Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Unless you need an MBP, get an Air. In many cases the Air has similar performance and it has no fan to spin up.

I record developer training classes in a sound booth (actually a sound treated closet) professionally. With other laptops, I always had to take a break when the fan spun up. With the M1 Air there is no concern about the fan spinning up since there is no fan. I use Adobe Audition to record and the Air will record for hours on end with no issues in performance.

Be interesting to see if you'd have the same experience with the M1 MBP though as it's fan behavior is drastically different from any prior Macbook I've owned.

I would posit that if the M1 MBA is doing fine with no performance impact, then the same workload would also result in a silent M1 MBP.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Queen6
Be interesting to see if you'd have the same experience with the M1 MBP though as it's fan behavior is drastically different from any prior Macbook I've owned.

I would posit that if the M1 MBA is doing fine with no performance impact, then the same workload would also result in a silent M1 MBP.
Problem is you can't be sure. You cannot control it. It was another thing, if Apple allowed disabling the fan at the cost of a bit throttling. With the Air you are guaranteed, that Never Ever will the fan kick in, not even if a process run amok. And even if it is a workload that throttle the Air, you will hardly know it is running 75-80% performance, unless you are doing the exact same tasks on M1 MBP next to it.

That said, OP's problem might have been solved in Monterey, from what I can see people report in the MacBook Pro forum.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jerryk
Problem is you can't be sure. You cannot control it.

Sure you can. There are fan control apps such as https://crystalidea.com/macs-fan-control

Not that I've ever tried one - my M1 MBP is completely silent even in my quiet home office. Except once when I was specifically trying to make the fan audible.


And even if it is a workload that throttle the Air, you will hardly know it is running 75-80% performance, unless you are doing the exact same tasks on M1 MBP next to it.

though as mentioned if you're doing the exact same tasks and they Air isn't noticeably throttling, then there's not enuf load to make the MBP fan audible (if it even turns on).


My point is simply that the "buy an M1 MBA because Intel MBPs were noisy" ignores the fact that it's quite likely the M1 MBP will also be silent for most users workloads, and could perhaps mislead someone away from the model that best fits their needs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Queen6
Sure you can. There are fan control apps such as https://crystalidea.com/macs-fan-control
They can only increase fanspeed not decrease or turn it off.
though as mentioned if you're doing the exact same tasks and they Air isn't noticeably throttling, then there's not enuf load to make the MBP fan audible (if it even turns on).
The air never throttle noticable. It may finish long tasks a bit slower, but it stay responsive and not going into into slow motion. Speed is not a problem. The tasks that take longer is tasks that already take so long you don’t sit and wait for, but start doing something else in the meantime, so it doesn’t matter that much if it takes 20% longer
My point is simply that the "buy an M1 MBA because Intel MBPs were noisy" ignores the fact that it's quite likely the M1 MBP will also be silent for most users workloads, and could perhaps mislead someone away from the model that best fits their needs.
Maybe, but the point is maybe is not always good enough. No fan noise is a guarantee on air, even when software misbehave and eat up all cpu, which is a joy compared to my previous machines. I had it transcoding for two days straight and no problem having it in the livingroom or bedroom. The only thing that make me second guess no fan air over pro is the screen (it sounds like there might be more quality difference than purely brightness) and maybe the touch-bar, which I have never tried.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LuisN
Be interesting to see if you'd have the same experience with the M1 MBP though as it's fan behavior is drastically different from any prior Macbook I've owned.

I would posit that if the M1 MBA is doing fine with no performance impact, then the same workload would also result in a silent M1 MBP.
I suspect you are correct, but since the Air does what I need I have never felt the need to get an M1 MBP.

In the future, if my needs warrent it, I might get at a 14" Mxx system and relegate the M1 Air to permanent sound booth duty.
 
  • Like
Reactions: deeddawg and Queen6
I suspect you are correct, but since the Air does what I need I have never felt the need to get an M1 MBP.

In the future, if my needs warrent it, I might get at a 14" Mxx system and relegate the M1 Air to permanent sound booth duty.
With the M1 Air your assured silence nor a slouch by any means. The M1 Presents benefits for those that the need the likes of active cooling and sustained performance which is beneficial in hotter climates where the Air's cooling is less efficient.

TBH unless you were to be hammering the M1 SOC 100% for long periods there will be no difference in real-world performance across all the M1 Mac's. When in the field I don't explicitly control the conditions so the M1 MBP was the better option with it's active cooling, brighter display and longer battery life.

Q-6
 
  • Like
Reactions: yaboid01
Out there suggestion incoming…..

A decent microphone set up to record yourself will be a far cheaper solution than buying a whole new machine if this is the only use case you have for a new machine.
I have an EV RE20 with an Apogee Symphony desktop. I’m not using the built in mic on the laptop. Sadly the microphone is relatively close to the computer because I have to operate the software while recording.
 
Unless you need an MBP, get an Air. In many cases the Air has similar performance and it has no fan to spin up.

I record developer training classes in a sound booth (actually a sound treated closet) professionally. With other laptops, I always had to take a break when the fan spun up. With the M1 Air there is no concern about the fan spinning up since there is no fan. I use Adobe Audition to record and the Air will record for hours on end with no issues in performance.

FWIW, I always capture the demos separately from the voice-over and merge them in post. This makes it a lot easier to edit out typing or navigation errors, speed up video sections, etc. It also makes your life much easier when your boss comes to you and wants to remove or add a section. Finally, I always use a script.
I tried recording the voice over separately from the demo, but it never seemed to work out. If I need to add comments or remove them, either I’m talking really fast trying to fit dialogue in, or talking slowly and pausing. What has worked best for me is to write a script, and do the demo while talking so I can properly synchronize what I’m saying with what I’m doing. It saves a lot of editing and overdubbing.
 
I tried recording the voice over separately from the demo, but it never seemed to work out. If I need to add comments or remove them, either I’m talking really fast trying to fit dialogue in, or talking slowly and pausing. What has worked best for me is to write a script, and do the demo while talking so I can properly synchronize what I’m saying with what I’m doing. It saves a lot of editing and overdubbing.
What software are you using to integrate your video with audio? Many packages let you extend a frame (i.e. insert more the same frame) so you can lengthen the time the video shows to match your audio length at your normal talking pace. If you want you can also go the other way and add some time when capturing beyond your voiceover estimate. It is always easier to cut than to insert.

Also, look to see what the editor you are using provides in this area. I use a product called Camtasia, but there are others.

And completely agree with scripting, and rehearsing.
 
What software are you using to integrate your video with audio? Many packages let you extend a frame (i.e. insert more the same frame) so you can lengthen the time the video shows to match your audio length at your normal talking pace. If you want you can also go the other way and add some time when capturing beyond your voiceover estimate. It is always easier to cut than to insert.

Also, look to see what the editor you are using provides in this area. I use a product called Camtasia, but there are others.

And completely agree with scripting, and rehearsing.
That’s a good tip. I use either iMove or FCP. I could use freeze frame, but then the mouse would stop moving. I guess that’s not so bad, but even a better choice could be slowing down the footage to stretch out the time of that particular “scene”. Still it requires more editing and in my mind I should know the software well enough to be able to teach it without making a million mistakes, particularly if I have a script.
 
Lapel mic?
No it’s a large diaphragm dynamic broadcast microphone. It’s in the same league as the Shure SM7B (I prefer it much better than the SM7B). You see Kelsey Grammar use one in his radio program on the spin-off “Fraser”. :)
 
No it’s a large diaphragm dynamic broadcast microphone. It’s in the same league as the Shure SM7B (I prefer it much better than the SM7B). You see Kelsey Grammar use one in his radio program on the spin-off “Fraser”. :)
Sorry.

I meant it as a suggestion, not a question. :)
 
I’m thinking about the upcoming Pros, which should run hotter than the 13” due to the M1X being higher performance, if you temporarily disable the fan(s) or set a fan limit will it just throttle safely like the MacBook Air or is there an additional risk of damage? Nothing crazy like turning them off during a long render, but rather keeping the computer silent during regular tasks (for the sake of this discussion let’s assume that the fans are slightly audible during a moderate workload).
 
Last edited:
Not a bad idea, I think I used to use an app called SMC Fan Control to do something similar while gaming back in the day. Maybe by proactively cooling with the fans at a higher RPM it can keep the temperature from increasing.

I'm starting to think a laptop isn't ideal for audio recording unless I physically relocate it somewhere else in the room. I typically have it in clamshell mode (I use an 21:9 monitor) while working which probably doesn't help.

A 16" MBP in clamshell mode is probably the noisiest Mac configuration currently available. Almost any other Mac would be better for noise. An M1 MBA, an M1 MBP, an M1 iMac or even a 2020 27" Intel iMac. Since you already have a monitor, you may want to consider an M1 Mini. That has a fan but it is designed to cool a desktop Intel CPU.

Wait until tomorrow afternoon though to see if one of the new Macs suites you better.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.