True. I’ve suggested in other threads (no pun intended) that Apple should just be focusing on the Thread border router portion for a “hub” device, allowing users to extend the useful life of devices they have as home control front end devices. I’m guessing it is more profitable to Apple to also push the front end display piece with it, but I’m curious to see how they differentiate it. Back end (Thread, etc.) functionality aside, to the average user it will still look like it does the same things (calendar, messages, facetime, show photos, control home devices, etc.) as their mobile devices.
Yep. That's why I think this device has legs if it's cheaper than a base iPad ( priced say midway between a HomePod mini and an iPad) and does all these basics - FaceTime, time and arms, controls, messages, music controls, podcasts, phots, weather etc - the using widgets as the interface suggests all this functionality will be there, but it makes very little sense if the price is the same or higher than a base iPad.
EDIT: Why I think price is a huge factor here isn't just the gouging, it's that, if you want to playground with HomeKit and use theApple ecosystem for smart home stuff, rather than any other system, you probably already have a bit of Apple gear lying around, and you may well already have an iPad or iPhone lying around that's relatively new but no longer your main iPhone / iPad, and it would make sense just to use the devices you already have as a HomeKit interface, rather than buy a new device.
As an example, I have a few homepod minis, these acts as hubs for the lights etc around my home, and I use a iPhone SE 2020 as the interface - the battery's pretty degraded, but it's in a case with MagSafe magnets, and lives on a MagSafe stand in my living room. I've set up the home screen with widgets, and that's used as the smart home control.
If the price of this new HomePad device, less the discount from trading in a device that runs iOS/iPadOS26. is less or roughly equal to the price of a HomePod mini or AppleTV ( and not trading in your IOS device), then it's a reasonable proposition.
If the price, with trade in, of the new HomePad, is significantly higher, then the numbers don't add up.