I completely disagree. HomePod is very good, simple, and intuitive *IF* you are an Apple Music subscriber. HomePod isn’t Apple’s home audio solution. It’s an Apple Music accessory. You want it to do things it was never designed or intended to do.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple Shares New Video on Getting the Most From HomePod
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I completely disagree. HomePod is very good, simple, and intuitive *IF* you are an Apple Music subscriber. HomePod isn’t Apple’s home audio solution. It’s an Apple Music accessory. You want it to do things it was never designed or intended to do.
Siri on HomePod can do ALL of the things that Apple lists on its website. Siri on HomePod can do many other things (not listed) too.
But look again at Apple's page for HomePod. The things you quote are listed at the BOTTOM of the page. The majority of the page is about the SPEAKER and its hardware. About sound quality and music playback.
Apple isn't marketing the HomePod as a "smart speaker" that sounds good. Apple is marketing it as an excellent speaker that also happens to have some smart speaker features.
The problem isn't Apple's marketing, the problem is your inability to understand exactly what Apple is marketing.
Mark
Bought one yesterday and ready to return it today. Speaker quality is ok but Siri’s intelligence and lack of smart home integration with my google calendar, SiriusXM, Logitech harmony and Nest are showstoppers whereas my 2 yr Amazon echo supports all these devices. Simply not worth it and doubt Apple will ever catch up.
"I just see the HomePod and HomeKit as overpriced, limited products, that if anyone did ten minutes of research they'd find much better value propositions."
OK... After comparing other music services a few years ago, I much prefer Apple Music and am solidly in that camp. At $8.33/mo it's a deal.
Which always-on ready for a verbal command speaker, with excellent audio quality anywhere in the room via superior technology, and with the ability to take commands at a normal speaking level no matter the environment, do you recommend as a better value proposition over HomePod? I'm certainly not tripin' over the $349 price.
Last edited:
It can't make phone calls because it doesn't have a carrier attached to it. But you can make phone calls on your iphone and pick them up using the Homepod. The sound is super clear. I tried this with my Homepod and the person on the other line said they could hear better on the Homepod than the phone itself too.
Why would Apple care about plugging in a record player to the HomePod? It’s clearly built for accommodating Apple Music subscribers and growing that business.
I have a turntable and small hi-fi setup, but I think of that as an entirely different entity, and, sadly, I’ll likely be using it less and less, since the HomePod sounds good and I can yell out anything I want to hear instantly, which is likely what Apple is hoping for. It’s rare I actually get to take the time to sit in the sweet spot of my hi-fi system and listen to records hours on end, anyways.
I’ve long said that I listen to digital music on the go and records at home, but the convenience and quality of the HomePod may push me over the edge.
You bought a product that doesn’t work with all of your non-Homekit compatible products, was never advertised or marketed to work with your non-homekit compatible products, and your disappointed? I can’t imagine why.
Yeah if you want a speaker that doesn’t sound nearly as good. which is the primary purpose of a, you know, speaker.
if i want more siri commands i’ll use any of the multiple devices i have including two that are on my person.
[doublepost=1518891819][/doublepost]
and you forgot to include that ou can turn that optional feature off.
not that i ever ask siri on my own personal devices to do this, ever. reading is better.
[doublepost=1518891896][/doublepost]
only if you have a living finish piece like oiled wood. which you don’t.
and as you know sonos does it too. oops. but but but apple!
Listen closely, the background music really resembles the old Mac vs PC music!
I hope this was intentional!
I hope this was intentional!
I asked Siri yesterday in the apple store to find me a good chicken recipe..it said "Sorry Homepod can't find this" at least it knew the answer to what is 8x4
Wrong. I am selling my dumb Sonos 5. HP is smarter, sounds better and is more versatile. Why you here just to hate on Apple? I bet you didn’t buy and have zero experience with it,
[doublepost=1518897718][/doublepost]
Why? Speaking is so easy.
I love the HomePod. It sounds amazing, Siri works great and I will buy at least two more. This video helps those that own one learn more of what they can do, which is a good thing.
[doublepost=1518898655][/doublepost]
Hahaha. Google and privacy don’t ever belong together.
[doublepost=1518898655][/doublepost]
Hahaha. Google and privacy don’t ever belong together.
Last edited by a moderator:
Says the person who has never purchased one or tried one in their home...
I'm starting to think if I really need my homepod.
the main reason I bought it is for sound and music and podcasts. However so far the most I've used it for has been for my lights which for me isn't worthy of £319
I'm very tempted to pull the trigger and buy the amazon Alexa echo for my lounge and the Alexa dot for my bedroom. That would come to £139 for two smart speakers compared to the £319 for the homepod while being a far better voice assistant which so far is all I have used it for.
The echo sound wise will be ok for my needs I reckon and now I realise the heating I use which is hive supports Alexa.
homepod is a great piece of kit but I feel the assistant is so limited that if I'm mainly using it for that then Alexa is the way to go.
tough decision and I wish I used the homepod more for it's main strengths.
the main reason I bought it is for sound and music and podcasts. However so far the most I've used it for has been for my lights which for me isn't worthy of £319
I'm very tempted to pull the trigger and buy the amazon Alexa echo for my lounge and the Alexa dot for my bedroom. That would come to £139 for two smart speakers compared to the £319 for the homepod while being a far better voice assistant which so far is all I have used it for.
The echo sound wise will be ok for my needs I reckon and now I realise the heating I use which is hive supports Alexa.
homepod is a great piece of kit but I feel the assistant is so limited that if I'm mainly using it for that then Alexa is the way to go.
tough decision and I wish I used the homepod more for it's main strengths.
Sometimes it would be nice stepping volume up and down quickly with an up/ down button.
The reason those products don’t work with Apple/HomeKit are not Apples fault. Perhaps you should ask them when they plan on supporting HomeKit. Maybe they don’t like Apples restrictions on HomeKit (like privacy and encryption). Regardless, it’s the responsibility of each manufacturer to decide if they want to support HomeKit.
Those of you that plan to take your HomePod's back to the store... Please hurry and do it so I can buy your unit as a refurbished one at a discount price!
Mark
Mark
Those of you that plan to take your HomePod's back to the store... Please hurry and do it so I can buy your unit as a refurbished one at a discount price!
Mark
It can get even better. If people start returning HPs, Apple may drop the price for new ones.
Not sure any company releases a new product and immediately releases upgrade information. For example, when I bought my Sonos Play:1, nowhere did Sonos advertise “Wait, don’t buy this yet. We're releasing a Sonos 1 with Alexa capability in 6 months.” Would have put quite the dent in their Play:1 sales I would think. Ah well, the Play:1 now belongs to daughter as I experience the HP excellence in music daily.