Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

vdoc

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Jan 11, 2006
23
0
My PB 15" 1.5 has been at Apple for service for over a week now and it still says "part on order" when I check online. It's one of the ones that came out early 2005 so it's not like they don't have those parts somewhere. I would understand if it was an old model.

The guy at the Apple Store said 7-10 days max - I need my PB back soon!

Is this typical? What should I expect?
 

kevso

macrumors newbie
Jan 23, 2006
8
0
I'm in the exact same boat as you, I took my 15" PB to the GeniusBar on the 15th (Sunday), the factory received it three days later on the 18th, and it's been on hold ever since...the online status has been the same for almost a week now "On Hold - Part on Order".

It's starting to get ridiculous...my PB is only 6 months old and was sent in for possible logic board failure.

They told me the same estimated time of repair is "7 to 10 business days", and if by Friday nothing happens...I plan to call and complain.
 

yg17

macrumors Pentium
Aug 1, 2004
15,027
3,002
St. Louis, MO
I shipped my PowerBook out on a Thursday and got it back Monday morning.

It just needed a new keyboard, so when it got there Friday, they replaced it and shipped it the same day.
 

cnakeitaro

macrumors 6502
Jan 16, 2006
277
0
Virginia Beach
yg17 said:
I shipped my PowerBook out on a Thursday and got it back Monday morning.

It just needed a new keyboard, so when it got there Friday, they replaced it and shipped it the same day.

Wow...when I called Applecare about my broken keyboard, they just sent me a keyboard to replace it with. Told me to throw the broken one out.
 

kevso

macrumors newbie
Jan 23, 2006
8
0
cnakeitaro said:
Wow...when I called Applecare about my broken keyboard, they just sent me a keyboard to replace it with. Told me to throw the broken one out.

Heh lucky...I was already dissapointed when I was told my PB couldnt be fixed in store..if that was the case I wouldve picked it up a long time ago.

But bleh..gotta wait I guess.
 

yg17

macrumors Pentium
Aug 1, 2004
15,027
3,002
St. Louis, MO
cnakeitaro said:
Wow...when I called Applecare about my broken keyboard, they just sent me a keyboard to replace it with. Told me to throw the broken one out.


What Mac do you have? AFAIK, the iBook keyboards are user replaceable and the PB ones aren't.
 

dblissmn

macrumors 6502
Apr 30, 2002
353
107
If 7-10 days is getting to be the norm then there's some serious slippage going on at Apple.

My repair experiences include two warranty screen replacements on a TiBook, both of them 48 hour turnaround, and thoroughly diagnosing some nagging hard drive trouble, also 48 hour turnaround, with the computer deposited at Apple Stores by me; and, going back a decade, a screen shim on a PowerBook 145 (out-of-warranty recall) which involved Apple shipping an Airborne mailer to me for the computer, overnight to Apple at their expense, same-day turnaround and overnight back to me. Granted, that last one was a minor repair that they had done thousands of, but still most impressive.

I would be interested to find out the impact ProCare is having on Apple's overall repair service. The last repair I had, the second TiBook screen replacement, was done in store but it was very clear that ProCare customers were getting priority and I was fortunate to get the speedy turnaround I did (the fact that there weren't any logic board issues helped in that regard too) as they beat their target date by two days. I worry that it may be a case of ProCare getting the service everyone used to get but not better, and everyone else being dumbed down.

The other thing I'm curious about is whether Apple's service budget is getting ramped up in line with the company's overall sales.
 

kevso

macrumors newbie
Jan 23, 2006
8
0
dblissmn said:
I worry that it may be a case of ProCare getting the service everyone used to get but not better, and everyone else being dumbed down.

That definately makes sense, I'm just curious as to why it takes Apple so long to order and receive part(s) necessary to complete the repair. The 'on hold' status is what's becoming most irritable, beside the fact that they have yet to even attempt to repair the machine + ship it back, also what guarantees are there that the part on order will be the solution to the problem...

If ProCare takes ultimate priority then Apple clearly has lost it somewhere, I paid just as much as the next person for their Mac, why should I have to be put in the backseat because someone felt inclined to purchase more service and support above the 1-yr complimentary service.

I've always heard that the turnaround is usually pretty "fast", but apparently that only applies to service done in-store...
 

Mitthrawnuruodo

Moderator emeritus
Mar 10, 2004
14,426
1,066
Bergen, Norway
I've always had good luck with Apple shipments (phone calls are another matter), except for one time when my Pismo needed a logic board replacement (after a thunderstorm). The Pismo more or less went on tour around Europe (I suspect it was at least in Oslo (Norway), Holland and Ireland. It took a good month before I had my precious back... :(
 

ravenpen

macrumors newbie
Jul 22, 2002
11
1
I took my G5 tower into the Apple Store for hard drive trouble and they determined the drive would have to be replaced.

At the time that said they were a bit backed up and that it would take a week to complete.

I got a call from them four hours later saying that they had replaced the drive and that they had recovered and transferred all my old data free of charge, which I guess can have a fee even under warranty.

The guy on the phone said that they happened to have the new drive in stock and that he stayed after his shift was over to get it done.

Not only did I get my tower back the same day, I also avoided a nasty 500-dollar repair bill thanks to Apple Care.

I find it funny that they always point out what the repair would’ve cost without a warranty. :)

P.S. This was under regular Apple Care I don't have Pro Care.
 

Jovian9

macrumors 68000
Feb 19, 2003
1,967
110
Planet Zebes
My RevA 17" AluPB (refurbished) 1GHz 60GB 512MB had a logic board problem. Apple had it for a month waiting on the parts. When it reached a month they told me they would send me a new one.....I called them.....and they sent me an upgraded RevB 17" AluPB (new) 1.33GHz 80GB 1GB.
 

mattraehl

macrumors 6502
Feb 26, 2005
384
1
iBook HD replacement

I had to get my iBook's HD replaced, and it arrived at my doorstep within a week of taking it to the Apple store.
 

kevso

macrumors newbie
Jan 23, 2006
8
0
KD7IWP said:
3 days for my powerbook

Was this in-store?

I'm pretty confident that anybody that takes their machine, ipod, etc and has it serviced there will get it within a business week. Shipped out to the factory on the other hand...whole different story. =|
 

discoforce

macrumors 6502a
Jan 27, 2004
575
0
Vermont, USA
I've had great success with repairs completed at my local Apple Specialist (1 week or less turnaround for pb screen replacements).

Right now I'm waiting for DHL to come pick up my powerbook, so I'll report back as things progress. Do you thinking writing "PROCARE" on the box would help? :rolleyes:
 

kevso

macrumors newbie
Jan 23, 2006
8
0
discoforce said:
Right now I'm waiting for DHL to come pick up my powerbook, so I'll report back as things progress. Do you thinking writing "PROCARE" on the box would help? :rolleyes:

Heh it just might...

I opted for my PB to go back to the Apple Store, I don't trust UPS/FedEx/etc. to carefully handle something that precious. Plus, if the people at Apple decide to drop mine on the ground at any time = new PB =)
 

kevso

macrumors newbie
Jan 23, 2006
8
0
=O oh man...I love the world:

Step 3 - Return
Product shipped to Apple Store (25-Jan-2006), With delivery courier
 

discoforce

macrumors 6502a
Jan 27, 2004
575
0
Vermont, USA
Update

D'oh! Looks like I'm waiting with Vdoc:

Apple said:
The repair of your POWERBOOK G4 (15-INCH FW800), Repair ID D#######, is currently on hold, pending receipt of a needed part. We will notify you by email when the repair is complete.

Picture 3.png

The service requested on 1/16 is a bit misleading since I sent it to them on 1/24. Start your watches!
 

elbennet

macrumors member
Apr 28, 2005
30
0
I have a friend that has a bad experience with Apple's repair. She ended up having a friend that worked at an Apple store that told her that there was a list of "reasons" that the geniuses tell people when their computer is not finished. One of them was that the part was not in stock. She figured this out when she called on a Friday evening to check on the status of her iBook, and the part (a hard drive) wasn't in stock, the following weekend was July 4th weekend, and then they called early Monday morning that the computer was finished. A little sketchy......
 

discoforce

macrumors 6502a
Jan 27, 2004
575
0
Vermont, USA
Powerbook repair update

Timeline:

1/16 on phone with tech support :confused:
1/17 received box to ship to Apple :eek:
(1/17-1/24 finished projects needed laptop for)
1/24 pm sent powerbook to Apple :(
1/25 informed part on hold :mad:
1/29 "service request has been completed" :cool:
1/30 expected arrival :D

Assuming I receive it tomorrow, and it works, a 7-day turnaround time seems pretty good. Especially for having to order a part (probably logic board).
 

jsalzer

macrumors 6502a
Jan 18, 2004
607
0
Procare?

Mitthrawnuruodo said:
The Pismo more or less went on tour around Europe (I suspect it was at least in Oslo (Norway), Holland and Ireland. It took a good month before I had my precious back... :(

The love of a Pismo owner. There is nothing more beautiful! :)

Am I the only one who has never heard of "ProCare"? What the heck is that, and when did it start? Isn't AppleCare the only choice? Or do organizations get ProCare options that individuals don't?

My iMac G5 17" (which I call my "special needs computer") spent 41 days with the fine folks at CompUSA waiting for a new midplane. That was his longest trip. He's currently on trip #3 (day 9) with PMU issues.

And yet my Pismo has never left my side. ;)
 

discoforce

macrumors 6502a
Jan 27, 2004
575
0
Vermont, USA
jsalzer said:
Am I the only one who has never heard of "ProCare"? What the heck is that, and when did it start? Isn't AppleCare the only choice? Or do organizations get ProCare options that individuals don't?

Nope, you can also get Procare. Not sure how it would have helped my situation because I can't imagine a faster turn around time. Maybe they could have dropped someone off to pack my computer up for me... :rolleyes:

jsalzer said:
...my Pismo has never left my side. ;)

You know after have 4 screens and now the logic board replaced on my 15 AL powerbook, a Pismo is sounding pretty good.
 

jsalzer

macrumors 6502a
Jan 18, 2004
607
0
ProCare

discoforce said:
Nope, you can also get Procare....You know after have 4 screens and now the logic board replaced on my 15 AL powerbook, a Pismo is sounding pretty good.

I almost want ProCare just so I can have one of those cool cards in my wallet!!!

As much as I love my Pismo, you probably don't want to make that leap. Pages 2 is bringing it to a halt. I think this is the beginning of the end. :(

If only Steve would drop this "it's got to be under an inch" obsession and bring the Pismo back. But, alas, this isn't a Pismo thread. And my iMac is now on Day 10 of its third trip. (To end on topic.) ;)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.