Originally posted by rutabaga
as usual with apple, incredible idea, flawed execution.
Question: when was the last time apple came up with an absolutley brilliant idea?
Answer: just about every product they release.
Question: when was the last time apple actually executed the release of that product in a brilliant fashion?
Answer: umm, maybe the pismo g3 powerbooks?
As usually, apple's release leaves something to be desired. Why apple didn't release a windows version alongside their mac version is beyond me. Clearly they havn't even hardly started on working on the windows version, if the job posting on monster.com is any indication. The eight months from now until the end of the year (which is the timeframe within which jobs said that service for windows would arrive) could be a critical delay.
The only reason it makes any sense to keep this exclusive to the macintosh in the short term is to try and win converts and to sell more macintosh computers. Towards that end, it would make great sense if apple could bundle the perks of their song service when you buy a new computer, i.e. give away 100 free song downloads with the purchase of any imac. but alas, I see no indication that they are going to do such a thing.
alas - unless they can bring this to windows within four months or so, this may be another wave that apple just missed riding to the promised land.