This was a S6 SB Ti. I might think about getting another watch in the fall, just in case my watch is defective.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple Watch failed to detect a significant fall!
- Thread starter jaybar
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Actually yes, several times. The trail where I run has roots and rocks and two times, I have tripped and fallen face first, breaking my fall judo style though I did wind up with a skinned knee once and a skinned knee, elbow and hand the other. Nothing on my watch.
On two other occasions it did note my fall. Once, was a legitmate slip onto my ass on ice in my steep driveway, it asked if I fell and I said 'yes' for diagnostic purposes. The other I was doing high plank shoulder taps and came down a little quickly on my watch hand and it asked me if I fell and I said "no."
All on AW6.
Honestly, I just do not think it is that accurate. Just like I occasionally get wacky HR readings (once in a hundred times) o2 readings, I think there's a reason it isn't classified as a legitimate medical device.
Last edited:
OMG I hope she is OK and has had a full recovery. A bit off-topic but what car?
Ahh, this may explain my falls. I got right up on both running falls but on the icy driveway one didn't because I was on ice.
@wilberforce. I too hope your wife had a full recovery. Also, you as the caregiver. We lose sight of the caregiver, at times.
2012 mini cooper. Yes, she is all OK now, thanks, with some more titanium bits fusing some of the vertebra. Fortunately no nerve damage. I tell her she literally now has her head screwed on right.
Great2012 mini cooper. Yes, she is all OK now, thanks, with some more titanium bits fusing some of the vertebra. Fortunately no nerve damage. I tell her she literally now has her head screwed on right.
Not just your opinion. It was rude. And it is well known that emailing Tim Cook gets you to the Executive Team who almost always responds. No one would think that Tim Cook actually reads these emails.
Damn. With the exception of the non-airbags, I will say that car design did a good job of protecting your wife. The way the engine compartment crumples in on itself it takes on a lot of the impact.
I used to drive a same-year, same-brand, same-model car. *shudder*
Back on topic, I triggered fall-detection on my S6, once - I don't remember if it was yoga, chasing a fly (swat-swat) or something else. But it wasn't a fall. But I was glad the thing worked.
Back on topic, I triggered fall-detection on my S6, once - I don't remember if it was yoga, chasing a fly (swat-swat) or something else. But it wasn't a fall. But I was glad the thing worked.
@jaybar - You never answered this question (that I could see)? Did you move after you fell? If so, well, then there's your answer as to why your AW didn't call Emergency Services. Sounds like it's only designed to do so if you're knocked unconscious or immobilized.
I had similar issues! Smacked a bug, using a hammer with the same arm your Watch is on, or clapping, while falling on my butt from slipping on ice last winter, not even a peep!
My husband has same experience. Purchased Apple Watch 6 series after he had a serious fall BECAUSE of AW fall detection function. Since the purchase & consistently wearing AW, he had 4 falls, the Watch missing 3 of them. The most recent serious fall was on concrete with some skin injuries. Apple phone support walked us through settings and remote software troubleshooting with no issues. Took to “Genius Bar” in Apple Store and the tech found a sensor problem. Sent to repair center & they are returning it with no repair “can’t duplicate the problem”. We called Apple Support again asking for replacement (still under warranty) and basically told no. Spoke to senior advisor who subsequently transferred to store Genius Bar manager, who stonewalled and hung up on us. Refused to bump up chain of command.
Let me think back. My father had a fall last week, the family was all around. This was the first time AW failed to detect it. The fall detection application does have a flaw somewhere, but I would rather have him wear it still and detect a fall more times than not, than wearing nothing at all.
Nothing is perfect. Good that only once it failed to detect your dad’s fall, and hopefully he is doing ok. Maybe if people report the real but undetected falls, Apple will improve the product. We are very distressed that apple didn’t repair or replace our Apple Watch 6 that missed 75% of my husband’s falls in the 10 months he’s had it. They stonewalled us and hung up on us. Would not bump up to more senior management.
I think the feature is really inconsistent. I recently had a fall from a bike (swerving to miss a child and hit a tree root) I was down for at least a minute because it knocked the wind out of me and the watch (ss4) did nothing. A friend of mine sets hers off at least once a week just waiving her arms around.
Funny you should say clapping at my cat triggered fall detection. That’s exactly what happened to me. Detected a fall correctly when hiking over hill in Shropshire, UK. Not sure it would have helped as no-one in the group of 20 had a mobile signal at that location.
If I fall and am unconscious and the Watch doesn’t record it as a fall that will be unfortunate.
But the likelihood is that I’ll fall and still be conscious. So, either my Watch registers or as a fall and contacts emergency services or I do it.
This is why I always wear my Watch in the shower.
New word learnt and is one that can be added to my daily lexicon, thanks!
I have a Series 8. I fell one time and it succesfully worked. But once while I was playing basketball, it was triggered as well.