Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Is it really that hard to figure out? I think it's a brilliant solution to a very annoying problem.

Imagine you're walking and have your iPod in your pocket. A song comes up you don't want to listen to. If you have this clip-on device attached, you can simply reach in and hit the next button--easy to find in your pocket since it's got actual buttons. This is something that is next to impossible to do with the current generation of iPods and iPhones that are primarily controlled by touch.

Now, let's see if Apple is smart enough to design this to also work as a game controller.

Ok, you know that apple made headphones that are for that exactly? I have around 4 to 5 pairs of headphones that have remotes in the cord. Just remember other devices apple has made. :)
 
what's that circle with a hole in the middle and play/pause, forward and backward arrows all around?
 
Communicator.

Attaches to your collar.

Open locked doors, speaker phone, room preference notifier and adjuster (sound control, web preferences, temperature adjustment...)

Great for notification of "your turn" in any waiting situtation.

A remote control for your entire humanity.
 
Is it really that hard to figure out? I think it's a brilliant solution to a very annoying problem.

Imagine you're walking and have your iPod in your pocket. A song comes up you don't want to listen to. If you have this clip-on device attached, you can simply reach in and hit the next button--easy to find in your pocket since it's got actual buttons. This is something that is next to impossible to do with the current generation of iPods and iPhones that are primarily controlled by touch.

Now, let's see if Apple is smart enough to design this to also work as a game controller.

There's a button on your headphones to address this very problem.
 
Is it really that hard to figure out? I think it's a brilliant solution to a very annoying problem.

Imagine you're walking and have your iPod in your pocket. A song comes up you don't want to listen to. If you have this clip-on device attached, you can simply reach in and hit the next button--easy to find in your pocket since it's got actual buttons. This is something that is next to impossible to do with the current generation of iPods and iPhones that are primarily controlled by touch.

Now, let's see if Apple is smart enough to design this to also work as a game controller.

The headphones with mic that come with it do this.
 
The headphones with mic that come with it do this.

This idea, unlike the headphone buttons, could also be used for other applications, most obviously for games. To me, the buttons on the headphones always seemed like a weird kludge to maintain that "almost no buttons" aesthetic of the iDevices. Touch-based UIs are amazing and can do so much but there's still a place in the world for actual buttons.
 
I patent matter. I win. You can't use matter in any products from now on unless you pay.

I know you're being funny but this shows a typical misunderstanding of patents that leads to people getting on their soapboxes and complaining about how broken the system is or how evil and destructive the patent office has become.

The point is, you can patent matter if you want, providing you're using it in a specific and unique way on a specific class of products for a specific application.

Good luck with it. I'm eager to see what you come up with.
 
This subject came up the day before the iPhone 4S was announced. They predicted it might be a part of the iPhone 4S way back then.
 
The market is full of ear-phones with better sound quality (better than Apple's) but no remote control. More choice for the customer, the better.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.