Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Maybe if Apple spent less time on pushing this A.I. we don't want in our face...they could get to work!

It only took NASA 8 years to land a man on the moon and get him back home safe.

And 2% of US GDP for 8 years.

That was in a glorified washing machine with rockets strapped to it and computer less powerful then a modern calculator.

The technology invented for the Apollo program was mind-boggling for its time. A friend's company worked on the materials for the space suits. That alone required 3 materials breakthroughs.

Not all problems are a matter of computing power.

Come on Apple, after 15 years, you should have this already.

I'm not convinced it is theoretically possible to measure blood glucose values that are medically useful (as in people should take actions based on them) over the skin. There are a lot of problems out there that society hasn't been able to solve a lot of problems despite 15+ years trying. I am not sure blood glucose monitoring that isn't medically useful would be at the top of my list of such problems to solve.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tagbert
the technology just doesn't exist yet. if you can measure that on the blood, u probably would be able to measure other components as well. and that is only possible trough a blood test.

even something simpler as blood pressure still can't be measured directly. so, I don't expect something like that to come soon. maybe in the next 50 years....
 
Apple is full of useless people sorry to tell you guys. These people talk health all the time and introduce completely useless features like:

*Apple Fitness (embarrassing)
*Apple Health App
*Mindfullness App (embarrassing)
*Sensors in the Apple Watch worn primarily by young, healthy adults and teenagers

Let me give you some tips Apple, since you guys don’t have anyone smart there any longer.

Instead of your embarrassing and useless endeavors into AirPods Max, HomePod, Vision Pro, and Apple TV.

Let’s go ahead and make a true health sensor device that is just that, and nothing more. It can be worn by anyone of any age and is specifically designed for extreme comfort so it ‘disappears’ when being worn. It is worn in a tighter way than watches, has far greater surface area for more accurate sensing, has no screen, and only wireless communicates with smartphones of any brand, not just Apple. This device is for humans not Apple customers. It is for health not ecosystem locking. It is for elderly people so they can actually be tracked because we know they won’t be wearing a damn Apple Watch on their wrist. It is a largely cloth, extremely breathable device that wraps around the wrist, but much wider and with more elasticity than the Apple Watch or any of its bands. It can also be worn around the upper arm, or leg. In all cases there are different cloth band sizes that are of different size but with extreme elasticity and comfort and extremely hypoallergenic. It is not thick at all, it lays almost flush and the electronics wrap around an interior grooved portion in the elastic cloth. It can be remove and magnetically charge on any qi1 qi2 MagSafe charger or the back of iPhones and other smartphones.

It has no display as mentioned, all data is sent to the phone but there is an app for iOS, android, and Samsung designed specifically for it. It has external LEDs which can light up and flash to give notifications to the wearer which can be dismissed with a double-tap (accelerometer/gyroscope sensors). These LEDs are in a band on both sides of the electronic device itself and so they look like 2 bars of light flanking the device. These LEDs are not just for notifications, but also for safety when running at night, for a visual clue to drivers. There is a specific type shown when the battery is low, etc. these are obviously astronomically more efficient and take virtually no space or battery compared to a display.

There is also a tiny speaker but again, there are no phone calls, or anything of the sort. It is strictly for notification sounds. A very tiny Taptic Engine could also be included, but it would be limited to very specific notifications such that you could not link it to most notifications people get on their phones all day from useless apps. We don’t want it using battery unnecessarily. It would only notify for phone calls, messages in official message apps, health sensing, and alarms/timers. All of which can be silenced instantly with a double tap on the device.

I’d fire everyone on the Siri teams, hire all new AI-focused researchers and experts. One of the main things they’d be tasked with is creating a Siri AI agent that’s only job is to monitor the data from this device and can communicate to the user via notifications on the phone, and via directly talking to the user as they are wearing AirPods or in the home via HomePod minis which I would reduce in price to $30. You—as the user— can use natural language to tell this Siri when you’d like it to talk to you about this data or if you’d like it to update you at regular intervals or when it thinks is important. For example, if you were out running and you were wearing AirPods you can have this Siri agent to be cognizant when you begin running based on sensors and music playback, and every 5-10min or every mile, or whenever you choose, Siri would lower the music and update you on whatever metrics you want updated on. It could also tell you in natural language whether you should speed up to maintain or break your previous pace from the past mile or from prior runs or exercises.

Overall, I think it’s sad what Apple has become and that I can conceive of these ideas as a singular person, yet their ideas and implementation is so poor with large teams.
 
I’ll write the code for you.

Return currentUser.weight > averageAmerican || (currentUser.ethnicity == .Asian and currentUser.weight > averageAmerican)


Now iterate over that.
This always returns true if the current user’s weight is greater than the average American regardless of ethnicity.

You have an error in logic or at least redundancy by adding in the Asian check.

Return currentUser.weight > averageAmerican

Would do the same as your current code.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SAIRUS
Hauwei and Samsung already have bp monitoring Google already has the AI even eith a chatbot to ask about ur health sleep and fitness
I actually used pixel watch ai to lose 65lbs last yr in another 1-2 yrs I will have a perfect body. Like a model Google also has AI running features too
 
I think like with other things Apple watch, it just needs to be good enough.
If it can give someone a warning who otherwise would be oblivious, that's probably good enough at this point.
This should be the first goal and if it's marketed correctly they can get past the regulators. For me, this would be good enough, initially.

If the rate of change is the same as a test with blood (declining, steady, rising) the wearer would know if they need a more accurate test, go to a doctor, change of diet, etc. Since the watch is checking all of the time it's a good warning about a change.
 
This is one of the Holy Grails for the Apple Watch. Once the engineers figure this out will be absolutely huge with health benefits.

It's not particularly hyperbolic to say that engineering a non-invasive way to monitor blood glucose, have it fit in a reasonably-sized watch, have it reasonably-priced, and have it clinically accurate is akin to the Apollo program. Possibly even more challenging because this is dealing with human microbiology in real world situations.

Fairly recent summary of what's been done so far: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10331674/
Exactly. There >no< non-invasive glucose trackers in existence - those devices that claim they do it are lying. So much so that the FDA put out a warning about them in the last year. This is a Holy Grail for the whole medical device industry.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LlamaLarry
This should be the first goal and if it's marketed correctly they can get past the regulators. For me, this would be good enough, initially.

If the rate of change is the same as a test with blood (declining, steady, rising) the wearer would know if they need a more accurate test, go to a doctor, change of diet, etc. Since the watch is checking all of the time it's a good warning about a change.
Nobody’s gotten “past the regulators” because the science isn’t accurate enough.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bzgnyc2
They need to sense their customer’s blood pressure first….. they are pizzing people off.
Wrist-based blood pressure readings are currently very technique dependent - the user has to hold their arm in a specific position, and sit in a specific pose, otherwise, the readings, even on wrist sphygmomanometers in a doctor’s office, are quite inaccurate.
 
Apple is full of useless people sorry to tell you guys. These people talk health all the time and introduce completely useless features like:

*Apple Fitness (embarrassing)
*Apple Health App
*Mindfullness App (embarrassing)
*Sensors in the Apple Watch worn primarily by young, healthy adults and teenagers

Let me give you some tips Apple, since you guys don’t have anyone smart there any longer.

Instead of your embarrassing and useless endeavors into AirPods Max, HomePod, Vision Pro, and Apple TV.

Let’s go ahead and make a true health sensor device that is just that, and nothing more. It can be worn by anyone of any age and is specifically designed for extreme comfort so it ‘disappears’ when being worn. It is worn in a tighter way than watches, has far greater surface area for more accurate sensing, has no screen, and only wireless communicates with smartphones of any brand, not just Apple. This device is for humans not Apple customers. It is for health not ecosystem locking. It is for elderly people so they can actually be tracked because we know they won’t be wearing a damn Apple Watch on their wrist. It is a largely cloth, extremely breathable device that wraps around the wrist, but much wider and with more elasticity than the Apple Watch or any of its bands. It can also be worn around the upper arm, or leg. In all cases there are different cloth band sizes that are of different size but with extreme elasticity and comfort and extremely hypoallergenic. It is not thick at all, it lays almost flush and the electronics wrap around an interior grooved portion in the elastic cloth. It can be remove and magnetically charge on any qi1 qi2 MagSafe charger or the back of iPhones and other smartphones.

It has no display as mentioned, all data is sent to the phone but there is an app for iOS, android, and Samsung designed specifically for it. It has external LEDs which can light up and flash to give notifications to the wearer which can be dismissed with a double-tap (accelerometer/gyroscope sensors). These LEDs are in a band on both sides of the electronic device itself and so they look like 2 bars of light flanking the device. These LEDs are not just for notifications, but also for safety when running at night, for a visual clue to drivers. There is a specific type shown when the battery is low, etc. these are obviously astronomically more efficient and take virtually no space or battery compared to a display.

There is also a tiny speaker but again, there are no phone calls, or anything of the sort. It is strictly for notification sounds. A very tiny Taptic Engine could also be included, but it would be limited to very specific notifications such that you could not link it to most notifications people get on their phones all day from useless apps. We don’t want it using battery unnecessarily. It would only notify for phone calls, messages in official message apps, health sensing, and alarms/timers. All of which can be silenced instantly with a double tap on the device.

I’d fire everyone on the Siri teams, hire all new AI-focused researchers and experts. One of the main things they’d be tasked with is creating a Siri AI agent that’s only job is to monitor the data from this device and can communicate to the user via notifications on the phone, and via directly talking to the user as they are wearing AirPods or in the home via HomePod minis which I would reduce in price to $30. You—as the user— can use natural language to tell this Siri when you’d like it to talk to you about this data or if you’d like it to update you at regular intervals or when it thinks is important. For example, if you were out running and you were wearing AirPods you can have this Siri agent to be cognizant when you begin running based on sensors and music playback, and every 5-10min or every mile, or whenever you choose, Siri would lower the music and update you on whatever metrics you want updated on. It could also tell you in natural language whether you should speed up to maintain or break your previous pace from the past mile or from prior runs or exercises.

Overall, I think it’s sad what Apple has become and that I can conceive of these ideas as a singular person, yet their ideas and implementation is so poor with large teams.
Great ideas, but some fanboys think that Apple’s efforts are comparable to the Apollo program moon accomplishment and make excuses for marketing gimmicks.
 
This list a lot of issues, and points out that while it may be possible it may not be clinically accurate.
It just needs to be directionally accurate. I've used a Precision Xtra, Keto Mojo, Libre 2 CGM, and Dexcom G6 for various applications and strips (both glucose and ketones), and they're all a little different from each other in their absolute readings. The useful information for me was to measure the impact of different foods on my glucose and ketones. It mattered less whether the monitor showed it go from 75 to 110 or 90 to 125. Same with ketones. The Mojo was more sensitive and always read slightly higher than the Precision Xtra. Which is more accurate? Didn't really matter to me, but I could measure the depth of ketosis regardless.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rmadsen3
I may be a Murse but I do not claim to know anything about biomedical technology.

Would it be possible to do this using the sweat that accumulates under the Apple Watch?
 
As as Type 1 I use a FreeStyle Libre which is a game changer over the old finger stick method. If Apple could do this without something sticking into your skin that would be awesome. Another issue is battery life which is why the Libre expires after 14 days and gets replaced by a new one. For this to work with a watch you would need amazing battery life and super fast charging. Part of the problem for us Type 1 is "good enough" isn't - you need near medical grade, dependable, accurate results 24/7. Getting this data from just your skin has proven (so far) to be impossible.

I'm fed up with the misleading accuracy of even the best Libre 3 and Dexcom G7 sensors, and not expecting any better through optical sensors. Compression lows, spikes and dives due to change in temperature, or age of sensor (First 24 hours I've always found pretty brutal). The longer that probe is under the skin, the bigger inaccuracies will form, and I don't necessarily think it is battery each time unfortunately.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rmadsen3
This always returns true if the current user’s weight is greater than the average American regardless of ethnicity.

You have an error in logic or at least redundancy by adding in the Asian check.

Return currentUser.weight > averageAmerican

Would do the same as your current code.
Or…is my code intent revealing that the two are commonly associated?! (Yes I should of commented it)

Honestly thanks for the code review. I think my code is more manageable though since I know the client is about to ask to put in averageIndianWeight…and to prove a point that our linter isn’t working…
 
Apple will be continuing with the development. But not sure when it will come to the watch. Anyway don't think it is a feature that will be here in the next 5 years at least.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mganu
While I'm disappointed hearing this, I'd rather the feature be fully developed and working at least 95% of the time for everyone who wants or needs to use it. Keep working toward that Apple!
 
Or…is my code intent revealing that the two are commonly associated?! (Yes I should of commented it)

Honestly thanks for the code review. I think my code is more manageable though since I know the client is about to ask to put in averageIndianWeight…and to prove a point that our linter isn’t working…

More generally using absolute weight is a bad way to gauge/estimate health. Vast difference between a 200lb 5' women and a 200lb 6'4' man. BMI somewhat better but still doesn't distinguish lean muscle mass. For a simple, easy to use measurement, waist size is now preferred: waist sizes > 35" for women and > 40" for men are risk-factors. Still waist sizes don't account for ethnic/genetic differences nor general scaling of waist to height at the extremes.

Nonetheless, none of this needs an iThingy. An analog tape measure will tell you what you need to know.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SAIRUS
More generally using absolute weight is a bad way to gauge/estimate health. Vast difference between a 200lb 5' women and a 200lb 6'4' man. BMI somewhat better but still doesn't distinguish lean muscle mass. For a simple, easy to use measurement, waist size is now preferred: waist sizes > 35" for women and > 40" for men are risk-factors. Still waist sizes don't account for ethnic/genetic differences nor general scaling of waist to height at the extremes.

Nonetheless, none of this needs an iThingy. An analog tape measure will tell you what you need to know.

BMI is actually not that great I agree...soooo the iMeasure will be crafted from a single piece of aluminum, etched with a space grade laser, and will be compatible with all iDevices and should not be used for the measuring of genitalia...because only the iMeasure Pro can do that.

The iMeasure Pro is made from flexible OLED, but we here at Apple didn't want to use any flexible OLED, so we went hard...and really needed to measure up and set a new bar...

...introducing Dynamic Ink Circular Kinetics...

...because only with D.I.C.K. you can truly measure up...

...oh we already made commercials and sent them out...hmmm.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.