in amp other than Sonos.
 
Maybe we can take this to PM as it's getting off-topic - but I'd ask here:

I live in the second floor unit of a two-familly house. The people that live below me are pretty cool, but I don't want to annoy them with a sub; low frequencies tend to travel even through the best insulated walls.

Is there a way to get "directional" sub that doesn't fire down as much as it fires up? Or, is there a mat I can get that lessens the amount that goes down? You know what I mean?
Yes, but anything PSA makes is going to be too annoying in a non single family house. These are really serious subs and audiophile quality. It’s probably too much in your situation. Bass frequencies will travel through walls even if they are directional, so you’ll always have to keep the volume down regardless. Sorry.
 
Curious to hear the sound quality of it. If it is indeed groundbreaking I might consider buying couple. I currently have a Bowers Wilkins A5 and it sounds great but the Airplay feature is pretty weak. Drops quite a bit. So I am interested on the HomePod.
 



Ahead of the promised "early 2018" launch of the HomePod, Apple has received official FCC approval for the smart speaker. Now that FCC approval has been obtained, Apple is free to begin selling the device at any time.

All devices that use communications technologies like Bluetooth and Wi-Fi must be submitted to the United States Federal Communications Commission to ensure compliance with federal regulations before they're eligible to be sold in the United States. That FCC approval has been obtained suggests the HomePod will launch in the near future.

fcclabel.jpg

For comparison's sake, Apple received FCC approval for the iPhone X on October 4, just under one month before the device was released to the public on November 3.

Today's FCC clearance of the HomePod follows a rumor earlier this week suggesting HomePod supplier Inventec has already started shipping HomePod units to Apple. Apple is reportedly set to receive "about 1 million" HomePod devices and an industry source that spoke to the Taipei Times, the source of the rumor, has said that the HomePod is coming "soon."

Apple originally planned to release the HomePod in December, but the company ended up requiring additional development time, delaying its debut until 2018. Apple has said the HomePod will ship out to customers in the US, UK, and Australia in "early 2018."

HomePod-on-shelf-800x451-800x451.jpg

Early 2018, by Apple's historical definition, is something of a broad window. Apple considers "early 2018" to be the period between January and April, so it's been tough to narrow down the prospective launch date of the HomePod. Given the shipment rumors and the FCC approval, however, we may see the device in late January or early February rather than later in the year.

Like many new Apple products, rumors suggest initial supplies of the HomePod could be constrained at launch. Inventec is expecting revenue from the HomePod to be "limited" during Q1 2018 due to a low quantity of HomePod devices available for shipment.

Article Link: Apple Receives FCC Approval for HomePod, Suggesting a Launch Could Come Soon
My endocrinologist will recognize the shape as the round fat diabetic look. With that white hospital look mesh yuck. Please have Johnny Ives have a chance to change that to an angular metallized rectangle like 2001 Space Odissey or a MacPro cylinder look, not the shape of great great grandpa. Sent that thing to a Spa. While you are at it, change the iPad keyboard away from the mouse fur flexible rat body that bends in all the wrong places into the Brydge keyboard that looks like an extension of a MBP. Remember, Apple, the Alumiinuuuum look. Like the iPhone, the MBP, the iPad, all silver and beautiful and thin looking.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: RogerWilco
Why couldn’t they gotten all the necessary licenses and permit before announcing the launching date?
I think this will never happen under Steve’s sleeve.
 
I am still hoping for apple to release a base/soundbar unit that has a build-in apple tv, sound bar and a truedepth camera(like faceid/ms kinect type unit), that gou can put under the tv. And perhaps a homepod mini(for rear or sidespeakers).
An a dedicated homepod sub, so i can combine to make a true 5.1 (or more) setup.
Still years away, i know. But one can dream...
Take the same route as Sonos, with a powerfull apple tv/mediaplayer/console.
 
They need to add Atmos or at least 5.1 simulated surround sound not just stereo so that with enough of these you can do true wireless surround sound. Expensive yes but less expensive then rewiring your house for maybe people
Are you one of those people that believes "technology" can solve everything you wish for? Dolby Atmos is, in effect, a 7:1 sound system. That means it requires eight strategically placed speakers. Homepod aint gonna do that with all the imagined best will in the World.
[doublepost=1516436857][/doublepost]
Maybe we can take this to PM as it's getting off-topic - but I'd ask here:

I live in the second floor unit of a two-familly house. The people that live below me are pretty cool, but I don't want to annoy them with a sub; low frequencies tend to travel even through the best insulated walls.

Is there a way to get "directional" sub that doesn't fire down as much as it fires up? Or, is there a mat I can get that lessens the amount that goes down? You know what I mean?
Are you saying "can this physical acoustic thing (sound, for those those in the know) only trouble my ears and not those down below (who also possess ears and are hindered by, you know, sound) because I like my music but don't want to trouble anyone-else?" Of course not! To even believe that is science fiction.
 
Last edited:
I am equipped with seven Sonos speakers. When listening to music, these speakers work excellently. Great sound, good response from both iOS and macOS, AppleMusic is also integrabel.
But: Playing videos (beamer or e.g. working with FCP; QT) causes delays between image and sound. There are several workarounds to compensate (software or system patch or AirPlay) but they are all annoying and/or do not always work.

Unfortunately, Sonos has not yet solved this problem with Apple.
(Who's to blame, you'll never know for sure.)

Therefore, when Apple's new boxes are properly integrated into the operating system, I will sell all my Sonos boxes and start again with Apple's HomePod.

Another aspect of this decision is my mistrust of the integrated microphones that are now listening to conversations in rooms with the current Sonos firmware. Here Apple (hopefully still for a long time) has a confidence advantage for me compared to advertising platforms like Alexa etc.
 
Last edited:
Lets see ... 350$ with a female voice that sounds like an angry rude bitch, no skills store, likely no Spotify, TuneIn etc support ever or a cheap 69€ Echo 2 that even makes my lights in the living room go blink when my Uber arrives, hmmmm
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.