As others have said, I think your TV deserves the PS3. You mentioned quality so that means Blu-ray, especially on a 60 inch TV. You also mentioned multimedia options, and off the top of my head just about the only thing the PS3 won't do that the AppleTV will do is play back DRM'd iTunes content - which would bring us back to the quality issue again anyway.
That's all before you even begin to look at features and value, which I think the PS3 blows the AppleTV away on. The PS3 is a huge, massive product for Sony, whereas by their own admission it's a "hobby" for Apple. Why should you take it seriously when the designers of the thing don't?!
PS3 all the way. It's the only bit of tech I own that I love as much as my Apple devices.
That's all before you even begin to look at features and value, which I think the PS3 blows the AppleTV away on. The PS3 is a huge, massive product for Sony, whereas by their own admission it's a "hobby" for Apple. Why should you take it seriously when the designers of the thing don't?!
PS3 all the way. It's the only bit of tech I own that I love as much as my Apple devices.