Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
You do realize that the geiger counter modification is to throw you off from its real purpose.
Most likely with the large hard drive it was a recording device for the CIA given as gifts to visiting foreign delegates and internal covert operations.

Wouldn't we have been more thrown off if he just didn't release the story at all?
 
  • Like
Reactions: JosephAW and bennyf
‘We don’t work with government to build secret backdoors into our products’

They didnt build anything into our products. They built something into their products. That they used. Where in the article does it say anything about doing anything to any product sold to normal people?
 
I'm kind of surprised this guy wasn't bound for life to secrecy on this topic. Or at least for another 10-20 years. There are many high-security areas that do allow non-network iPods without cameras where they wouldn't allow most any other device. I could see these devices still being in use to detect radiation during informal visits to installations where a formal investigation wasn't agreed to yet.

At least until today.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jybrick
Secret iPod = iPhone

So Huawei is banned in the USA because it works with the Chinese military...
Could Apple be banned in China for working with the US military?

To be honest this news along with banning Epic developers for adding in their own payment method (even though they allow Amazon to have their own payment method in their app ) has made Apple lose all credibility in privacy and being developer / consumer friendly company.

But amazon also offers a channel for sales of apple equipment. Epic doesn't provide apple a way to earn money in another segment except through their app.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macbug
Did this man show the agents how to use Apple's iGadgets?
2dcf12dae93a1ef82e7e2c2249fd8f7f--desmond-llewelyn-not-enough.jpg
 
  • Haha
Reactions: BaltimoreMediaBlog
When Edward Snowden leaked the NSA classified documents, one of them identified Apple as one of the companies that the government has a secret access door to. Of course Apple and I think that Tim Cook itself denied such possibility. And I always think that both possibilities can be true. Apple may think that there's not secret door, but it's really easy for the government to approach 3 or 4 key Apple engineers, extort them or just pay them, and have ears and eyes into the Apple user data. This article suggest that such thing can be done without leaving any trace inside the targeted company.

It’s also possible for another option to be true: the government had a secret way to access Apple’s security keys, and Apple is aware of this, but instead of trying to fight a never ending game of cat and mouse, they started engineering their systems and products so that not even they have the keys and the only way to access something is either by obtaining passwords from a device’s owner, or through tedious brute force.

This is, probably, the most likely “best case” scenario from a privacy standpoint.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macbug
We actually developed an iPod to do just this in the mid '00s and offered it to law enforcement. Plug it in and it'd acquire all kinds of information from the connected device. A USB drive based version was much more popular though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macbug
As a TS SCI clearance holder, this is a sad leak that damages national security. Regarding the story itself, there's a distinction for me between helping our country with an extremely narrow, clandestine project vs. compromising hundreds of millions of users's privacy by giving law enforcement backdoors into iPhones. So I don't blame Apple for participating in this, but I wish I wasn't seeing this story.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macbug and jybrick
Secret iPod = iPhone

So Huawei is banned in the USA because it works with the Chinese military...
Could Apple be banned in China for working with the US military?

To be honest this news along with banning Epic developers for adding in their own payment method (even though they allow Amazon to have their own payment method in their app ) has made Apple lose all credibility in privacy and being developer / consumer friendly company.

thats only thing they could say... real thing is that huawei is banned for other reasons, such as low price etc...
 
$23B yearly for nuclear weapons...my god...

When Edward Snowden leaked the NSA classified documents, one of them identified Apple as one of the companies that the government has a secret access door to. Of course Apple and I think that Tim Cook itself denied such possibility. And I always think that both possibilities can be true. Apple may think that there's not secret door, but it's really easy for the government to approach 3 or 4 key Apple engineers, extort them or just pay them, and have ears and eyes into the Apple user data. This article suggest that such thing can be done without leaving any trace inside the targeted company.

Lets assume the software has a backdoor, can security researchers discover it?
I imagine if your device is locked with a password, there might be a single 22 character passwords that can unlock any device out there, like a skeleton key of some sort. How can you discover that?
 
Wow, you do know that you’re not suppose to advertise your security clearance like this don’t you? It makes you a potential target. You should go back and read your security manual. Pathetic.

As a TS SCI clearance holder, this is a sad leak that damages national security. Regarding the story itself, there's a distinction for me between helping our country with an extremely narrow, clandestine project vs. compromising hundreds of millions of users's privacy by giving law enforcement backdoors into iPhones. So I don't blame Apple for participating in this, but I wish I wasn't seeing this story.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macbug
Now, what if those guys weren't from the US Govt but instead were CCP agents wanting help to make items to give to US employees. Now what?
 
SpyPod...

I'm still wondering why there are no government edition iPhones... I mean MDM does quite a good job in combination with the base security of the OS which is quite high, but I could imagine certain customers in the intelligence gather sector need "custom" features that can only be embedded low level in the device.
I’ve seen a modified iPhone 4/4s that had no camera. The back glass was just solid black. Everyone at that facility had one.

Not sure what they did about the front camera tho.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macbug
As a TS SCI clearance holder, this is a sad leak that damages national security.

You don't know if this project was actually classified. It's doubtful because if it was everyone involved would have to have clearance, including the Apple guys, and they'd understand what that meant.

Since nothing was written down they can talk about it. It's just some random thing that may or may not have happened.
 
My guess it was a iPod to catch Chinese agents that were stealing secrets at the time from are programs. You swap out their iPod for your iPod it goes back to China and unleashes a tracking or virus package or reports back to the NSA that this person is stealing top secret information. Thanks china party for stealing are secrets and using it against us, oh and thanks for the human viruses also.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DanTSX
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.